Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The Kaliningrad Region reported that about 500 teachers from other regions of the Russian Federation moved to the region during the year. And not only from the north, as it was before, but also from Central Russia. In this region, as in a number of others, attention to teacher migration is quite high — this is one of the ways to solve the personnel problem there. Izvestia investigated how the subjects of the Russian Federation are fighting for teachers and how the migration of teachers in Russia works.

How teachers are attracted to the Kaliningrad region

Svetlana Truseneva, Minister of Education of the Kaliningrad Region, said that "mostly Siberians come to the region — the Tomsk Region, Novosibirsk, Irkutsk Region," as well as people from the Arkhangelsk and Murmansk regions. From there, according to her, they go, among other things, for comfortable climatic conditions. And this year, the relocation of teachers from Central Russia has also become a special feature — previously there was no such trend.

Currently, the total number of employees of the education system in the Kaliningrad region is 15 thousand people, the head of the department said. 7.5 thousand of them are teaching staff. Svetlana Truseneva stated that all places are staffed, "the workload is distributed, all teachers are certified."

At the same time, according to the Teacher trade union, based on official statistics from the Ministry of Education, in the Kaliningrad region at the beginning of last school year, teachers on average worked at 1.5 rates: 4,734 teachers filled 7,163 vacancies.

Линейка
Photo: RIA Novosti/Alexander Podgorchuk

The continued "certain tension in certain subjects" was also recognized by the Minister of Education of the region. First of all, it is the Russian language and literature, mathematics and computer science.

It is worth noting that the Kaliningrad Region does have a large list of support measures for new and incoming teachers. Young teachers under the age of 35, in particular, are paid from 100 to 200 thousand rubles for their first employment, depending on their education. In addition, relocation compensation is provided in the amount of up to 100 thousand rubles and rental housing up to 15 thousand rubles per month. And some of the teachers can apply for a housing certificate of 2.5 million rubles. There is also a "call a friend" or "bring a colleague" payment for teachers who have attracted specialists from another region. For this they give a payment of 50 thousand rubles. The federal program "Zemsky Uchitel" is also being implemented.

Moreover, the work on "hunting" teachers from other regions has been going on for a long time. Back in 2023, the director of one of the rural schools in Mordovia told the media that teachers were "being sent photos of their future homes from Kaliningrad."

Izvestia sent a request for a policy on attracting teachers from other regions to the Ministry of Education of the Kaliningrad Region. No response has been received at the time of publication.

However, other regions are also engaged in attracting teachers. Dmitry Kazakov, chairman of the Teacher trade union, who himself moved from the Nizhny Novgorod region, first to the Moscow region, and then to Moscow, noted that in addition to the two capitals, teachers also travel to the northern regions, where teachers receive high salaries.

Трудовая книжка
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

But if teachers move to Moscow and St. Petersburg for permanent residence, then in the northern regions it is a "teacher's watch". At the same time, he clarified, the Moscow region really purposefully attracts teachers from other regions, offering primarily housing or compensation for accommodation.

— The salary in the Moscow region is not very high, but due to the living conditions it is possible to attract from other regions. I worked in the Moscow region for a bit, for about a year. But after talking with colleagues, I saw that the percentage of teachers from neighboring regions is quite high. And there is some kind of advertisement regarding these conditions," the source told Izvestia.

How does teacher migration work?

One of the few studies on teacher migration in Russia was conducted in the Kaliningrad Region in 2024 by the staff of the I. Kant Baltic Federal University. It was dedicated to the relocation of teachers to the region and how this affects the economic security of the region. The researchers conducted 14 interviews with 10 relocated teachers, two principals, and two representatives of the professional community.

It turned out that teachers were attracted to the region by the climate, ecology, the "European" image and historical and cultural heritage. Moreover, it was noted that the move often took place after tourist trips.

Школа
Photo: IZVESTIA/Pavel Volkov

One of the most common reasons is to reunite with relatives. In addition, the researchers identified the so-called ruler method, when young university graduates go (often with friends) to work "the further the better."

That is, the choice of the region was almost unrelated to professional reasons: the motives turned out to be vital, not career.

According to the researchers' calculations, in the coming years, the influx of teachers from other regions of the country to the Kaliningrad region will only partially cover the personnel shortage, the timing of which depends on the migration scenario and how much the region will be able to use its own staff. Moreover, the total migration to the region, according to the authors, is still higher than the number of teachers who have moved, which only increases the burden on the educational system. At the same time, the employment and retention of local graduates of pedagogical universities and vocational education institutions turned out to be quite low — only about 40%. The researchers concluded that it is much more important not to increase the influx of teachers from other regions, but to increase the recruitment and retention of their own graduates. And from the point of view of migration, it is necessary to attract the most qualified specialists in a targeted way, promoting professional motives for moving.

Nina Fedina, Candidate of Pedagogical Sciences, Rector of Lipetsk State Pedagogical University named after P. P. Semenov-Tyan-Shansky, prepared another major work on this topic in 2021, together with her team, who studied the migration of teachers and graduates of pedagogical universities between regions, its causes, practice and consequences. More than 3,000 teachers, 1,100 graduates, school principals, rectors and experts from 18 regions were interviewed.

Учитель
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

This work indicates that teacher migration has a pronounced "centripetal" character, as well as in the economy as a whole. The main vector is Moscow, the Moscow region, St. Petersburg, large regional centers and economically strong regions.

Among the regions there are donor ones (the Lipetsk region is one of them, also called the Siberian, Far Eastern and part of the central regions of the Russian Federation), from where teachers leave for the capital and the "attractive" cities.

At the same time, graduates of pedagogical universities are more mobile than current teachers. The study noted that more than 30% of pedagogical students are thinking about moving to another region, and about 12% of already working teachers. At the same time, the majority of teachers (over 50%) do not plan to leave their place of residence at all.

The respondents cited the salary level as the main motive for moving.: It was indicated by about 50% of graduates and more than 37% of working teachers. This was followed by housing conditions, standard of living and infrastructure, opportunities for personal and professional growth, climate and ecology, attractiveness of the city, as well as family circumstances. And only the last reason is the material and technical base of the school and the staff.

Квартира
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet

The monograph does not talk about direct "hunting" of teachers: rather, the study describes regional competition through differences in salaries, housing conditions, living standards, and support measures.

Basically, as Sergey Zair-Bek, associate professor at the HSE Institute of Education, explained, teacher migration between regions is a common market process (but with certain specifics).

— For example, teachers are mostly women — a little less than 90% of them. Some of these women are married to military men, and therefore migrate from region to region with their husbands and their families," he told Izvestia.

Of course, there is also a targeted migration of teachers, primarily related to the salary level. However, for school teachers, the desire to migrate to another region is rather uncharacteristic, the expert added.

— In our research, we have recorded that teachers are very often tied to their workplace, to their school, and rarely change it. Especially teachers with experience. This is a more typical behavior for young people, but so far we do not have reliable data that would clearly record this as a pattern," the source said.

Школа
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

The main reason that teacher "turnover", that is, their transfer to other schools, is generally not a very common phenomenon in this profession, is that employees are mostly in the group over 40 years old.

Meanwhile, Natalia Tarasova, a leading researcher at the Scientific and Educational Development Center of the Higher School of Economics of the Presidential Academy, said that the migration of teaching staff in Russia is gradually becoming a systematic, albeit rather complex process.

— In regions with the most acute personnel shortage, the burden on teachers often increases to one and a half to two rates, which additionally stimulates the search for a more attractive job. No less important are social conditions: the availability of housing, transport and medical care, the availability of places in kindergartens and schools — in general, everything that determines the quality of life. Opportunities for professional and career growth, continuing education and advanced training are also important," the specialist said.

Alexey Tishchenko, a leading researcher at the Central Research Institute of the Presidential Academy, added that teachers are motivated to migrate by "significant wage differentiation between the subjects of the Russian Federation, cities and villages." Moreover, some teachers are potentially ready to change their profession, but it is easier for them to go to work at a school in another region with better conditions than to look for work in a new field at their place of residence.

How migration affects regions

The LSPU study notes that teacher migration has a particularly bad effect on donor regions: staff shortages are increasing, teaching staff are aging, the burden on remaining teachers is increasing, and the quality of education is declining.

Школа
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

But it's not good for the country as a whole either. The imbalance is increasing: there is an excess of staff in large centers, and an acute shortage in the periphery. Migration in this sense only exacerbates regional inequality.

According to Natalia Tarasova, territories with difficult climatic conditions, population decline and insufficient social support are particularly affected: these are certain regions of the Far Eastern Federal District, the Altai Territory, the Omsk Region, etc.

Alexey Tishchenko, however, recalled that at the same time there are government measures to encourage the labor migration of teachers: the Zemsky Uchitel program, which encourages teachers to move to work in villages, towns, small towns and closed administrative-territorial formations (BUT), with a doubled payment when resettling in the regions of the Far East, DNR, LNR, Zaporizhia and Kherson regions.

According to Natalia Tarasova, in 2024-2025, teachers began to move more actively to rural areas and small towns. Moreover, the nature of such mobility is changing.

Школа
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Vinogradov

— Teachers who are ready to participate in the program are increasingly trying not to move to the other side of the country, but to find a new place of work in their own or neighboring region. The willingness for professional mobility is growing, but at the same time people are striving to maintain their usual social and family ties," she explained.

Izvestia sent a request to the Ministry of Education of the Russian Federation. No response had been received at the time of publication.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast