The scandal between Ukraine and South Korea continues unabated. What you need to know
According to Seoul, the reason for the diplomatic dispute between the countries was Kiev's disclosure of confidential information about the transfer of prisoners of war from the DPRK to South Korea. The statement made by President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky at the UN General Assembly on September 23 has already led to the threat of lowering the level of diplomatic relations between the countries. The reason for the statements of Ukraine and South Korea and how the international context influenced the development of the conflict is in the Izvestia article.
Circumstances of the conflict
• Speaking at the UN General Assembly, Zelensky said that two North Korean soldiers captured in the Kursk region in January 2025 had been transferred to South Korea. Earlier, Kiev claimed that these were the first North Korean soldiers whom the Armed Forces managed to capture alive, and hoped to transfer them to Pyongyang in exchange for help in freeing the Armed Forces fighters from Russian captivity. However, as a result, it was decided to transfer the fighters to the Republic of Korea, where there is a principle of recognizing all Koreans as their citizens. The reaction of the South Korean authorities to Zelensky's statement was extremely harsh: Seoul said that the parties had agreed on strict confidentiality.
• Advisor to the President of Ukraine Dmitry Litvin publicly announced that there were no non-disclosure agreements with Seoul. This statement was perceived by the South Korean side as an accusation of the republic's authorities of lying: Seoul demanded a public apology from Kiev and warned of "additional measures" if Ukraine refuses to admit its mistake. The Ukrainian Foreign Ministry called the incident a diplomatic misunderstanding and hoped for an early resolution of the conflict. Later, the South Korean Foreign Ministry said it had received apologies from the Ukrainian side, but was not satisfied with their level, and threatened to recall its ambassador from Ukraine.
Causes of an acute reaction
• The reason for the sharp reaction from South Korea may be the fact that Ukraine's statement on the transfer of prisoners of war of North Korean citizens to South Korea occurred at a time when Seoul and Washington agreed to resume dialogue with Pyongyang to develop a lasting peace agreement between South Korea and the DPRK. Formally, the countries are still in conflict.
• Shortly before Zelensky's statement to the UN, Seoul announced that three soldiers of the republic had been injured by a mine explosion in the demilitarized zone that divides the countries of the Korean peninsula, accusing Pyongyang of violating the truce, but nevertheless the South Korean side was aiming for negotiations. But the transfer of prisoners by Ukraine to South Korea could dramatically change the situation in the diplomatic field, since the DPRK considers this as an abduction, and provoke an aggravation in relations between the countries.
• South Korea pursues a cautious international policy, trying to maintain a balance in its relations with other countries. That is why Seoul refuses to transfer weapons to Kiev, maintains trade relations with Moscow and is looking for an opportunity to resume diplomatic dialogue with Pyongyang. Seoul perceived Kiev's gross violation of confidentiality agreements regarding the transfer of prisoners as damaging trust in relations with Kiev and interfering in South Korea's national interests.
Positions of the parties
• The transfer of prisoners of war to another country does not comply well with the provisions of international law: neither Ukraine nor South Korea disclose the grounds for the transfer of soldiers and the termination of their status as prisoners of war, as required by the Geneva Convention III. Seoul and Kiev agreed on the transfer of DPRK citizens back in March 2026: at the same time, according to the parties, the opinion of the prisoners themselves was taken into account. According to Seoul, the transfer should have been kept secret also in order to protect the soldiers themselves and their relatives. It is not known how soon the DPRK military will be freed, as the usual procedure under the South Korean "Law on Protection and Support of Defectors" provides for an investigation of up to 90 days with a possible extension. In addition, there are questions about the physical and mental state of the prisoners who were in prolonged isolation.
• Until September 2026, Ukraine and South Korea reported on cooperation: in the summer, the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry announced that it had received $100 million from Seoul as humanitarian aid. Therefore, the Ukrainian press is discussing the version that the diplomatic conflict could have been provoked by the internal political crisis in Ukraine. Due to the struggle of the elites in Kiev, internal communication between the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry and the presidential office could have been disrupted, and the careless statement is explained by the fact that the text of Zelensky's speech was prepared by the speechwriters of the office of the President of Ukraine, and not the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, aware of the circumstances of the agreement.
In an attempt to gain increased support from European countries and the United States, Kiev uses publicity as a resource to put pressure on its partners. In this case, North Korean prisoners were also used as a diplomatic asset. Zelensky's statement was supposed to show that Ukraine is facing several opponents at once, and therefore it needs more extensive support. At the same time, Russia previously confirmed that the DPRK military participated in the liberation of the Kursk region, and only there. The territory where the DPRK forces were involved is of fundamental importance here.
Kiev has repeatedly called on Seoul to provide Ukraine not only with financial support, but also with weapons. South Korea limited itself to humanitarian aid. Now there is a question about the recall of the South Korean ambassador from Ukraine and the possible lowering of the level of diplomatic relations between the countries. At the same time, Seoul will not further reduce the level of support for Kiev, since it has to reckon with Washington and Brussels.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»