- Статьи
- World
- Dialogue is a delicate matter: the United States supported Europe's participation in the negotiations on Ukraine
Dialogue is a delicate matter: the United States supported Europe's participation in the negotiations on Ukraine
European leaders are preparing for possible quadrilateral talks on Ukraine — they intend to join the format with the participation of Moscow, Washington and Kiev. However, Russia has not yet agreed on such a format and invited the Europeans to come to Russia first to explain their position. At the same time, the European press notes that the political influence of the leaders of France, Germany and the United Kingdom is weakening. Instead, Finnish President Alexander Stubb, who has already spoken with Vladimir Putin, is calling for a more active direct dialogue with Russia. Helsinki is beginning to realize the need for cooperation with Moscow, the Russian embassy told Izvestia.
The "coalition of the willing" is getting weaker
Following the meeting of the coalition of the Willing in Berlin on November 19, Vladimir Zelensky announced the preparation of quadrilateral talks between Ukraine, Russia, the United States and Europe. According to him, Washington supported the involvement of Europeans in the peace process. They should be represented by five countries, as well as the structures of the EU and NATO.
The meeting in the German capital was organized by the leaders of Germany, France and the United Kingdom. It was attended by representatives of almost 40 countries, the leaders of the EU and NATO, as well as American envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner. The European leaders, for their part, confirmed their readiness to participate in the settlement.
Witkoff and Kushner held a separate meeting with Merz and his national security adviser Gunther Zautter. The Americans spoke about the results of Donald Trump's meeting with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping in China. Trump himself also joined the discussions in Berlin by phone. According to Kushner, Washington continues to coordinate with the Europeans the terms of a future settlement, including guarantees of Ukraine's security.
However, Moscow has already indicated its position on the participation of Europeans in the negotiations. On November 19, Vladimir Putin announced that the United States was insistently proposing to expand their format. Russia does not object to discussing European security with the participation of EU countries, but first it intends to find out their position.
— We need to understand what Europe will come to these negotiations with. That is why, through diplomatic channels, we have invited the Europeans to come to Moscow in order to determine their position," the president noted.
Currently, there is no single approach to contacts with Moscow among European countries. Germany insists on preserving NATO as the foundation of European security, while France insists on guarantees to Kiev, including the possible deployment of troops after the truce. The head of the European Diplomacy, Kaya Kallas, demands a cease-fire first, and the European Commission advocates increased sanctions pressure on Russia.
Despite the differences, the European leaders were able to agree on the composition of the negotiating group on November 13. It included representatives from France, Germany, Great Britain, Italy, Poland, as well as the European Commission and the European Council.
Moreover, the leaders of the "coalition of the willing" themselves, who are preparing to send their representatives to negotiations, have serious problems within the countries. According to Politico, citing four European government officials, the political influence of the leaders of France, Germany and the United Kingdom has noticeably weakened. They are forced to switch to the domestic agenda in their countries, and some diplomats fear that as a result, the coalition is losing its previous activity and may stay away from the agreements between Moscow and Washington.
The European Parliament also doubts the EU's ability to mediate in the negotiations. As MEP Thomas Geisel told Izvestia, Brussels almost unconditionally supports Kiev's position and does not offer its own options for ending the conflict.
— First, both sides need to take confidence-building measures and agree on non-violence and disarmament. In the long term, a system of collective security with Russia's participation should be created on this basis," the MEP told Izvestia.
The participation of Europeans in the negotiations largely depends on the position of the United States, said Evgeny Semibratov, deputy director of the Institute for Strategic Studies and Forecasts at the Rudn University. In his opinion, Washington will have to exert political pressure on the allies so that they do not interfere with the settlement. At the same time, in Europe, some political forces advocate ending the conflict and restoring relations with Russia, while others advocate continuing the confrontation. Much will depend on Steve Witkoff's diplomatic efforts, the expert believes.
Which European leader is ready to talk to Moscow
Finnish President Alexander Stubb has become one of the active supporters of direct dialogue with Russia. He maintains close relations with Donald Trump and urges the Europeans to negotiate with Moscow on their own. In an interview with the Financial Times on November 17, Stubb said that Europe had relied on US mediation for too long, and it would not be possible to reach a peace agreement without Putin's consent.
The Finnish leader also proposed six topics for negotiations: guarantees of Ukraine's security, territorial issues, reconstruction of the country, confidence-building measures, a cease-fire and the future system of European security.
However, despite Stubb's increasing calls for negotiations, there have been no proposals for a full-fledged restoration of political relations with the Russian Federation.
— Helsinki has not yet announced specific proposals for the resumption of a full-scale interstate dialogue. At the same time, the rhetoric of the Finnish political leadership shows that they are beginning to realize the need to build cooperation with our country," the Russian Embassy in Finland told Izvestia.
At the same time, diplomatic relations between Moscow and Helsinki were not completely interrupted. According to the embassy, contacts between the Ministries of Foreign Affairs, diplomatic missions and relevant departments are maintained, and current bilateral issues are being resolved at the working level.
On October 27, Alexander Stubb, together with Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Harrer, had a telephone conversation with Vladimir Putin. The initiative came from Helsinki and Oslo, and the conversation was coordinated with Kiev and lasted about an hour and a half. After that, the Northern European leaders also contacted Vladimir Zelensky.
However, calls for dialogue are still just calls. On November 12, the Finnish authorities tightened restrictions on the entry of Russians, extending them to professional athletes, including those competing in a neutral status. The new rules became effective on November 16. Because of them, seven Russian figure skaters will not be able to compete at the Grand Prix in Helsinki.
On November 19, Putin drew attention to the contradiction between Stubb's statements about the need for negotiations and the subsequent decisions of the Finnish authorities.
"This is a movement in the opposite direction, this is inconsistency, and this reduces the level of trust,— the Russian president stressed.
The change in the rhetoric of Stubb and Stere indicates a revision of previous approaches to relations with Russia, Semibratov believes. At the same time, one should not expect other Nordic countries to follow the example of the two leaders. New initiatives to restore contacts with Moscow are likely to appear in Italy and some Central European states.
Now the Europeans will have to work out a common position on the negotiations. It will not be easy to do this: disagreements persist even between the leaders of France, Germany and the United Kingdom. If the EU fails to offer Moscow conditions for dialogue without ultimatums, which Russia has repeatedly warned against, its participation in further settlement will remain questionable.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»