Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

An accident caused by a road sign closed by branches is not an insured event, and damage from such an accident cannot be compensated for by CTP. This is the conclusion reached by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. This insurance only works when determining the fault of one of the direct participants in the accident, lawyers and experts say. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.

It won't be enough

In the fall of 2023 in Volgograd, Shumkov (last name changed. — Izvestia), who was moving along a secondary street, did not provide an advantage to Ifanov (last name changed. — Izvestia), who was driving along the main road. Ifanov applied to the insurance company for CTP compensation. However, the insurer did not issue a repair referral to the car owner, as required by the victim, but compensated for the damage by transferring money. The refusal to send to the technical center and the amount of insurance paid did not suit the motorist, so he filed a lawsuit with the court.

молоток суд
Photo: IZVESTIA/Anna Selina

Ifanov also disagreed with the decisions of the Central District Court of Volgograd, the Volgograd Regional Court and the Fourth Court of Cassation of General Jurisdiction and the amounts of compensation established by these instances. As a result, he filed a complaint with the Supreme Court (Supreme Court of the Russian Federation).

The branches are to blame

After reviewing the case materials, the judicial board of the Supreme Court for Civil Cases revealed violations committed by lower authorities. The judges drew attention to the documents about the accident and photographs from the scene taken by traffic police officers. From these data, it follows that the cause of the accident was a 2.5 road sign closed by branches, "Movement without stopping is prohibited," which did not see the Noise. The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation noted that the motorist was "in a voluntary delusion and had no way to determine the presence of certain signs in front of the intersection." At the same time, as follows from the case file, the administration of Volgograd improperly fulfilled its duty to maintain roads, and by the decision of the court of first instance, losses related to the repair of Ifanov's vehicle in the amount of 413.6 thousand rubles were recovered from it.

деньги
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

"The right to insurance compensation under the CTP agreement arises in the event of damage caused for which another person using the vehicle is responsible. In the present case, neither the traffic police officers nor the court have established the drivers' guilt in the specified accident, but only the fact of the guilty actions of the Volgograd administration has been established, and therefore civil liability provided for by the law "On OSAGO" has not occurred. Consequently, the court of first instance had no grounds to recover both insurance compensation and losses from the insurer," the Supreme Court ruling says.

As a result, the judicial board for civil cases overturned the decisions of the lower instances and sent the case for a new hearing.

Greed failed

The Supreme Court made a reasoned decision, since compensation for damage under the CTP provides for the guilt of another participant in the accident, says auto lawyer Sergey Smirnov. Why the court of first instance did not pay attention to this is completely unclear, he notes.

— The plaintiff in this case initially went down the wrong path, trying to recover CTP compensation from the insurer. At the same time, executing the decision of the court of first instance, the insurer nevertheless paid him a certain amount. In addition, according to the same court decision, the car owner also received compensation from the city administration, which did not ensure the visibility of the road sign, which led to the accident," the lawyer emphasized.

дтп знак
Photo: IZVESTIA/Zurab Javakhadze

Since the Supreme Court's decision explicitly states that there were no grounds for recovery of damage compensation from the CTP insurer, in this case the insurance company has the right to demand that the motorist refund the amount previously paid to him, Sergei Smirnov believes. This payment can be regarded as unjustified enrichment, he explained.

— The driver should have immediately applied for compensation of the full amount of losses to the relevant city services, which did not fulfill their duties on road maintenance and did not cut the branches covering the sign. However, it is too late to do this now: the law prohibits re—applying with the same claims to the same defendant, and the amount determined by the court has already been paid to him by the Volgograd administration," Sergey Smirnov added.

Accidents in which there is no culprit are extremely rare, says Sergey Radko, a lawyer for the Freedom of Choice movement. Nevertheless, since the law "On OSAGO" presupposes the guilt of one or another participant in the accident, in this case the Supreme Court acted based on the requirements of the law, he stressed. Despite the fact that the inaction of the employees of the city services led to the accident, they themselves did not participate in the incident, the lawyer explained.

суд весы
Photo: RIA Novosti/Maria Devakhina

— CTP works in case of an accident caused by someone directly involved in the movement - the driver, pedestrian, passenger, etc. The road and utility services that have committed certain violations in the maintenance of the highway are not such. Accordingly, if the accident occurred, as in this case, because of a sign covered by branches or, for example, because of a pit or faded markings, then it makes no sense to make claims to the insurer for CTP, - said Sergey Radko.

By returning the case for a new hearing, the Supreme Court gave the lower authorities an obvious signal, the lawyer noted. Therefore, he also believes that after the review of the court decision, the insurance company will have the right to demand that the motorist refund the amount previously paid to him.

An accident without a culprit

By overturning the decision of the lower courts, the Supreme Court acted based on the requirements of the law, believes Maxim Kadakov, editor-in-chief of Za Rulem magazine. Since there is no direct culprit of the accident, it means that there can be no question of compensation for CTP damage, he noted. However, from the point of view of the general attitude of drivers towards avtograzhdanka, another solution would probably be more logical, the expert believes.

— This decision reduces the already low level of drivers' trust in the CTP system. I think it would be more fair to oblige the insurer to pay compensation, and already the city administration, which did not keep track of the road, to reimburse the insurance company for this payment," Maxim Kadakov told Izvestia.

осаго
Photo: RIA Novosti/Alexey Maishev

Igor Morzharetto, an auto expert and partner of the Autostat analytical agency, holds a different point of view. In his opinion, even though the road sign is covered by branches, the second driver is still the culprit of the accident, because, driving to the intersection, he was not convinced of the safety of his maneuver.

"If time limits and other procedural rules allow, the court needs to establish the degree of guilt of each of the participants in the accident and, taking this into account, decide on the payment of compensation for CTP during the retrial of the case," he believes.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast