Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

While the foreign market is in a fever, the Moscow Stock Exchange is showing growth — last week the trading floor index rose to 2,455 points, while the Nasdaq 100 fell by 6.4%, showing the strongest drop since the pandemic. On the morning of Monday, November 9, the situation repeated itself — the Moscow Stock Exchange opened with an increase of almost 1%. Such situations are not uncommon, as the Russian stock market is now practically independent of the global one. Whether this can be called a structural feature, whether there are secondary risks for Russia from panic abroad and under what conditions the index of the trading platform can exceed 2500 points — in the Izvestia material.

Bad money

Last Thursday, November 5, the Nasdaq 100 technology index collapsed amid a 6.4% drop in shares of chip manufacturers, which was the strongest decline since the coronavirus pandemic. Investors began to leave the sector en masse due to fears of tightening control over the artificial intelligence industry by the Democrats who won the US congressional elections.

The capitalization of the S&P 500 shrank by $3 trillion in one session. The index fell by 4%, with all 11 sectors in the red.

Asian stock exchanges collapsed next — the South Korean KOSPI fell by about 6% by November 6, while the Japanese Nikkei 225 showed comparable losses. And here the main pressure fell on companies that depend on global demand for semiconductors.

южнокорейский KOSPI
Photo: Global Look Press/Lee Jae-Won/AFLO

The political situation in the United States remains a source of uncertainty for financial markets due to the expected personnel changes in the administration of Donald Trump. The American media reports, for example, on the possible departure of Secretary of State and National Security Adviser Marco Rubio. However, it is not unconfirmed information that is more important for the market, but the prospects for changes in the regulation of the technology industry and fiscal policy.

On Tuesday, November 10, futures for the S&P 500 continued to fall after the release of the US consumer price index, which increased by 0.4% on a monthly basis, which turned out to be higher than economists' expectations. The inflation figures reinforced expectations that the Federal Reserve will keep interest rates high for longer. In just one minute, the S&P 500 declined by -0.76%, which would have meant a collapse of $600 billion during normal trading hours.

Against the background of the global panic, the situation in Russia is noteworthy. The Moscow Exchange index rose by 0.54% to 2,455 points on the same day. And on Monday, November 9, the picture turned out to be similar — the world showed its worst week in years, while the Russian trading platform showed an increase of almost 1%, to 2,487 points.

Трехсторонняя встреча представителей России, США и Украины в Абу-Даби

Trilateral meeting of representatives of Russia, the USA and Ukraine in Abu Dhabi

Photo: RIA Novosti/Grigory Sysoev

The reason was the trilateral talks between the Russian Federation, the United States and Ukraine, which are taking place in Abu Dhabi on November 10-11. US President Donald Trump, commenting on the upcoming meeting, said that the parties were close to reaching an agreement. He noted that a "very important meeting" would be held in the coming days, adding that Ukraine would have a "slightly different form" after the deal was concluded.

Breaking with Wall Street

The situation on the Moscow Stock Exchange is not abnormal — Russia's dependence on the global market weakened back in 2022. And over the years, Wall Street's influence has become even less. Before the start of the Ukrainian crisis, the correlation between the Moscow Exchange index and the S&P 500 was high, often exceeding 0.6–0.7 on the horizon of the year. This situation developed due to the embeddedness of the Russian market in the global financial system. Today, the correlation coefficient on most horizons has dropped to near–zero or weakly positive values (0.1-0.3).

By 2022, 70-80% of the pricing in the Russian market was determined by Western funds that used global risk models. Therefore, in the event of a panic on Wall Street, the algorithms of these funds automatically dumped risky assets around the world. This also applied to Russia, local fundamental factors were not taken into account.

Now, foreign investors cannot operate with Russian assets, and compatriots' access to foreign platforms is limited, as a result of which the global collapse is not transferred to the Moscow Stock Exchange. The Russian market lives precisely according to its internal logic, where local interest rates, dividend yields and geopolitical news directly related to the Russian Federation, rather than the situation in the United States, come to the fore.

Здание Московской биржи
Photo: IZVESTIA/Andrey Erstrem

Until 2022, Western funds invested in Russian stocks, and the correlation with global indices was obvious, confirms Natalia Malykh, head of the stock analysis department at Finam. The situation has changed now, but how temporary it is will depend on the geopolitical arrangements.

— Western capital has either withdrawn from the Russian market or is frozen, but it cannot be said that Russian stocks are completely independent of the global stock market. Tangentially, events and expectations about the global economy affect us through changes in commodity prices and the dollar exchange rate," the Izvestia interlocutor points out.

Albert Koroev, Head of the Stock Market Experts Department at BCS World Investments, also recognizes the impact of a strong reduction in the presence of Western capital in Russian assets. However, he also draws attention to the influence of a number of other factors.

— In particular, the high current sensitivity of the Russian market to the issue of geopolitics, the dynamics of commodity prices, rather than the speculative movement of global capital, — the expert notes.

Банкноты в счетчике купюр
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet

Therefore, there is no need to talk about complete economic self-sufficiency. The isolation affected the stock market, but did not have a significant impact on the currency and commodity sectors.

The short game

According to the results of the vote in the United States, Brent benchmark oil fell from $116 to $93 per barrel, losing almost 19% in a few days. Reports of negotiations between Iran and Qatar, which demonstrated Tehran's willingness to continue diplomatic consultations, also contributed to a sharp drop in prices. This gave investors hope for de-escalation in the region, supporting expectations of a change in the Trump administration's rhetoric.

The echo of the global panic nevertheless reached Russia — the Moscow Exchange index fell to 2,409.74 points on November 7. And the oil and gas sector lost 3.06% on the trading floor last week.

Trading is a much bigger channel of vulnerability than portfolio flows. The price of oil affects export earnings, a decrease in which leads to a trade deficit and a weakening of the ruble, which accelerates inflation within the country.

НПЗ
Photo: IZVESTIA/Anna Selina

In addition, global panic can provoke an escalation of the geopolitical confrontation with the Russian Federation, whose instrument is increasingly secondary sanctions that can hit supply chains through friendly countries.

It is also important to understand that in times of collapse in global markets, the dollar traditionally strengthens due to the compression of global liquidity. Importing critical components and equipment eventually becomes more expensive, because payments in this case are still often pegged to the US currency. And this increases the risk of ruble devaluation.

Physical impact

Speaking about the stability of the Moscow Exchange, it is worth paying attention to the investor structure that has developed on the trading platform. Individuals are now playing an important role: in October alone, they invested 166.7 billion rubles in securities.

However, it should be borne in mind that "physicists" are often emotional and influenced by the news agenda, which creates high intraday volatility.

"Most individuals now prefer more conservative instruments due to increased interest rates and uncertainty in geopolitics: in September, they invested 6.8 billion rubles in stocks and 210.6 billion rubles in bonds," says Natalia Malykh.

Бизнесмен
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

Retail investors, as the Izvestia interlocutor notes, have only partially replaced Western capital— mainly in terms of trading activity and liquidity. But they have not become a source of long-term investment demand.

"Funds are usually long—term investors with low portfolio turnover, while individuals can often change their strategy depending on the level of interest rates and the news background, which makes their investments less predictable over a long horizon," the expert recalls.

The actions of liquid private banks acting as market makers (a major professional participant in the financial market that provides liquidity and trading stability) in their own stocks and money market instruments remain important for the situation on the stock exchange. with corporations of structures and closed-end mutual funds.

Cross the line

The Moscow Exchange index may exceed 2500 this week, if there is positive news following the results of the trilateral meeting in Abu Dhabi, Albert Koroyev does not exclude. From the current levels, this movement is small, he explains.

However, a combination of several factors is necessary to sustainably consolidate the indicator. First of all, a significant easing of monetary policy is needed. A lower key rate will make the dividend yield of stocks more attractive than deposits, as a result of which depositors' money will begin to flow massively from banks to the stock market. Without a rate cut, a break above 2,500 points is likely to be short-term, speculative in nature against the background of local corporate news.

Бочка нефти
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

At the same time, stable or rising oil prices are important, which will ensure the inflow of foreign currency into the country, budget replenishment and strong financial results for exporters, as well as de-escalation or the absence of tough new sanctions.

— An increase of over 2,500 points can be expected against the background of geopolitical optimism, but whether the index will gain a foothold above this mark and recover over 3,000—3,500 points will depend on real agreements in terms of peace, — emphasizes Natalia Malykh.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast