Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The eurozone has demonstrated resilience to the crisis: against the backdrop of the protracted blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, the shortage of diesel fuel and Washington's aggressive tariff policy, a symbolic but nevertheless GDP growth (0.4%) was noted. Moreover, it turned out to be higher than expected, and only slightly lower than in the second quarter (0.6%). The only major exception to this trend was France, whose economy unexpectedly went into negative territory. Izvestia investigated whether this positive sign means that Europe has passed the low point of the recession, or whether it is a temporary fluctuation.

French U-turn

France has become the next "sick man of Europe." The currency bloc's second-largest economy unexpectedly contracted in the third quarter (-0.1%). The decline was recorded in all key components, but primarily investments decreased by 0.6%. Overall, the figures for this year look bleak: in the first quarter, GDP decreased by 0.2%, and stagnation was recorded in April–June. To make matters worse, inflation accelerated in October (to 3.8%, the highest rate since 2023). In fact, the country is following a stagflationary scenario.

банк
Photo: Global Look Press/Vincent Isore

The reasons for the French failure are related to the situation in public finances and management. The country is operating under conditions of an inflated budget deficit (over 5% of GDP) and political paralysis ahead of the 2027 presidential elections. The cost of servicing the sovereign debt of the Fifth Republic has increased dramatically: the yield on 10-year bonds (OAT) is held at highs, and the spread with German securities exceeds 150 basis points.

The increase in the cost of credit was also transmitted to the real sector. French companies have lost access to cheap working capital financing, and the population, faced with rising mortgage rates and consumer loans, is in no hurry to increase spending. The government, burdened with debts, cannot compensate for the decline in private demand with budget injections.

Tourists save the economy

If France is falling, why is the eurozone growing as a whole? The countries of Southern Europe, Spain and Italy, have relatively good results. These countries traditionally show strong results in July and September due to a strong service sector and international tourism.

In the summer of 2026, the strong US dollar, strengthened against the backdrop of global instability and the Fed's harsh policy, made trips to Europe extremely attractive for American and Asian tourists. The influx of foreign currency into the hotel, restaurant and retail sectors of the Mediterranean countries helped offset the decline in other sectors. The Spanish economy has pulled the consolidated European GDP indicator into a positive zone, largely due to the sale of tourist services. The factor of mass immigration is also important: Spain, by European standards, is growing at a rapid pace precisely because of the increase in population. In terms of per capita figures, the results in recent years look less impressive.

туризм
Photo: Global Look Press/David Zorrakino

As for Germany, the largest economy in the bloc, growth was at around 0.2%. The secret is simple — government spending increased dramatically after the Bundestag lifted the "debt brake" on most military spending, and the total amount of additional infrastructure financing amounted to about €560 billion over the next few years. This makes it possible to add to the country's GDP the very few tenths of a percent that make it possible to avoid stagnation or recession.

The investment brake

Reliance on the public sector and the budget creates the illusion of well-being in many EU countries. The composite PMI (purchasing managers' index) is now in a positive zone, unlike in previous years, when it dropped to 45 points or lower — this is the situation even in Germany, which was at the epicenter of the industrial crisis in 2023-2025. The government order mitigates the situation in the economy, but other indicators are much less positive.

завод
Photo: Global Look Press/Florian Gaertner

The situation with investments (gross fixed capital formation) looks doubtful. The EU corporate sector continued to reduce investment budgets in the third quarter. The reasons are obvious: the European Central Bank is forced to maintain a high base rate (around 4.75%) to combat inflation fueled by a shortage of diesel and gas. The situation with bank lending to legal entities, according to ECB estimates, continues to deteriorate.

The industry is facing a natural gas price of over $1,000 per 1,000 cubic meters. With such introductory investments, it is not very profitable to invest in the modernization of machine tools, the expansion of conveyors or the construction of new workshops within many sectors of the EU industry. Capital continues to flow to the United States, where the cost of energy is lower (gas prices can vary 10 times — an unthinkable thing by the standards of previous years), or settles on bank deposits. The current GDP growth is due to the depletion of old reserves and an increase in government spending, while the base for future income — the industrial infrastructure — is deteriorating. At the same time, of the large EU economies, only Germany has the opportunity to increase budget allocations due to its still small debt, while the rest do not have such an option.

Temporary trend

Overall, the positive trend in Europe looks temporary, although this year has repeatedly surprised skeptics. The eurozone has not passed the low point of the crisis, and so far has received only a short-term seasonal respite.

The third quarter covers the summer months, when household gas consumption is minimal. The fourth quarter of 2026 and the first quarter of 2027 will shift the focus from tourism to energy. Europe is entering the heating season with half-empty underground storage facilities (occupancy is 15 percentage points below the historical norm).

отопление
Photo: Global Look Press/IMAGO/Sven Heidmann

As cold weather sets in, energy-intensive enterprises will have to compete for resources with the housing and communal services sector. Fuel prices will inevitably rise, forcing chemical concerns and metallurgical plants to switch to mass production shutdowns. At the same time, the support from the tourism sector, which is typical for the summer months, will run out. The cost of diesel is also added to gas prices, which is also breaking records, which puts a heavy strain on continental transport networks. European Commissioner for Energy Dan Jorgensen recently urged citizens of the bloc countries to prepare for a difficult winter.

In these circumstances, the ECB faces a difficult choice. A contraction in business activity will require a reduction in interest rates, but the rise in energy prices in winter will create a new inflationary impulse, blocking any attempts to ease monetary policy.

Even if the eurozone economy manages to stay above zero in terms of growth in the coming months, the situation will worsen. Permanent stabilization is possible only if global energy prices return to at least relative order. But even in this case, problems from the financial sector will begin to spill over into the real economy — first of all, the debt crisis in France and, to a lesser extent, in Italy, multiplied by political instability, which will only grow in the foreseeable future.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast