Control work: how Stalin became the main producer and censor of Soviet culture
In November 1947, the premiere of the opera "The Great Friendship" by Vano Muradeli took place at the Bolshoi Theater. She was subjected to devastating criticism, and this marked the beginning of a new round of struggle against formalism in Soviet art. Under Stalin, culture was both a personal interest of the leader and a powerful tool of state propaganda. This theme is reflected in Vladimir Bortko's new six-part film "Stalin," which will premiere on December 6 on REN TV. Why Shostakovich was blamed for "confusion instead of music," how the leader's reaction to "Ivan the Terrible" determined Eisenstein's fate, and what in the works of Akhmatova and Zoshchenko did not coincide with Kremlin policy — in the Izvestia material.
"Stalin's attitude to art was specific"
It's night outside. Stalin and his closest associates, including Beria and Malenkov, are sitting in a private cinema room. On the screen is the second part of Sergei Eisenstein's film "Ivan the Terrible". The viewer has not yet seen this picture, and the first, most important, review will determine the fate of not only the tape, but also its creator.
"This is not a movie. This is some kind of nightmare. The Oprichnina is shown completely incorrectly. The Oprichniks look like some kind of Ku Klux Klan!" the leader pronounces the verdict.
This is one of the scenes of the new historical drama "Stalin" directed by Vladimir Bortko, who is well known to the audience for "The Heart of a Dog", "The Master and Margarita", "Taras Bulba" and "Bandit Petersburg". The episode becomes a small but important detail of the narrative — a thread to understanding the motives of the leader of the USSR through his special relationship with the culture of that time.
This story is based on a real foundation. Stalin did not just control the cinema, but directly participated in the formation of the Soviet poster. At his request, a whole gallery of historical characters appeared on the screen: "Peter the Great" and "Kutuzov" by Petrov, "Admiral Nakhimov" by Pudovkin, "Alexander Nevsky" by the same Eisenstein.
It was at the insistence of the country's leadership that the latter took up the story about Ivan the Terrible. There were no problems with the first film: the image of the great emperor worked as an ideological portrait. In 1946, the director was even awarded the Stalin Prize of the first degree. But continuing from the heroic image of the collector of lands, Eisenstein came to depict the tragedy of power and the destructive underside of autocracy, which the viewers at the top did not appreciate.
In February 1947, Nikolai Cherkasov, the director and performer of the main role, was invited to the Kremlin. The recording of this meeting, made by Cherkasov in hot pursuit, preserved a detailed list of Stalin's claims to the new tape. In particular, according to the leader, the tsar was painted as indecisive and similar to Hamlet.
Today, what is striking about this story is not so much the conflict between the ruler and the artist, but rather the attention that Stalin paid to cinema, sparing no time for a detailed discussion of a particular work.
— Stalin had a specific attitude to art. He viewed it mostly utilitarianly. From his point of view, art had to serve a specific state purpose. At the same time, of course, there were also artistic requirements, that is, it was assumed that the directors, actors, and artists had some talents, so that it would still attract due to its undoubted cultural and creative value. But there had to be an ideological state super-task embedded in all genres of art, in all creative works. He dealt with it especially harshly. He did not assume any kind of free search and got rid of those who were excessively independent in these searches," explained Sergey Stankevich, a historian and former adviser to the President of the Russian Federation on political issues (1991-1993).
For Eisenstein, this story ended tragically. He was grieving over the fate of his brainchild and, despite the formal promises made to the leader, he was not going to redo it, preferring to literally drive himself to death with another job: the genius's life was interrupted due to a heart attack in 1948, when he was only 50 years old. The viewer saw the second episode of Ivan the Terrible many years after Stalin's death.
At the same time, being well aware of the role of cinema, Stalin supported the development of Soviet musical comedy in the difficult 1930s. One of the first striking examples was the "Funny Guys" by Grigory Alexandrov, Eisenstein's former assistant. After watching the tape, made according to the patterns of Hollywood musicals, but with our national flavor, the leader said that he felt like he had been on vacation. But in addition to personal sympathies, he probably took into account the "therapeutic" effect that a playful, carefree picture would have on Soviet citizens who needed positive emotions so much.
It was this film that made Lyubov Orlova a star. This was followed by Circus and Volga-Volga, which were a huge success. The leader's calculation turned out to be correct.
How Stalin became a producer of Soviet art
In essence, Stalin assumed the role of the main producer of Soviet art, repeatedly intervening in the development of music, theater, literature and personally participating in the fate of many cultural figures, both positively, awarding them prizes and solving problems, and negatively. For example, the struggle against formalism dealt a severe blow to Soviet composers.
— A kind of symbol of the struggle against formalism in music has become a campaign launched by an article in Pravda entitled "Confusion instead of music." Her target was Shostakovich's opera Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District. Soon, Shostakovich's ballets received the same sweeping censure, to which the article "Ballet Falsity" was devoted. These events were the beginning of a full—scale campaign, which, weakening and intensifying, in fact, never stopped in Soviet culture," Marina Raku, Doctor of Art History and a leading researcher at the State Institute of Art Studies, said in an interview with Izvestia.

The 1948 decree on the opera The Great Friendship continued, and Vano Muradeli's composition turned out to be just the reason for a new blow to a number of great musicians, primarily Shostakovich and Prokofiev. This marked the beginning of a new round of administrative condemnation of "wrong" creativity in the USSR.
— The idea of the importance of art for building a new society and a new person was inherited by Soviet culture from the Romanticism of the 19th century and was perceived through the ideas of the Silver Age lifestyle. Music was perceived as one of the most important tools of this all-encompassing work. It is impossible to imagine the importance of music for society today. Stalin was brought up aware of the special status of musical art and transferred these ideas to Soviet ideological work,— Marina Raku said.
Stalin's relationship with literature was no less controversial. Writers and poets had a huge influence on public consciousness, which means that the state sought to control not only the content of their works, but also the very possibility of their publication. In 1946, Mikhail Zoshchenko and Anna Akhmatova were attacked. The resolution of the Central Committee on the magazines Zvezda and Leningrad effectively deprived them of the opportunity to work and publish normally. An episode referring to these events is also featured in Bortko's TV series Stalin.
"Let the writers Akhmatova and Zoshchenko write, but why would the Soviet state publish their works, their personal experiences that have nothing to do with the tasks of the country or the aspirations of the people?" asks the leader performed by Igor Mirkurbanov.
And in this phrase, the director's idea of the new film is revealed. This is not just an appeal to the era — from the victorious year of 1945 to Stalin's death in 1953, but an artistic study of the personality and role of the leader and the motives that determine his decisions and the future of a large country that, after a difficult war, has to rebuild the economy, establish a peaceful life, and resist the West against the background of increasing tension and the race to create a nuclear weapons.
— It had metaphysics, a mystical plan of a certain kind. I assume that such people don't end up there by chance. The role of personality in history is always associated with some kind of higher leadership, the highest principle," Igor Mirkurbanov shared his opinion with Izvestia. — And if you look a little further, then there was a question of survival — first in the war, and then against the background of the creation of a nuclear bomb. It seems to me that there are moments in the history of the country when all efforts should be directed towards a common goal.
There is a brilliant casting on the screen: Viktor Sukhorukov as Nikita Khrushchev, Alexander Yatsko (Lavrentiy Beria), Alexander Samoylenko (Georgy Malenkov), Kristina Babushkina (Stalin's housekeeper Varvara Istomina), Julia Rutberg (the future fourth Prime Minister of Israel, Golda Meir).
This is Vladimir Bortko's first major work in the last decade. The director collected the story from archival documents, Politburo transcripts and memoirs. On December 6, the six-episode drama "Stalin" about a man who had no power beyond even art, will be released on REN TV.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»