The Magic of Numbers: carriers were not ready for digital documents
Despite the fact that electronic waybills become mandatory on September 1, most road freight carriers were not ready to switch to digital. At the moment, only one in ten Russian carriers has received the electronic signature required for processing such documents in digital form. Izvestia found out how this situation will affect the logistics market.
With a score of 1:10
As of the end of August, only 9.8% of carriers have a qualified electronic signature required for signing documents in digital form. This follows from an analysis conducted by the Association of Carriers and the logistics platform. ATI.SU . During the study, the results of which were reviewed by Izvestia, it turned out that out of more than 119 thousand carriers registered on this platform, only 11,634 companies had an electronic signature uploaded to the participant's passport.
The share of logistics companies with such a signature is 22.6%, and 11.3% among individual entrepreneurs. As for the self-employed, only 0.5% of carriers with this status received an electronic signature. Of the forwarders registered on the ATI platform.SU, only 22.2% have it, and 16.1% of cargo owners have also issued a digital signature.
The situation with the digital signature of carriers varies greatly depending on the region, the study notes. For example, out of 1,440 logistics companies in the Smolensk region, 15.6% of companies have it, out of 3,369 St. Petersburg carriers, only 12.7% have issued it. On the ATI platform.There are 6,048 SU transport companies from the Moscow region — only 12.5% of them have a digital signature. Of the 6,514 Moscow motor cargo carriers, 11.6% of the companies received it. The smallest share of firms with such a signature was recorded in the Rostov Region (9%), Krasnodar Territory (7.4%), Buryatia (5.3%) and Dagestan (2.7%).
"These figures show how heterogeneously carriers have approached the mandatory transition to electronic document management, and where readiness for it is now noticeably lower than average," said Andrey Leshin, head of the Association of Carriers.
According to the founder and director of the ATI logistics platform.SU Svyatoslav Wilde, with the introduction of the mandatory electronic bill of lading on September 1, the market will have to carry out a large volume of transportation daily through electronic document management.
— Therefore, the result will depend on the coordinated work of the entire chain: the shipper, the carrier, the driver, the warehouse and the recipient. Companies need to secure the signatories, check the data exchange with counterparties and the procedure for dealing with failures," he stressed.
So far, verbally
The Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation notes that at a meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin in June, a proposal was supported to introduce a non-fined period for road transport without electronic transport documents (EDS). The Ministry of Internal Affairs and Rosstransnadzor will limit themselves to an oral remark instead of fines for the absence of electronic transportation documents, the Russian Ministry of Transport said in a statement.
— It is important to understand that the non-fined period does not exempt carriers and forwarders from the obligation to issue electronic transportation documents. It only allows employees of the State Traffic Inspectorate and Rostransnadzor not to apply fines for failure to submit documents in electronic form," said Artem Yurenkov, Director of the Digital Development Department of the Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation.
Difficulties of transition
Large businesses, especially in cities with millions of residents, have prepared for the transition to electronic waybills, but if we look at the market as a whole, the situation is more complicated, especially in the regional segment, said Artem Vaskanyan, Deputy General Director for Logistics at 3PL operator NC Logistic. According to him, there are still market participants who have not fully understood the basic requirements of the new system. For some companies, a full-fledged transition is actually starting only now, the expert noted.
— At the same time, many small and even medium-sized carriers assume that they can operate according to the old rules until the spring of 2027. Therefore, starting from September 1, part of the market is likely to continue to process paper documents, and for some time individual processes will be carried out in parallel, both electronically and in paper form," Artyom Vaskanyan told Izvestia.
According to his estimates, 40-50% of the regional carrier market is not yet ready for a full-fledged transition. An electronic bill of lading requires the correct allocation of roles, setting up processes between the shipper, carrier, recipient and other participants, as well as ensuring the correct signing of documents. For some companies, it is almost impossible to do this without the participation of an IT specialist, Artyom Vaskanyan emphasizes.
— It is worth mentioning some industries, in particular the food industry, where the requirements for digital paperwork are particularly strict and supply chains are complex. Already, some cargo owners are making it clear that from September 1 they are not ready to load the transport if the carrier or other participants in the chain cannot work with the EPD. This may lead to a decrease in the supply of transport in certain directions," he said.
Currently, only 10-20% of carriers are ready to fully operate under the new rules, according to Alexey Shpikelman, General Director of the federal transport and logistics company Byte Transit. At the same time, cargo owners have already begun to require carriers to be ready for electronic document management, so companies are rapidly learning from each other's experience and refining their processes, he noted.
— Many market participants have not yet appointed responsible employees, have not set up the necessary processes, have not issued electronic signatures and machine-readable powers of attorney. Technical failures of digital services create additional difficulties," said Alexey Shpikelman.
The introduction of a non-penalized period until March 2027 will avoid a complete shutdown of the market, he believes. At the same time, the expert does not rule out some delays and organizational difficulties in September. However, during the month, the main processes will gradually improve, Alexey Shpikelman believes.
Market Transformation
The transition to EPD is primarily aimed at increasing the transparency and openness of the road freight market, where there are quite a lot of different "gray" schemes, says Anton Shaparin, Vice President of the National Automobile Union (NAS). The results of the study clearly demonstrate the unwillingness of this business to whitewash.
— Electronic document management is, first of all, a tool for monitoring carriers by fiscal authorities. Unfortunately, schemes where transportation is carried out in cash or payment is made by ordinary transfer to a card are quite common. This allows unscrupulous carriers to reduce the tariff by at least 22%, removing VAT from the cost of transportation," said Anton Shaparin.
In his opinion, such companies will delay the transition to digital until the last moment in order to keep tariffs low. However, starting next spring, with the proper level of government control, they will have to abandon such schemes, he believes.
— Not all carriers, whose economic business model was based on low rates, will be able to safely switch to a fully transparent model. Apparently, about a third of the players will eventually leave this market," the NAS vice president believes.
The new rules will certainly force a number of carriers to leave the market, said Taras Koval, vice president of the Association of Transport Experts and Specialists. However, this will not be widespread, rather, the new requirements will lead to certain changes in the very structure of the freight market, he believes.
— It is possible that some small carriers will leave long-distance intercity transportation, concentrating on short flights "locally". This way they will reduce the risk of getting checked by regulatory authorities. Therefore, now the business has taken a kind of wait-and-see attitude in order to figure out how to proceed. If EPD is really tightly controlled, carriers will receive the necessary electronic signatures relatively quickly and switch to digital. But if the control is formal and selective, the logistics business will continue to work with paper," said Taras Koval.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»