- Статьи
- Economy
- We can repeat: does the current downturn in the stock exchanges threaten a new financial crisis
We can repeat: does the current downturn in the stock exchanges threaten a new financial crisis
The US stock market quotes rebounded after the catastrophic collapse on November 5, when the stock sale immediately removed $3 trillion of capitalization from the market. The drop was one of the largest in recent times, as a result of the formidable rhetoric of the Democrats who won the midterm elections, who are going to create big problems for the AI sector. If you look at it in retrospect, a good half of the largest collapses in the history of the American market did not entail any consequences. But there are signs of a major crisis brewing both within the financial sector and beyond. Whether the current market turbulence is a harbinger of something more catastrophic is in the Izvestia article.
Assessment of fear
Financial history knows many episodes when panic sales on stock exchanges turned out to be only local "ripples on the water." A classic example is "Black Monday" on October 19, 1987, when the Dow Jones index collapsed by 22.6% in a trading session. The reason for the shock was imperfect trading algorithms and lack of liquidity. However, thanks to the decisive actions of the Federal Reserve System (FRS), the credit market did not stop, the banking system resisted, and the American economy not only avoided recession, but also continued to grow steadily. A similar situation was observed in the fall of 1998 after the default in Russia and the restructuring of the LTCM hedge fund, and in August 2024, when the emergency curtailment of speculative transactions (carry trade) on the Japanese yen caused a short-term collapse on the Tokyo and New York stock exchanges, which exhausted itself in a matter of weeks.
Events took a completely different turn when the stock market crash affected the backbone, the "circulatory system" of the economy — bank credit. In October 1929, a drop in margin positions on the stock exchange triggered a wave of loan defaults and panic among depositors, resulting in the collapse of thousands of banks and the Great Depression. In the fall of 2008, the bankruptcy of the investment bank Lehman Brothers and the collapse of the mortgage derivatives market led to a complete paralysis of interbank lending: institutions stopped trusting each other, which froze financing of the real sector.
The dot-com crash of 2000-2002 became an intermediate precedent: then the Nasdaq index lost almost 80% of its value, provoking a series of bankruptcies and a decline in investments, which led to a moderate recession, although the basic banking infrastructure remained stable.
Held hostage by AI
The vulnerability of the American economy now lies in the unprecedented concentration of growth around the artificial intelligence (AI) industry. According to analysts, the combined investments of the largest technology corporations from the construction of data centers to the purchase of advanced chips in recent years have provided from 20% to 35% of the total net GDP growth in the United States. Against the background of high interest rates, which cooled traditional construction and consumer lending, large-scale infrastructure injections of bigtech remained almost the only reliable driver of investment.
However, the alarm bells in the sector are visible to the naked eye. First, there is a gap between costs and monetization. The total infrastructure budgets of technology corporations are approaching the $800 billion mark per year. At the same time, the real net revenue from the corporate implementation of generative AI is estimated in only tens of billions. Investors are beginning to realize that the euphoria phase has dragged on, and the return on invested capital is delayed.
Secondly, the industry has found itself in an energy and regulatory impasse. The timing of connecting new data centers to the power grid in the United States today stretches for five to seven years. Superimposed on this is the growing irritation of voters due to the rise in electricity tariffs and the shortage of water resources. The triumph of the Democratic Party in the midterm elections threatens the sector with stricter environmental standards, moratoriums on the construction of new energy-intensive facilities and antitrust proceedings. Especially considering that the Democrats won not only in the country as a whole, but also in key states like Texas for the development of the sector.
Thirdly, private credit poses a threat. In an effort not to overload their public balance sheets with debt obligations, technology players are increasingly attracting financing through the private loan sector secured by infrastructure and computing clusters. In the event of a reassessment of the industry's prospects, these assets may rapidly depreciate, which will create a direct gap in the capital of funds and institutional investors. A symptomatic signal for the market was the recent fixation of losses and a wave of margin calls from aggressive speculative funds that relied solely on the exponential growth of the AI infrastructure.
The main driver of the recession may be the "reverse wealth effect." More than a third of the capitalization of the S&P 500 index is accounted for by a narrow group of technological megacorporations. American households today hold a record share of savings in securities. The continued decline in the stock market can undermine consumer confidence, triggering a sharp squeeze in spending, which accounts for about 70% of the American economy.
The situation is compounded by the political impasse in Washington. The loss of the Republican Party's majority in both houses of Congress has made President Donald Trump a "lame duck." The chances of adopting new anti-crisis fiscal packages, tax breaks, or raising the debt ceiling without shocks tend to zero, and verbal interventions are unlikely to convince anyone.
In the real sector, this background will inevitably lead to an investment pause. The slowdown in data center financing will hit related industries such as semiconductor manufacturers, energy engineering, and equipment suppliers, increasing pressure on the labor market.
The airbag
Nevertheless, it is premature to talk about a guaranteed repeat of the 1929 or 2008 scenario. Unlike the dotcom bust of 2000 (when penny—a-lot startups went down), the flagships of the current industry (Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon, Meta, SpaceX) are super-profitable corporations with tens of billions of dollars of free cash flow from their core businesses. Even large-scale write-offs of investments in AI do not threaten their financial stability and will not lead to bankruptcies of systemically important issuers.
In addition, the American banking sector operates under much stricter capital adequacy and collateral quality requirements than on the eve of the subprime mortgage crisis. Financial problems today are localized mainly in the unregulated private debt sector.
Finally, the Fed still has room for maneuver. The American regulator has sufficient reserve on the interest rate to reduce it promptly in the event of a threat of recession, and the emergency liquidity mechanism has repeatedly proved its effectiveness. Another question is that this may cause another round of inflation, but this is a different problem.
The current turmoil on American platforms hardly portends a repeat of 2008. However, they cannot be considered harmless fluctuations either. Investment fatigue from AI, political activism by opponents of the new technology, and the standoff in Washington risk severely slowing down business activity. All this threatens to deflate the bubble and trigger a prolonged and painful recession. Which is then likely to overwhelm the rest of the world.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»