- Статьи
- Economy
- Capital in superposition: how the breakthrough of the monetary canopy will affect the Russian economy
Capital in superposition: how the breakthrough of the monetary canopy will affect the Russian economy
The amount of funds of the population and businesses on deposits reaches tens of trillions of rubles, which is not least facilitated by the high key rate. Companies are increasingly choosing deposits as a way to earn money, refusing to modernize equipment or expand production. With a significant easing of the Central Bank's policy, the excess money supply may flood into the consumer and foreign exchange markets. Why businesses do not seek to invest in development, what is the threat of a long—term freeze on investment programs and under what conditions private capital will withdraw from deposits - in the Izvestia article.
The inviting pot
The volume of funds of the population and business in banks as of September 1 amounted to 135.4 trillion rubles, follows from the Bank of Russia's review on the development of the banking sector. Individuals had 68.5 trillion rubles in deposits. For legal entities, the amount is approximately the same. At the beginning of September, companies had 66.9 trillion rubles in banks.
The increase was mainly due to balances on current ruble accounts with oil and gas and energy companies. But small and medium-sized businesses also prefer not to spend money, but to put it at a percentage. According to VTB, customers conducted 8.2 million deposit transactions in the first seven months of 2026, which is 20% more than a year earlier. The revenue from the placement of available funds reached 256 billion rubles.
A similar trend was recorded earlier in Dom.RF. By the end of 2025, the average deposit amount of small and medium-sized businesses increased by 25% year-on-year to 50 million rubles, and in early 2026, the indicator started at 83 million rubles with an average period of seven days.
And the trend towards a decline in investment in production has been observed for several years — in 2024, for example, as analysts at the Center for Macroeconomic Analysis and Short-term Forecasting found out, the physical volume of investments in machinery and equipment could not exceed the level of 2021 and exceeded the target of 2019 by only 13%.
The stake is above development
The desire to keep money in banks without investing it in modernizing and scaling production is based on an economic calculation in which the risks and costs of expanding a business often outweigh the potential profit. One of the main reasons is that bank deposits provide guaranteed returns, while investments in modernization are a project with a 3-7-year horizon characterized by high uncertainty.
"An entrepreneur compares a relatively predictable interest income with investments that will pay off in a few years and depend on demand, cost of equipment, availability of personnel and financing," explains Denis Astafyev, an entrepreneur, fund manager and founder of the SharesPro fintech platform.
At the same time, as the expert emphasizes, one cannot say that business is turning into a rentier. Deposits may temporarily hold money for taxes, purchases, salaries, or future upgrades. The number of transactions should not be equated either to the number of legal entities that refused investments, or to the amount of money withdrawn from production, since the same funds can be placed for a short period of time.
At the same time, there are structural and operational barriers to investment in production. The shortage of personnel has its effect on the situation — modernization and scaling require qualified engineers, technologists, line staff and managers, and it is extremely difficult to find them on the market now. The costs of import substitution put additional pressure on, as scaling in such conditions becomes a difficult task with unpredictable results.
A separate factor is the tax burden. The 2026 reform has significantly changed the rules of the game, which is why small companies are facing an increasing fiscal burden. Naturally, they have fewer available funds that could be invested in development. Businesses currently cannot predict possible changes in the tax regime, the introduction of new sanctions, or the rise in price of critically important imported components due to a jump in the exchange rate. In such conditions, planning for 5-10 years, which is necessary for large-scale investments, becomes impossible, and the horizon shrinks to 6-12 months.
The payback requirements for new projects have increased in recent years, says investment advisor Yulia Kuznetsova. When placing money in a bank generates significant income, production should offer more, and adjusted for risk.
— Buying equipment requires not only initial costs: employees, raw materials, connection to infrastructure, maintenance and a sales market are needed. Income will appear later, and the actual payback may turn out to be worse than the estimated one," the Izvestia interlocutor draws attention.
And the deposit against this background gives a relatively predictable result and the opportunity to choose a short placement period. Therefore, in conditions of uncertainty, entrepreneurs prefer to save money until there is a clearer demand, while receiving income.
Rusted engine
The problem is that placing free money on deposits brings, although guaranteed, but limited income. And the protection against inflation of funds on deposits is quite average. Modernization of equipment and expansion of production can generate much higher net profit over a long horizon. In this case, the cost of production decreases, and its quality increases, which makes it possible to capture new markets.
If a company systematically postpones the necessary modernization, it risks losing productivity and competitiveness, warns Denis Astafyev.
— Aging equipment requires more maintenance, limits output and makes it difficult to reduce costs. A vicious circle arises: first, investments are postponed due to the lack of attractiveness of the project, then the deterioration in efficiency further reduces the opportunities for its implementation," he explains.
A short pause in investment programs can preserve the stability of the company, but a long one will begin to destroy it, confirms Yulia Kuznetsova. And it's not just the wear and tear of the equipment.
— Without automation, the company remains highly dependent on manual labor and salary increases. As a result, the cost increases, and the ability to produce more products remains limited," explains the expert.
There is also a risk of loss of competencies, she adds. Engineers are leaving, project teams are breaking up, and collaboration with developers is ending. And resuming the program in a few years will require additional costs and time.
At the economic level, according to the editorial's interlocutor, an unpleasant contradiction arises: today, the rejection of investments cools demand, but tomorrow it will limit supply.
— If consumption recovers, but production capacity and productivity do not increase, it will be more difficult for enterprises to respond to demand by increasing output. This creates conditions for new price pressure," she is convinced.
Denis Astafyev also confirms the price increase in cases when production capabilities stop keeping up with demand. Such an imbalance is considered a pro-inflationary risk.
However, as the specialist emphasizes, it is necessary to distinguish between the rejection of a weak, economically unjustified project and a long-term delay in updating, without which the company loses ground.
It is important to understand that temporarily available money is not always an investment capital. The deposit may contain funds for paying salaries, taxes, seasonal purchases, or equipment payments in a few months, Yulia Kuznetsova draws attention to. Using such money for long-term construction would create a cash gap.
The main question is which viable projects the company has postponed for the sake of deposit income, not how much it has earned on deposits.
Waiting for a tailwind
Businesses will start transferring money from deposits to the real sector if several conditions coincide. The key rate should be reduced to a level at which the return on the deposit will be less attractive than the premium for entrepreneurial risk (for example, below 8-10%).
At the same time, the ruble exchange rate should stabilize, and the rules of the game should become predictable over the next few years.
In addition, understandable demand is important for entrepreneurs, and reducing the key interest rate alone is not enough. Its reduction reduces the cost of financing and reduces the attractiveness of deposits, but in itself does not provide buyers for future products.
In order to return private capital from deposits in production, the expected profitability of the project should compensate for the risk, the long duration of investments and the inability to quickly return capital, Yulia Kuznetsova notes. At the same time, it should be possible to implement the project — we need affordable equipment, technologies, specialists, electricity and infrastructure, she lists.
— Moreover, companies can continue to keep operational reserves on deposits and at the same time expand production. This is a normal model. The goal is the growth of high—quality investments, and not the disappearance of deposits from the balance sheets of enterprises," the investment adviser emphasizes.
Denis Astafyev agrees that there is no need to mechanically push money out of deposits. According to him, these funds do not disappear from the economy. They are part of the banks' resource base and can be used to finance borrowers. And when paying for equipment or goods, money usually transfers from the buyer's account to the seller's account without leaving the banking system.
— It is not the volume of deposits itself that is dangerous, but the situation when expenses grow faster than the economy's ability to produce goods and services. Therefore, the rate cut should be based on a steady slowdown in inflation, and not on a desire to speed up the spending of savings at any cost," the expert points out.
Dam break
The problem of concentrating trillions of rubles on deposits is not only that companies refuse to modernize. This amount is an impressive monetary overhang, the main danger in the case of which is the risk of its sudden breakthrough.
The massive and simultaneous withdrawal of funds from bank deposits into the real sector is a classic macroeconomic shock that hits the economy from several sides at once. The most obvious negative consequence is hyperinflation and the depreciation of savings.
In addition, the collapse of the monetary overhang creates enormous pressure on the foreign exchange market. Firstly, in such cases, consumer imports are growing sharply (people are starting to buy foreign goods), which destabilizes the ruble exchange rate. Secondly, in anticipation of inflation, both citizens and businesses will be interested in protective assets.
The banking system operating on the principle of partial redundancy will also face problems. The money stored on deposits is used to make loans to other people or companies. And the simultaneous withdrawal of trillions of rubles will reduce the amount of cash, which will lead to a liquidity crisis. And the business is not ready for an emergency repayment of loans right now.
In the most negative scenario, panic will become widespread, which will require decisive action from the state. For example, to impose a moratorium on withdrawals. And the key danger here is undermining confidence in the financial system, which may take decades to restore.
To stop the outflow of money, the Central Bank may need a new cycle of monetary policy tightening, which will make loans for businesses needed for modernization even less affordable.
Deposits are not a warehouse of money withdrawn from the economy, but a source of funding for banks that issue loans and acquire financial assets, confirms Yulia Kuznetsova.
— When the company pays for the machine, the money usually goes to the supplier's account. They do not disappear from the banking system — their owner and purpose change. Therefore, the task is not to mechanically reduce deposits, but to create conditions under which expenses and lending grow in proportion to the capabilities of the economy," the editorial's interlocutor emphasizes.
According to Denis Astafyev, it makes the most sense to combine a consistent easing of monetary conditions with the elimination of supply constraints: infrastructure bottlenecks, staff shortages, and equipment difficulties.
"At the same time, the behavior of the population cannot be automatically transferred to companies, since the released corporate liquidity can be used for purchases, debt repayment or investments, and not necessarily to the consumer or foreign exchange market," he notes.
Yulia Kuznetsova also points to the need for a gradual reduction in the rate as inflation steadily weakens. It is also necessary to support projects that increase output and productivity and develop long-term financing (project loans, leasing, initial public offerings of bonds and shares can channel savings into investments). At the same time, it is important for the authorities to coordinate monetary and budgetary policies, since the simultaneous sharp reduction in the cost of credit and strong fiscal stimulus can disperse demand faster than supply.
But it should be understood that a massive transfer of funds from deposits to cash is a risk scenario, and not an automatic consequence of a rate cut, the Izvestia interlocutor adds. The probability of its occurrence depends on confidence in the ruble, inflation and exchange rate expectations, as well as external conditions.
— At the same time, corporate balances cannot be fully considered as potential consumer demand: companies have obligations to employees, the budget and suppliers, — the investment adviser summarizes.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»