Paper figure: carriers are in no hurry to switch to electronic documents
A month after electronic invoices became mandatory, the share of carriers who switched to digital increased by one and a half times. Nevertheless, a significant number of logistics companies still prefer "paper", and those that have switched to a new format often face difficulties. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
There is growth
During the month, the share of carriers with a qualified electronic signature required for processing documents in digital form increased to 16%. This follows from an analysis conducted by the Association of Carriers and the ATI logistics platform.SU, which was reviewed by Izvestia. In late August and early September, market participants actively switched to digital. However, this growth slowed down later, the study notes.
As of the end of September, the number of digitally signed logistics companies increased from 22.6% to 27.5% compared to August, while the number of such sole proprietorships increased from 11.3% to 20.4%. As for the self-employed who refused paper documents, their number is still small: 2.4% in September versus 0.5% as of the end of August.
At the end of September, 26% of freight forwarders had an electronic signature (22.2% a month ago), and 19.7% of cargo owners (16.1% in August).
The largest percentage of "digitized" carriers is noted in Chuvashia (23.8%) and the Smolensk region. Their share currently stands at 16.9% in Moscow, 18.5% in the Moscow Region, 18.4% in St. Petersburg, and 12.4% in the Krasnodar Territory (the region with the largest number of registered cargo carriers). The least number of logistics companies switched to digital in Dagestan — only 5.7%.
The slowdown is due to the clarification of the situation regarding sanctions for the lack of electronic documents, industry experts say.
— The week before September 1 and the week after gave more carriers with signatures than the next three weeks. After the deadline, the market slowed down, and the reason is clear: there is a moratorium on document checks on the road until March 1," said Andrey Leshin, head of the Association of Carriers.
The number of carriers with a real electronic bill of lading has increased from 1,059 to 2,715 in the last 30 days, said the founder and director of ATI.SU Svyatoslav Wilde. In three weeks, 1,423 carriers switched from testing to a real electronic document, he added.
— Further growth depends on the entire chain: the shipper, the carrier, the warehouse and the recipient. The more counterparties require an electronic document from each other, the faster they become the norm," said Svyatoslav Wilde.
Speed and transparency
Logistics companies confirm the growing trend in the number of "digitized" counterparties. Thus, according to the federal transport and logistics company Byte Transit, at the beginning of last month, only about 5% of customers were ready to work under the new rules, and now their share has increased to 8%. According to Viktor Kalinin, Head of the Transport Logistics Department at PEC, the number of contractors of carriers and forwarders who switched to electronic transportation documents increased by 30% in late August and the first half of September.
He noted that if the sender, recipient and carrier are ready to exchange electronic waybills, processing can be doubled compared to the preparation of paper documents. At the same time, the company can also achieve the effect of reducing the proportion of routine operations related to transportation documents, Viktor Kalinin emphasized.
— The main thing is that the transition to mandatory electronic documents along with mandatory registers of carriers and forwarders will increase the transparency of the industry. It will be impossible to hide part of the supply chain, and there will be fewer companies dumping through savings on taxes and fees," he told Izvestia.
Difficulties of transition
The industry is adapting to digital requirements, as evidenced by a multiple increase in the volume of electronic document processing, Loginet logistics platform said. The results of the first month of autumn show that the process of implementing digital tools is stabilizing, although there are still technical failures related to both the operation of the operators' infrastructure and non-standard scenarios during transportation, the company noted.
The share of digital market participants is growing, but many carriers, especially in the regions, continue to work only with paper documents, said Artyom Vaskanyan, Deputy General Director for Logistics at NC Logistic, a 3PL operator. According to him, some players are trying to use both formats at the same time, because they still do not fully trust electronic document management, or they do not have time to rebuild internal processes. While the market is at the stage of adaptation, the expert emphasizes.
— The main difficulty now lies not so much in the connection to the system itself, but in the correct configuration of the process. Market participants need to correctly define the roles of all parties involved in transportation, understand who should sign the relevant title and at what stage, and set up interaction between their own accounting systems and operators," Artyom Vaskanyan told Izvestia.
In practice, there are still many questions about the distribution of roles, especially for small companies, he stressed. For example, the shipper in the bill of lading is a party to the contract of carriage, and not necessarily the warehouse from which the goods are actually shipped. Similar issues arise with persons engaged in loading and receiving cargo. If the roles are defined incorrectly, the errors are then transferred to the electronic document, the Izvestia interlocutor explained.
— Now there is actually a full-fledged test period. Market participants are trying to adapt internal processes to new requirements and integrate into a given electronic document management system. In September, the process of switching to electronic transportation documents really accelerated noticeably, but the market will still need time for this system to work stably," Artyom Vaskanyan believes.
Difficulties when working with electronic documents arise on the part of the consignees: not all customers have figured out the new procedure yet, said Viktor Kalinin. According to him, companies often delay the signing of the third titles of the electronic consignment note, which records information about the acceptance of the cargo: date and time, condition of the goods, discrepancies in quantity and quality. Because of this, drivers stand idle while unloading, which is especially critical, for example, when delivering to retail chains, he emphasizes.
— Current legislation requires that the weight, dimensions and packaging of the cargo be indicated in the documents when receiving the cargo. Transportation companies face inaccuracies in these data, especially when dealing with bulk shipments. There are not always scales and equipment at the loading sites, therefore, approximate information is entered into the documents based on customer data, which is subsequently checked by the forwarder at the warehouse," said Viktor Kalinin.
He also noted that a mechanism for correcting already signed electronic documents is important for business. Now, when the data in the order application or the order to the forwarder is changed, the documents have to be redone.
— We have proposed to include additional titles in these documents for making adjustments. This will allow changing the conditions — the route, the recipient, the service — without revoking the original document, eliminating double document flow," Viktor Kalinin told Izvestia.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»