- Статьи
- Auto
- The policy is on fire: the Supreme Court ordered the insurer to pay compensation for the burnt-out car
The policy is on fire: the Supreme Court ordered the insurer to pay compensation for the burnt-out car
The insurance company under the casco policy is obliged to compensate for the damage caused to the car by the actions of third parties, even if the refusal of such payment is stipulated in the contract. The corresponding decision was made by the Supreme Court, recognizing such restrictions as null and void. The details are in the Izvestia article.
Burn, burn clearly
In December 2022, in St. Petersburg, as a result of arson, an SUV belonging to citizen Yezhova (surname changed. — Izvestia). Since the car was insured under a hard hat for 3.3 million rubles, Yezhov applied for compensation from the insurance company. However, the insurer refused to pay her, referring to the clause of the contract according to which, if the amount of damage caused by illegal actions of third parties exceeds 65% of the cost of repairing the car, then such an event is not recognized as an insured event.
The car owner appealed to the Kalininsky District Court of St. Petersburg, but there, also referring to the relevant clause of the insurance contract, sided with the insurer. Yezhova challenged the decision in the St. Petersburg City Court, and then in the Third Court of Cassation of General Jurisdiction, but she failed to defend her point of view in these instances. As a result, Yezhova filed a complaint with the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation (SC RF).
An insignificant point
After reviewing the case materials, the Judicial Board for Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation concluded that the lower authorities had committed significant violations of substantive and procedural law, which affected the outcome of the case. Recognizing the principle of freedom of contract enshrined in law, the judges of the Supreme Court noted that the clause setting limits on the amount of payment contradicts a number of articles of the Civil Code, as well as the law "On the Organization of Insurance Business in the Russian Federation." The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation emphasized that the terms of the contract are determined at the discretion of the parties, except in cases where the content of the relevant condition is prescribed by law or other legal acts.
"The norms of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation contain an imperative indication that the insurer's exemption from the obligation to pay insurance indemnity is possible only if it is expressly provided for by law. Reservations [specified in the contract. — Ed.], exempting the insurer from paying insurance compensation in the event of damage caused by illegal actions of third parties, in which the cost of car repairs exceeds 65% of the insured amount, are negligible," the Supreme Court ruling says.
The Judicial Board also noted that the insurance company, being a professional market participant, acts as an economically stronger party to these legal relations. By including such clauses in contracts, the insurer "actually minimizes its business risk associated with the payment of insurance compensation."
As a result, the Supreme Court overturned the decisions of the lower courts and sent the case for a new hearing.
With fines and penalties
The Supreme Court explicitly pointed out to the lower courts the mistakes they had made, according to Sergei Radko, a lawyer for the Freedom of Choice movement. Therefore, upon reconsideration of the case, the court will recognize the specified clause of the insurance contract as null and void and oblige the insurer to compensate for the damage, he is convinced.
— The district, as well as the city and cassation courts reacted quite formally to the consideration of the case and based their decisions only on the terms of the contract itself, without correlating them with the requirements of the legislation. Having recognized the clause stipulated in the contract as null and void, the Supreme Court made a fair and balanced decision," the lawyer believes.
Sergey Smirnov, an auto lawyer, agrees with him. In his opinion, the clause of the contract allowing the insurer not to recognize the insured event if the damage exceeds a certain percentage of the total amount of insurance compensation contradicts the very principle of insurance.
— It turns out that the value of the property specified in the contract is 3.3 million rubles, but if the damage is more than 65% of this amount (2.145 million rubles. — Izvestia), then the motorist will not receive a penny from the insurer. Obviously, these are bonded conditions that do not meet the very essence of property damage or death insurance. Therefore, it is quite logical that the Supreme Court declared this clause of the contract null and void," the lawyer said.
Sergey Smirnov stressed that the conditions under which an insurance company is exempt from paying compensation are clearly specified in the legislation. This is primarily the intention of the policyholder himself or his gross negligence, which caused damage or loss of insured property, he stressed. There was neither one nor the other in Yezhova's actions: in the framework of the criminal case initiated on the fact of arson, it was established that it was committed by a third party, the lawyer pointed out.
Since the insurance company did not pay compensation on time, along with full compensation for the losses caused, the motorist also has the right to expect to receive a penalty from the insurer (its amount cannot exceed the amount of the claim), the human rights activist notes. In addition, the court may fine the defendant for non—fulfillment of the terms of the contract - this money will also be sent to the plaintiff, he emphasizes. In total, according to Sergey Smirnov's calculations, the motorist can expect to receive about 9 million rubles from the insurance company.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»