Short report: UNESCO ignores the death of Russian military personnel
UNESCO has released a report on journalists who died in the line of duty, which did not include many Russian war correspondents. Among the "forgotten" are the military commanders of Izvestia, Semyon Eremin and Alexander Martemyanov. At the session of the Intergovernmental Council of the organization, Russia intends to seek inclusion in the statistics of all dead domestic reporters. The Russian Foreign Ministry points to the bias of such reports, as their methodology is largely based on data from Western non-governmental organizations. Experts also emphasize the politicization of UNESCO itself, whose headquarters are located in Paris.
New UNESCO report
On November 19, the 35th session of the Intergovernmental Council of the International Program for the Development of Communication opened at UNESCO's Paris headquarters. The report of the organization's Director General Khaled El—Anani on the safety of journalists in 2024-2025 is on the agenda.
The document names 189 media workers who died in the performance of their professional duties. Most of them — 127 people — lost their lives in areas of armed conflict, with 50 victims of drone strikes. In seven cases, as noted in the report, several media employees were killed during one attack. In this report, Khaled el-Anani once again recalled the UN Security Council resolution adopted in 2015, which protects media workers in war zones.
However, this report, like the previous one for 2022-2023, again ignores the deaths of a number of Russian journalists. The UNESCO statistics, in particular, did not include Izvestia reporters Semyon Eremin and Alexander Martemyanov, both victims of attacks by Ukrainian drones. In addition, the report does not contain data on other media workers killed by the Ukrainian Armed Forces, such as Yulia Kuznetsova, editor—in-chief of Narodnaya Gazeta, whose life was cut short in the Kursk region during the invasion of Ukrainian troops, as well as Nikita Goldin, military commander of the Zvezda TV channel, who died in the spring of 2025. At the time of the shelling, he was with cameraman Andrei Panov and the driver of the film crew, Alexander Sirkeli, whose names were eventually added to the list. Alexander Fedorchak, a correspondent of Izvestia, also came under the same fire.
— They included Sasha Fedorchak, but did not include Nikita Goldin, who died with Sasha. But their charter says: "If a journalist was purposefully killed for his work." Both Sasha and Nikita were deliberately killed. They were hunted by the Ukrainian Armed Forces. We are a red mark for them," said Alexey Poltoranin, a correspondent for Izvestia.
In October 2023, Poltoranin himself was wounded, along with military commander Yevgeny Bykovsky and Alexander Martemyanov, when they came to film the aftermath of the shelling of Donetsk.
There is another problem: in the lists, opposite the names of even those journalists whose circumstances of death are reliably known, there is often a note "No information" in the corresponding column. For example, the Beirut bureau of the Al-Mayadeen TV channel lost three reporters in Israeli strikes, but this information is not included in the report.
"We are obliged to achieve justice for the families of the dead journalists, to restore justice to our colleagues who gave their lives while fulfilling their professional duty," said the head of the Beirut bureau of the Al TV channel.‑Mayadin" by Roni Alpha.
The Russian journalistic community, unwilling to put up with this situation, sent official appeals to CEO Khaled El-Anani. Izvestia also sent a letter to the head of UNESCO demanding that all the dead Russian journalists, including employees of the media holding, be included in the organization's report. In response, UNESCO stated that before including the names of the dead Izvestia journalists in the report, the organization plans to find out the circumstances of their deaths. Senior spokeswoman Claire O'Hagan said the organization is now "consulting with accredited organizations."
"The deaths of journalists are included in our statistics after several international and regional organizations involved in the protection of press freedom, media freedom and human rights confirm that the death of a journalist could be related to his professional activities," the response says.
Engagement of UNESCO reports
However, the methodology followed by UNESCO is something that raises special questions. The organization's secretariat receives reports on the alleged death of a media employee from three main categories of senders: UN Member States, field offices and field missions, as well as from specialized observers. Initially registered cases are included in the internal monitoring list. However, in order for the case to eventually be included in the official report, the fact must be confirmed by non-governmental organizations that cooperate with UNESCO. Among them, for example, the Committee to Protect Journalists and Reporters Without Borders (both organizations are considered undesirable in Russia).
— She (methodology. — Ed.) suggests relying only on those sources that are Western non—governmental organizations (NGOs), that is, Western NGOs that rely on direct financing from structures such as the US State Department and NATO," Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova told Izvestia. — An organization that unites states does not take into account the data of the states themselves, but takes into account the information of a "narrow" group of certain NGOs — to put it mildly, biased and long ago tainted by unscrupulous behavior.
A similar situation has already arisen during the preparation of the previous report for 2022-2023. Then the heads of the leading Russian media sent official appeals to the Director General Audre Azoulay demanding to restore justice and stop the practice of selective approach to tragedies in the journalistic environment. As a result, at the IPRC meeting in Paris in November 2024, the draft of that report was not adopted precisely because of the lack of consensus and obvious political bias in counting the dead media employees. Thus, the report of the current CEO inherited distortions, becoming an unreliable source of data on the security situation of journalists. In this situation, Russia intends to seek a revision of the methodology for recording the deaths of media representatives and ensuring proper accountability of international officials.
In addition, Russia plans to separately focus the attention of the UNESCO secretariat and the IPRC member countries on the numerous appeals from the editorial offices of the media and professional associations addressed to the Director General with demands to restore justice to their deceased colleagues. On behalf of the Russian journalistic community, Peter Fedorov, Head of the Directorate of International Relations of the All-Russian State Television and Radio Broadcasting Company, plans to address the UNESCO leadership at the session of the Intergovernmental Council.
Reports such as the one recently submitted by UNESCO only once again demonstrate the interference and double standards that such organizations are guided by, Roberto Zuniga, head of the Viva Nicaragua — Canal 13 news channel, said in an interview with Izvestia. According to him, they serve as tools of those who have declared themselves the owners of "absolute truth" and impeccable representatives of journalism.
Either the authors of the report were selected based on their political beliefs, or they were subjected to pressure from the authorities, said Gunnar Beck, an ex-member of the European Parliament. Of course, international organizations are subject to influence from the leading world powers, as well as large multinational corporations. At the same time, according to him, of course, it also matters in which country their headquarters are located.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»