Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Age teachers (and their share is only increasing over time) are not a problem of the education system, but a valuable resource. Older teachers, contrary to the myth that they experience burnout and loss of interest in their work after the age of 60, turned out to be more motivated than their younger colleagues. "Izvestia" investigated what advantages age-old teachers have and how to keep them in school.

What are the results of the study

The Moscow State Psychological and Pedagogical University (MGPPU) has prepared a study on the longevity of teachers. ""An analytical report on the results of an online survey of teachers (available to Izvestia) was conducted by Anna Shvedovskaya, Associate Professor of the Department of "Age Psychology named after Professor L. F. Obukhova" of the Moscow State Pedagogical University and Valery Fedorov, Senior lecturer at the Department of Social Psychology of Development of the Faculty of Social Psychology of the Moscow State Pedagogical University.

The survey results showed that teachers aged 60-74 retain a high interest in work and satisfaction with it in all areas — preschool, school, secondary vocational, higher and additional education. In addition, the average interest in the teaching profession among teachers aged 60-74 was 8.57–8.97 points out of 10 and was higher than that of their younger colleagues.

Учитель в День знаний
Photo: RIA Novosti/Anton Vergun

Professional goals don't disappear with age either — it's another matter that they change their focus. Transfer of experience and mentoring become more important for an age teacher. At the age of 60-74, 45.4% of kindergarten workers, 39% of school teachers and 62.8% of university teachers indicated this goal.

However, there was a desire to reduce the workload while continuing to work: 44.3% of school teachers and 51.8% of university staff reported this.

In general, the majority of teachers aged 60+ do not want to leave the profession. The share of school teachers who plan to continue working after retirement age is 60.5%, and 83.2% among university teachers. Almost no one is ready to completely stop working: from 0.7% of university employees to 4.8% of teachers in general education institutions.

And the emotional burden, contrary to stereotypes, does not increase depending on age. On the contrary, teachers aged 60-74 report less anxiety, stress and work-related fatigue than their colleagues aged 45-59, according to the analytical report.

Another thing is that the high professional confidence of older teachers is combined with a pronounced lack of digital skills. Among older teachers, 38.6% of preschool workers, 23.2% of schools and 24.8% of universities noted it. But this cannot be a reason to abandon the professional resource of the older generation, Anna Shvedovskaya emphasized in an interview with "Izvestia". On the contrary, this is a specific area where the school should provide educational assistance.

Учитель за ноутбуком
Photo: RIA Novosti/Sergey Pyatakov

But there is a certain paradox in matters of health and work organization. The authors of the study note that many senior teachers point out the difficulties with this, but they are much less likely to perceive this as an obstacle to teaching.

In general, it is important to pay attention to this category of employees: in schools, the proportion of teachers over the age of 60 increased by 5% from 2016 to 2024 and reached 16.4%. In other countries, by the way, the trends are similar — for example, in 2023, more than a third of primary and secondary education teachers in the countries of the Organization for Cooperation and Economic Development were over 50 years old. And this is against the background of the fact that public opinion towards age teachers is often ruthless: behind the numbers in the passport they also see a decrease in resources, deterioration of health, difficulties in mastering new technologies and the need to leave the profession. This is only partially true, and the study shows a much more complex configuration of professional longevity.

Shvedovskaya and Fedorov point out that a group of teachers aged 45-59 turned out to be a zone of increased professional stress: they often talk about emotional stress, fatigue, uncertainty about the future, a request for a balance between work and personal life, etc.

Why Age Educators are a resource

The study emphasizes that the professional longevity of teachers should be considered as a resource of the educational system. Mentoring potential is especially important, which is interesting for both the school and the 60+ teachers themselves.

Ученики в классе
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

Professional longevity, according to Anna Shvedovskaya, is one of the factors of the personnel stability of the school and the education system as a whole.

— It is important not just to keep a person in the workplace for as long as possible. It is important in what conditions the teacher continues to work: whether he retains interest in the profession, whether he feels in demand, whether the workload corresponds to his capabilities, whether he sees a further professional trajectory for himself," she explained.

Teachers aged 60-74 are not at all the group that massively seeks to leave the profession, said the interlocutor of the editorial board. And this is a specific reserve for overcoming the personnel shortage: if a teacher is ready and wants to continue working, the system should provide him with such an opportunity, including through a more flexible professional trajectory. By this, Anna Shvedovskaya means, for example, reducing the workload while maintaining professional activity in the roles of mentor, methodologist, author of educational programs, etc.

However, one of the reasons why teachers do not retire is its small size, said Irina Abankina, professor at the HSE Institute of Education. She recalled that the trade union had tried to achieve the establishment of an industry pension system, but so far this had not happened.

Пенсия
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet

— Age teachers receive both a pension and a salary, and try to take on a fairly high classroom load, if such an opportunity exists. In such a situation, of course, their earnings are higher, and there is almost no motive to retire in the face of a noticeable rise in the cost of living," the expert said. — But the situation may be changing, because the education system has been overtaken by a demographic pit. There are fewer students, and the reduction in their number will continue. We do not know what the policy will be: whether they will maintain such class occupancy, while reducing teachers, or not.

Meanwhile, Larisa Solodilova, chairman of the All-Russian Trade Union of Education, drew attention to the fact that so far the number of age teachers is only growing, although in five years the total number of teachers has decreased by almost 22 thousand. The number of teachers of retirement age has increased by more than 30 thousand. However, according to the expert, continuing to work should be a free professional choice of the person himself, and not a forced decision due to insufficient retirement income or lack of teachers at school. And keeping older teachers in the profession should not replace the policy of attracting young staff, she added.

However, often schools themselves simply do not have the opportunity to replace teachers of retirement age, said Alexey Tishchenko, a leading researcher at the Central Research Institute of the Presidential Academy. Many young teachers in general education institutions do not stay long, and it is easier for middle-aged teachers to find another job with a good salary and less workload.

Преподаватель во время занятий
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

But the teachers' resource is not infinitely reproducible without proper support, Anna Shvedovskaya emphasized. Flexible work organization, respect for age and experience, creation of opportunities for mentoring, digital support, and reduction of excessive workload are important. And most importantly, continuing professional activity should not be a necessity, but a meaningful and supported choice of a teacher.

— We should talk about creating a system of flexible conditions that allow us to retain experienced personnel in education. If a teacher is willing and able to continue working, the task of the system is not to lose his professional potential, but to find the most effective form of his further participation," she said.

Does the education system see 60+ teachers as a resource?

The conditions for professional longevity do not begin at the age of 60, but are actually formed from the moment a person enters the profession, Valery Fedorov noted.

— Personnel policy, in our opinion, should become not just age-oriented, but trajectory—oriented, - said the interlocutor of the editorial office. — The young teacher needs to be helped to enter the profession and stay in it; the middle—aged teacher needs to prevent the accumulation of overload and professional exhaustion; the older one needs to be given the opportunity to flexibly use the accumulated experience and, if necessary, gradually change the format of professional activity.

Учителя
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

At the same time, there is a certain contradiction in modern personnel policy, the researcher noted. It is often said about the need for school rejuvenation, difficulties with digital technologies, but not about the human and professional resource of senior teachers for the education system, which consists in a continuing and growing interest in work, as well as vast experience, measured over decades. Moreover, the survey showed that the dependence "the older the teacher, the worse his professional well-being" simply does not exist.

— Therefore, we would not oppose the rejuvenation of teaching staff and the retention of senior teachers. The school needs different generations," Valery Fedorov emphasized. — The task of personnel policy is not to replace one generation with another, but to preserve the personnel potential of the system and ensure the continuity of generations. The important question here is: how to ensure that their experience, professional stability and mentoring potential work for the development of the school and help overcome the personnel shortage?

According to the author of the study, so far this approach is more likely to manifest itself in individual practices and initiatives than in a fully formed systemic policy.

Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

The problem is also that senior teachers often do not find understanding from school leaders, said Dmitry Kazakov, chairman of the "Teacher" trade union. He knows of a case where a teacher of retirement age asked for health reasons to reduce his workload to 0.5 percent, but the director refused and offered to resign.

— However, is this considered discrimination? I'm not sure. This could have happened to any other teacher," suggested the source. — Currently, schools have difficult working conditions due to heavy workload. And everyone needs to reduce their workload, not just older teachers. Everyone should also increase their salaries to two minimum wages and above. Then both age teachers and young people will work at the school, and senior teachers will be able to share their experience. Now, due to the heavy workload, it is extremely difficult to even organize such mentoring work.

Larisa Solodilova added that the education system needs professional longevity programs. The guarantees provided for by them should be consolidated in industry agreements, collective agreements and local acts with the participation of trade union organizations, she concluded.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast