- Статьи
- Auto
- Mom doesn't drive: the Russian Armed Forces allowed the confiscation of cars from relatives of violators
Mom doesn't drive: the Russian Armed Forces allowed the confiscation of cars from relatives of violators
For traffic violations, you can confiscate a car, even if it does not belong to the violator himself, but is registered to another person. This decision was made by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation (SC RF). The decision to seize the vehicle should be made after examining all the circumstances of the case, and not only on the basis of information about its owner, the judges noted. Lawyers and experts ambiguously assess the decision of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
The Procurator's office is against
In October last year, the Yakutsk City Court recognized citizen Myshkina (surname changed. — Izvestia) guilty under Part 1 of Article 264.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. The court found that she, having been deprived of her driver's license for refusing to undergo a medical examination, was again detained by traffic police officers for driving under the influence. She was sentenced to 200 hours of compulsory labor. At the same time, according to the court's decision, the vehicle in which the violation was committed and which acted as material evidence was not confiscated, since it was owned by the convict's mother.
The verdict was upheld by an appeal decision of the Judicial Board for Criminal Cases of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) and a cassation decision of the Judicial Board for Criminal Cases of the Ninth Cassation Court of General Jurisdiction.
The Prosecutor General's Office opposed these decisions. The deputy head of the supervisory authority sent a submission to the Supreme Court, in which he asked to recognize the verdict as illegal, pointing out that, despite the fact that, according to the vehicle registration card, the convicted pensioner mother is listed as the owner of the car, Myshkina herself actually owns the car, which was prosecuted six times between 2020 and 2024 for traffic violations committed by her on this vehicle. In addition, her mother, according to the FIS of the traffic police, never received a driver's license, did not apply for a CTP policy. During the interrogation, she herself pointed out that she was the nominal owner of the vehicle and did not know where it was located.
With this in mind, the Deputy Prosecutor General asked the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation to reverse the decisions of lower authorities regarding the non-use of car confiscation.
Stand up, the trial is coming!
After reviewing the case materials, the Judicial Board for Criminal Cases of the Supreme Court concluded that the lower instances violated the rules for evaluating the totality of evidence. The Supreme Court noted that, according to the explanations of the Plenum of the Supreme Court, "in cases where the information provided by the accused about the alienation of the vehicle is refuted by the examined case materials and the court finds that the vehicle continues to belong to the accused, it is also subject to confiscation." However, these clarifications were also not taken into account. In addition, during the trial, the defendant herself explained that the car belongs to her mother, but she actually uses it.
"The court drew the appropriate conclusions based only on the vehicle registration data, without taking into account the testimony of a witness, information about administrative offenses in the field of traffic, indicating that Myshkina was using the car, as well as the testimony of the defendant, who did not deny this fact," the ruling of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation says.
From the totality of the examined evidence, the court should have concluded who actually owns the car that was used by Myshkina during the commission of the crime, the Supreme Court said.
As a result, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation decided to satisfy the representation of the Prosecutor General's Office, overturned the decisions of lower authorities regarding the non-use of vehicle confiscation and sent the case for a new hearing by a new court.
Law and expediency
Human rights activists and experts interviewed by Izvestia have different attitudes towards the Supreme Court's decision. According to Sergey Smirnov, an auto lawyer, the RF Armed Forces acted correctly, pointing out to the lower authorities the violations they had committed.
— The examination of evidence must be complete and comprehensive. In this case, it is obvious that the nominal owner of the car could not use it. And in fact, she was constantly exploited by the convict herself," he noted.
According to him, taking into account the established practice, the court will decide on the confiscation of this car upon a new hearing of the case.
Sergey Radko, a lawyer for the Freedom of Choice movement, holds a different point of view. In his opinion, in this case, the RF Supreme Court was guided not so much by the letter of the law as by "judicial expediency."
— It is obvious that in this case the convict's mother is the nominal owner of the car. But the legislation clearly states that only the vehicle belonging to the accused himself is subject to confiscation," the lawyer emphasized.
He agrees that during the review of the case, most likely, a decision will be made to confiscate the car. However, the execution of this decision may simply be impossible, the lawyer believes.
"Since this vehicle was not initially seized, it could well have changed ownership over the past time," Sergei Radko pointed out.
Even when the idea of confiscating cars for repeated drunk driving was being discussed, many lawyers and human rights activists warned about the likelihood of such collisions, Maxim Kadakov, editor-in-chief of Za Rulem magazine, recalls. He believes that in this case, the Russian Armed Forces acted correctly. However, to prevent such situations from happening again, a unified solution is needed on this issue.
— In this case, it is obvious that Myshkina's mother, who did not have a license, could not drive this car. But what would the court do if she still had a driver's license? I believe that if a person who has already lost his license for "drinking" gets behind the wheel drunk again, the car he was driving should be confiscated, regardless of who is listed as its owner. And only then let the owner of the transport, who allowed such a driver to drive, deal with him, demanding compensation for the cost of the confiscated car," Maxim Kadakov told Izvestia.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»