Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

EU countries have begun competing for positions on the board of the European Central Bank. Why is this important?

Berlin has started consultations in the EU on Lagarde's successor at the ECB, Klingbeil said.
0
Photo: Global Look Press/IMAGO/Florian Gaul
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The president of the European Central Bank (ECB), Christine Lagarde, announced her early retirement on February 7. A struggle has already begun between the largest economies of the European Union for the right to nominate their candidate for this post, despite the fact that the successor will have to find a difficult compromise between curbing rising inflation in the eurozone and stimulating economic growth. What is the reason for Lagarde's early departure and what advantages does a place in the leadership of the ECB give the countries of the bloc — in the Izvestia article.

Retirement opens up new opportunities

• Christine Lagarde herself explained her early resignation by saying that she wants to abandon the neutrality dictated by her position as head of the ECB and speak freely on issues beyond monetary policy. Some foreign publications interpreted this phrase as an application for participation in the political struggle in Lagarde's homeland, France. The head of the ECB also said that the search for her successor to the post of head of the main financial institution of the eurozone has already begun.

Lagarde's departure from office did not come as a surprise: Back in February, such a development was predicted in the foreign press, directly linking it to the timing of the French presidential election. The fact is that with the early departure of the head of the ECB from office, the current French president Emmanuel Macron, whose rating in October fell to a minimum since 2017 — 15%, will still be able to participate in the election of her successor.

• The foreign press believes that Lagarde's early departure from office may be beneficial not only to Macron, but also to the entire top of the EU as a whole, since politicians who refuse to accept the EU's demands for green initiatives and support for Ukraine come to power in European countries. That is why the EU authorities are trying to distribute key posts, while the states are headed by clear and predictable leaders.

• Currently, in the wake of the protests in France, the popularity of Eurosceptics is growing — the far-right Marine Le Pen and Jordan Bardella and the far-left Jean-Luc Melenchon. In Germany, the right-wing populist Alternative for Germany won the local elections in most of the eastern states, and the election of the new president of Germany is scheduled for January 30. In fact, the two largest EU economies, which are at the heart of any alliances within the bloc, acting as locomotives of reform and support for Ukraine, may soon drastically change their political course.

The successor will have to save Europe's finances.

• The most likely candidates to replace Lagarde are Klaas Knoth (Netherlands), a proponent of tight monetary policy, and Pablo Hernandez Cos (Spain), a proponent of a softer approach. The press reports that France is ready to support Knoth's candidacy for the post of ECB president, provided that the portfolio of chief economist in the Executive Council passes to the French representative. At the same time, the allocation of portfolios takes place directly within the council: according to Article 10.2 of the ECB regulations, a decision on the allocation of positions cannot be taken if the President of the ECB opposes it.

• Joachim Nagel (Germany) is also among the possible candidates, who is a proponent of strict debt restrictions, but the fact that German representative Ursula von der Leyen is the head of the European Commission may be an obstacle to his nomination. Traditionally, key positions in the European Union are distributed among the largest economies: in 2019, Lagarde and von der Leyen got their jobs thanks to the so-called big deal between French President Emmanuel Macron and German Chancellor Angela Merkel at that time.

Izvestia reference

The agreement on German-French cooperation and integration, signed in 2019 in Aachen by French President Emmanuel Macron and German Chancellor Angela Merkel, is called a big deal. It was an addition to the 1963 Elysee Treaty and is designed to regulate cooperation between countries in the field of foreign policy, defense and economics. The parties agreed to coordinate their positions within the EU, hold joint consultations before major meetings, provide mutual assistance in the event of an attack, and support Germany in obtaining a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.

• The ECB Executive Board consists of the President, the Vice-President and four members who are elected for a non-renewable eight-year term. In 2027, the composition of the council will be renewed — three of the six council members, including Lagarde, will expire their terms of office. German representative Isabelle Schnabel, who is responsible for the bank's market policy, has already announced that she will leave her post ahead of schedule in January in connection with her transition to work at the IMF, and Germany intends to nominate a new candidate to retain her representation in this post at the ECB. The term of office of the ECB's Chief economist, Philip Lane (Ireland), also expires in May 2027. The representative of the Netherlands, Frank Elderson, who oversees banking supervision, holds the post until mid-December 2028, but may leave it ahead of schedule if the president of the ECB becomes Cnot, since no country can have excessive representation in the council.

The allocation of seats gives access to money

• Key decisions of the ECB are made by the Governing Council, which, in addition to the Executive Council, includes the heads of the national central banks of the EU countries. In addition, formally, the authorities of the countries cannot determine the policy of their representative in the ECB, which means they cannot directly influence the policy of the eurozone financial regulator. Nevertheless, maintaining representation in the Executive Council gives the state certain advantages: it is there that an analysis of the economic situation, inflation forecasts and draft decisions are prepared for meetings of the Governing Council, and this information ultimately influences the decision on the amount of the interest rate.

• The voting composition of the ECB Governing Council consists of members of the Executive Council (six votes) and heads of national central banks (15 votes). Among the heads of central banks, the largest economies of the bloc (France, Germany, Spain, Italy and the Netherlands) have four permanent votes, and among other EU countries there is a monthly rotation so that the financial regulators of each country are evenly represented. In other words, a seat on the Executive Council automatically strengthens the role of the EU state in decision-making by the main financial regulator of the eurozone.

• According to the foreign press, France expects to receive the post of chief economist of the ECB. The analysis of inflation and debt risks depends on it to make decisions about the rate, which determines the cost of loans and servicing government debt. At the same time, Paris has a problem with the largest public debt in the eurozone (115.7% of GDP) and a serious budget deficit of 5.1% of GDP. The indebtedness of the French economy is already dragging the euro down, and the cost of borrowing for France is only increasing.

• Germany's national debt is almost twice as low as that of France, but at the same time, Berlin is interested in affordable investments in defense, since the country has large arms manufacturers. Berlin's interest in a portfolio that controls the eurozone's market operations may be explained by the need for affordable defense financing and risk assessment in order to avoid a situation where the ECB is forced to mainly support countries with high public debt.

• The Netherlands is a country with a low public debt, and its interest in the position of ECB president may be explained by the need to bring other EU countries to stricter budget discipline. For Madrid, the opportunity to head the bloc's main financial regulator is more a matter of status: Spain is one of the largest EU economies, but currently does not have a representative on the Executive Board. If the Netherlands gets the presidency, Spain can apply for Elderson's place in charge of banking supervision.

What does this mean?

With the approach of elections in the European Union and the growing popularity of political forces defending national interests, even formally independent EU institutions are becoming a platform for the redistribution of influence between the liberal elites of major European economies. The EU authorities are mobilizing all resources to maintain influence on the overall strategy of the bloc for politicians who are rapidly losing popularity with their own voters. In this situation, the economic policy of the main financial regulator of the eurozone risks being held hostage, because the heads of major EU economies intend to use their influence on the ECB to their advantage.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast