Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

A large-scale split is brewing in the European Union, which may call into question not only financial assistance to Ukraine, but also the entire budgetary architecture of the community for the next seven years. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has threatened to block the adoption of the EU budget for 2028-2034 if all member states do not commit to participate in financing Kiev. At the same time, some states are opposed to further spending on Ukrainians. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.

Give me more

"A collective commitment, according to which all of us, without exception, will make a fair contribution to covering [Ukraine's funding gap], is a necessary precondition for resolving this issue and discussing any further issues, especially those with financial implications," German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said in a letter to European Council President Antonio Costa. Financial Times with reference to a representative of the German government.

The head of the German government has threatened to block the next seven-year budget of the European Union if all member states do not commit to providing financial support to Ukraine in 2027 and beyond.

Европарламент
Photo: Global Look Press/Justin Tang/Keystone Press Agency

Negotiations on the EU budget for 2028-2034 have been going on for several months. Brussels plans to coordinate the financial plan by the end of this year. The states are rushing to reach an agreement before the elections in France, Poland, Spain and Italy in 2027, because otherwise it will be even more difficult to reach a compromise.

At the same time, Kiev is demanding more and more money from Brussels. Earlier, European leaders approved the allocation of a loan to Ukraine for €90 billion, but after a while Vladimir Zelensky requested another €70 billion. As a result, the EU decided to satisfy two thirds of this amount — €45 billion.

The split in the European family

The allocation of aid to Ukraine will be discussed at the informal EU summit in Dublin, which will be held on November 12-13. The countries will consider options for financing Kiev, including issuing joint debt securities.

At the same time, the issue of providing additional financial assistance has further divided the EU countries. Hungary, the Czech Republic, Slovakia and Bulgaria opposed further allocation of funds to Ukraine. Earlier, they did not participate in the provision of a loan of €90 billion, which caused misunderstanding in Germany.

Флаги Германии, ЕС и Украины
Photo: Global Look Press/Florian Gaertner/www.imago-images.de

Although Merz himself said that financing Kiev had become "a serious burden on European budgets," he promised, together with his allies, to continue helping Ukraine with money without receiving military equipment and funds from the United States for the purchase of weapons.

The current situation creates several interrelated risks for Brussels. First of all, this is an institutional precedent: linking the budget with foreign policy commitments blurs the logic of a multi-year financial framework, which traditionally serves as a tool for long-term planning rather than political bargaining.

In addition, it increases the risk of deepening the split. Merz's tough stance may consolidate the "refusenik camp" and strengthen Eurosceptic sentiments ahead of the 2027 elections. And finally, there is uncertainty for Kiev: even if a compromise is found, it may turn out to be fragile and may not guarantee the "reliable long-term financial prospects" that the German chancellor is talking about.

Фридрих Мерц
Photo: Global Look Press/IMAGO/Christian Spicker

The Dublin summit will decide whether the EU can remain united in the face of a budget ultimatum from its largest donor.

We are used to budget deficits

The current situation for the European Union is quite difficult, since the governments themselves decide to lift the debt brakes, said Natalia Eremina, professor at St. Petersburg State University, in an interview with Izvestia.

— The second important point is that at the level of the European Union, they are also uncritical about such a concept as the budget deficit, and, accordingly, they allow the growth of domestic debt. In addition, there have already been situations that have been collectively resolved by redistributing funds during covid," the political scientist explained.

Печать валюты в Италии
Photo: Global Look Press/Esma Cakir/dpa

Some EU economies, such as Italy, have periodically resorted to such mechanisms, asking for help, she recalled. The expert added that after the pandemic, a fairly large amount of money was printed, and thus the funds were redistributed. In the current situation, according to the editorial's interlocutor, a huge amount of money is accompanied by a drop in domestic production due to unprofitable energy prices.

— We see how businesses in Germany are closing every day, tens of thousands of people are out of work. We even see people moving to other countries or moving production facilities," the specialist said.

Germany, which is actually the main donor to the EU's general budget for all programs, is interested in sending the excess money supply, which cannot be invested in domestic production and the military-industrial complex, to Ukraine through various mechanisms.

Difficult negotiations are ahead.

Meanwhile, Politico reported that the largest donors are tired of financing Ukraine. The publication does not specify which countries it is referring to. However, there are indeed opposition forces in Europe, including the Alternative for Germany and the French National Association, which oppose providing financial assistance to Kiev.

ВСУ
Photo: Global Look Press/Viacheslav Madiievsky/Keystone Press Agency

Friedrich Merz wants to show the unity of the European Union on the issue of support for Ukraine, Artem Sokolov, a senior researcher at the MGIMO Institute of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Russia, told Izvestia. This is important in the context of the intensification of the negotiation process on the formation of a new European security system and the fatigue from the Ukrainian conflict in the countries of the union, which is recognized by the EU politicians themselves. The latter, along with the deterioration of socio-economic indicators, form a high level of discontent among citizens of most European countries regarding the actions of their governments. Complicating the situation is the widespread narrative of excessive aid to Ukraine, the high corruption component of the aid process, and the lack of success of the Ukrainian Armed Forces at the front.

— In other words, it seems that the moment has come when the principle of "oil instead of guns" is more relevant than ever. And in these circumstances, Merz wants to show that, despite this ferment within European society, the EU remains within the framework of a single consolidated position on issues of support for Ukraine and is ready to allocate large financial resources to it," the German stressed.

For now, the question of how Merz's rhetoric will be perceived by his European partners remains open, he added.

— As we have repeatedly seen, Friedrich Merz is a politician with a low level of empathy, and this created problems for him and his party. And, probably, this language of threats, to which he turns in communication with European partners, may be perceived ambiguously," the expert admitted.

ЕС Киев
Photo: Global Look Press/Pavlo Bahmut/Keystone Press Agency

Instead of listening to the position of Germany and the states that share it (primarily the Nordic countries), EU members who are not interested in expanding assistance to Ukraine will continue to adhere to their point of view. And here, Berlin, according to the analyst, will have to look for some non-trivial approaches in order to convince them to continue to support Kiev at the same level as in recent years.

— In any case, there will be very difficult debates, the outcome of which is not yet a foregone conclusion, — Sokolov summed up.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast