The credit of trust: who will pay for the new EU loans for Ukraine
The European Union may need more than €40 billion in new loans for Ukraine. According to calculations by Welt am Sonntag, in this case, the debt obligations of the association related to the support of Kiev will exceed € 200 billion. However, not all countries are ready to participate in guarantees for a new loan. In Europe, there is already debate about whether further assistance from general taxes will be required and whether cuts in social spending will be avoided. Who will pay for the new obligations and how long the EU will be able to finance Kiev in debt — in the Izvestia article.
Life on loan
Brussels will have to raise more than €40 billion in additional loans to help Ukraine next year, writes Welt am Sonntag. According to the calculations of the newspaper, this will increase the total debt obligations of the EU related to the support of Kiev to more than 200 billion euros.
Vladimir Zelensky appealed to European leaders for additional funds on October 16. At a meeting of the European Council, he requested at least €70 billion for defense, armaments and maintaining the stability of the country. "This is a realistic figure. I'm asking you to find this money," Zelensky said.
According to him, Kiev is capable of producing twice or three times as many drones, but there are not enough funds for this. Later, the Ukrainian government clarified that the money was also needed to cover budget expenses.
At the same time, the EU has already provided €90 billion in military and budgetary support for Ukraine until the end of 2027. The new request involves additional costs. Brussels expects to cover some of them with proceeds from frozen Russian assets. However, according to Welt am Sonntag, they bring in only about €4 billion a year, while Kiev needs tens of billions. The capital itself is not being transferred to Ukraine, and most of the income is already intended to repay previously issued G7 loans.
European Council President Antonio Costa has promised that the European Union will be able to provide about two thirds of the additional aid. Brussels expects to receive the rest from Kiev's other allies, primarily from the United Kingdom and Canada.
However, it is not yet easy to agree on the distribution of costs. At a summit with the EU on October 30, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney announced an initial contribution of 500 million euros. As Politico reported, the parties disagreed on what the money would be used for. The Canadian politician linked the contribution to the current European loan program, while in Brussels they expected to direct it to additional needs of Ukraine next year. The European Commission called Canada's promise a good start, making it clear that it expects more from its partners.
Dispute over guarantees
Over the past few years, support for Ukraine has become a major item of European spending. According to the European Commission on November 5, the total amount of EU aid exceeded €230 billion. This estimate includes loans, grants, guarantees, arms supplies, and costs for Ukrainian refugees in Europe.
Now the Europeans will have to agree on who will take over the guarantees for the new loan. The Czech Republic and Slovakia have already made it clear that they are not ready to participate in its financial support. A similar position is expected from Hungary. Attempts by these countries to obtain exceptions are causing dissatisfaction among German diplomats.
New commitments are being discussed against the background of attempts by European governments to reduce budget deficits. A nationwide strike against budget measures was held in Belgium on October 9. Trade unions believe that the authorities are shifting the costs of fighting the deficit to workers, pensioners and low-income families.
In France, the government is trying to agree on a budget for 2027, which provides for savings of €54 billion. At the same time, the country is protesting against the high cost and state of public services. These actions are related to internal problems, but they show the resistance the authorities face when cutting costs.
At the same time, European countries are increasing their own military budgets. According to the EU Council, this year they will allocate 454 billion euros for defense, which is 8.6% more than a year earlier.
Against this background, Le Monde notes signs of European society's war fatigue. Benjamin Martill, associate professor at the University of Edinburgh, says the debate is increasingly about the choice between military and day-to-day spending. According to his observation, even citizens who support Ukraine are beginning to doubt the effectiveness of the aid. He conveys their sentiments like this: "Okay, I support Ukraine, but the money we are sending seems to be going into a black hole, because there are no real prospects for victory."
Gregoire Roos, an expert at the Chatham House analytical center, clarifies that so far we are talking primarily about a weakening of readiness to support military spending. However, without a convincing diplomatic perspective, Kiev's support may also weaken, he warns.
Who will pay
The European Union is able to continue lending to Ukraine, says Evgeny Shatov, partner at Capital Lab. According to his estimates, 200 billion euros is just over 1% of the annual GDP of the association, and the amount alone does not threaten Europe's debt sustainability. But the interest on loans is paid from a much more limited overall budget.
— The budget of the EU itself is very small relative to the European economy. In 2026, its payment part amounts to about 190 billion euros. Therefore, the additional costs of servicing tens of billions of euros of debt are noticeable precisely within the budget of Brussels," the expert explains.
The interest on the current loan of €90 billion is covered from the EU budget, he said. If new loans are issued in the same way, the costs will also fall on him. This budget is largely formed by contributions from Member States, so the largest economies bear the greatest absolute burden.
At the same time, borrowing itself has become more expensive. As Shatov notes, ten-year EU financing costs about 4%, whereas a few years ago European debt was raised almost free of charge.
— Interest is starting to compete in the budget with spending on infrastructure, climate, agriculture, industry and defense. Thus, the macroeconomic burden is still moderate, but budgetary and political it is already becoming significant," the expert points out.
The more expensive new loans are, the stronger Brussels' interest in using the fixed capital of frozen Russian reserves. However, Shatov warns, this is hampered by legal risks, possible retaliatory actions by Moscow and the consequences for confidence in the euro and the European financial system. So the lack of money increases the likelihood of more aggressive use of Russian assets, but does not make direct confiscation automatic.
Denis Denisov, an expert at the Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation, considers the approval of a new loan to be quite realistic. Even the unwillingness of individual governments to participate in regular borrowing, in his opinion, will not necessarily lead to blocking the decision.
"Despite the fact that some countries oppose such decisions at the first stage, this position is subsequently smoothed out and the agreements necessary for Brussels are adopted," he tells Izvestia.
Countries that depend on Russian energy resources will try to use the loan negotiations to protect their interests, the source admits. First of all, he mentions Slovakia and, possibly, Hungary. On the one hand, they will give the go-ahead for a loan, on the other hand, there will be some kind of delay in the supply of hydrocarbons.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»