Insurance cover: fraudsters arrange accidents and arson for the sake of payments
In 2026, the number of property insurance fraud cases increased by 10% compared to 2025. Thus, signs of deception are detected in 20-25% of claims about fires in the private sector. Malefactors buy dilapidated or unfinished houses, issue overpriced policies for them, and then fake a short circuit or set a fire in order to receive payment. Fraud is also carried out with CASCO and CTP. About the schemes of criminals and ways to protect themselves — in the material of Izvestia.
How to cheat with real estate
In Russia, there has been a steady increase in property insurance fraud: over the past five years, the number of detected violations has increased significantly, and in 2026, the figure increased by another 10% year-on-year, according to the insurance company "Consent". The main impact falls on the residential sector: according to company analysts, up to a quarter of all claims about fires in private homes contain signs of deception. A typical scheme remains the purchase of dilapidated buildings or abandoned unfinished buildings, followed by the registration of a policy at a much higher cost in order to receive a large payment after a planned fire.
"Scammers simulate a short circuit or set fire to real estate on their own in order to receive a payout. So they don't just cash in on insurance companies, they put the lives and property of others on the line. In the private sector, houses are densely packed, and one such case can destroy several buildings," the company said.
The most common scheme is deliberate arson, Artyom Iskra, Managing director of Renaissance Insurance, confirmed.
— Fraudsters increase the insurance amount tenfold. For example, they redecorate an old village house, and then set it on fire. The statements include property that was not at the scene of the incident, and indicate an inflated value of the lost items. They often try to issue a policy for apartments that have already been affected by the gulf," the expert noted.
Another popular scheme is "Potemkin cottages". New houses are being built specifically for the registration of a policy for an amount many times higher than the actual cost of buildings, and then they are set on fire for the sake of payment.
Rosgosstrakh reported two prevented fraud attempts for more than 11 million rubles. For example, in the Kursk region, Sergey K., a former expert contractor, bought a cheap panel house in a village and, through friends, insured it at a much higher price. Then he set fire to the fire, writing off everything to the old wiring, and forged an act of inspection of the ashes in order to receive almost 5 million rubles. The security service uncovered the deception, a criminal case was opened against the man, and the court found him guilty.
"The second case occurred in the Tyumen region," the company said. — A local resident, Nikolai S., tried to get about 6.3 million rubles for burnt-out buildings on his property. The man knew that the land was under the program of integrated development of territories, and the buildings would be demolished anyway, so he staged a fire. The insurers contacted the developer, found out the real situation and exposed the client. Realizing that he was facing a criminal sentence for fraud, the Tyumen resident himself refused all payments and claims."
Maxim Baimov, Head of the Loss Settlement Department of Accident Insurance, Property and Mortgage insurance at AlfaStrakhovanie, gave an example of abuse in title defense. A man who was going through bankruptcy proceedings gave his apartment to a relative to hide it from foreclosure, and he sold the apartment to a client of the company. The payment for this transaction was refused.
How auto-repair works
Insurance fraud affects all areas, but most of these stories are related to cars, told Izvestia in "Consent". Moreover, the situation is different in each region of Russia. So, this year the top 3 cities with the highest number of confirmed episodes included Moscow, Krasnodar and Novosibirsk. In 2025, Krasnoyarsk and Smolensk were in second and third places. The reason is that criminal groups do not sit still — they migrate to places where payments are higher and control is weaker.
"In the first nine months of 2026, fraudulent schemes were detected in applications for almost 1.3 billion rubles — payments on them did not take place. Criminal cases have been initiated on 46 episodes, and the damage amounted to 235 million rubles," the company said.
The most common scheme is to provoke an accident by prior arrangement. The culprit is usually the owner of a domestic car — GAZ, VAZ, or a truck like ZIL or KAMAZ, which are more than ten years old. The victim is the driver of an expensive car, for example, a Mercedes, BMW, Porsche, or a foreign car with a right—hand drive, which has a higher repair cost and, consequently, a higher payout.
To get money for CTP, they arrange staging at roundabouts. One of the most popular schemes is the "steam train", when scammers accelerate the car and brake sharply, and the driver from behind does not have time to react and crashes. It is not uncommon for several cars following each other to be involved in such an accident. Since all these are not imitations, but real accidents, other road users, including pedestrians, may also be affected.
Alexander Akimov, head of the Information Technology Department of the RESO-Garantia Security Department, noted that the fraud scheme stands out, in which a car specially insured for an inflated amount is intentionally damaged.
"For this purpose, premium class vehicles are imported from Europe, China or through the EAEU countries," he explained. — When checking at the stage of reviewing losses, it is established that the costs of purchasing, customs clearance and importation of such turnkey cars into the Russian Federation are one and a half to two times lower than the amount of insurance coverage requested by fraudsters under the casco agreement. After the policy is issued, the attackers fake an insured event, that is, they intentionally damage the car and claim a loss in order to enrich themselves at the expense of the insurer.
According to Artyom Iskra, attempts to issue a hard hat policy at a price several times higher than the actual cost of a car, and then stage an accident with the complete death of the car, have also become more frequent. Usually we are talking about foreign cars worth from 5 million rubles imported through neighboring countries using customs privileges.
"The car is registered to a nominal owner who is entitled to a benefit, then an inflated amount is indicated in a fictitious purchase and sale agreement, the car is insured under a hard hat and a total accident is organized," the expert added. — The scheme has existed for a long time, but it began to be used more often after a sharp rise in the price of foreign cars and the expansion of the range of costs at which cars are ready to accept insurance. The same model can be valued at 2 million and 5 million rubles.
How to protect yourself from intruders
Car insurance fraud has long turned into a well-established industry, says Maria Susskaya, a lawyer and head of the St. Petersburg branch of Sokolov, Trusov and Partners Law Firm in Moscow.
"Suspicious circumstances include ideal conditions for staging — for example, if the accident occurred at night, on an empty suburban highway far from populated areas and surveillance cameras," explained Maria Suska. — Another striking marker is the apparent imbalance of cars and damage. The culprit usually has an old domestic car with minimal damage, while the "victim" has an expensive foreign car with serious defects that make it possible to claim the maximum payout.
If the insurer has doubts, the tracological examination plays a key role: specialists check whether the claimed damage can occur under the circumstances described by the participants. The expert highlights the constant exchange of data between insurance companies and the prompt transfer of collected materials to law enforcement agencies to initiate cases under Article 159.5 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation as systemic protection measures.
In order not to accidentally become a victim of such scams, experts advise to be extremely vigilant while driving, especially at difficult intersections, roundabouts and narrow streets of the private sector with closed turns, where intruders most often provoke accidents.
"The main argument of your innocence will always be the DVR, especially the one recording both in front and behind the car," the experts emphasize. — If a collision does occur, do not accept the offer to "sort it out on the spot" and immediately call the hotline of your insurance company. Be sure to capture the panorama of the incident, damage, numbers and faces of the participants on your smartphone camera yourself, save the records from the registrar and do not leave empty columns in the accident notification before signing. If there are any signs of a planned provocation, immediately call the traffic police squad and inform the insurer about the suspicion of staging."
In real estate matters, fraudsters often use arson, so when choosing a country house or plot, it is better to avoid the neighborhood of dilapidated houses and abandoned unfinished buildings.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»