Troika of the Century: Putin, Xi and Trump discuss new security architecture
The final day of the APEC summit in Shenzhen went far beyond the traditional economic agenda: on November 19, the first ever meeting of the leaders of Russia, the United States and China took place there. Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Donald Trump emphasized the role of the three largest world powers and their responsibility for the future. However, there were different approaches behind the general statements about strategic stability. China has set ambitious goals, including the complete elimination of nuclear weapons. The United States promoted a more pragmatic risk reduction agenda, while Russia emphasized the need to strengthen international law and the inadmissibility of interference by external structures. The media has already called the meeting a marker of the end of the era of the unipolar world: each side has received its own strategic gain.
Bilateral contacts at the APEC Summit
The final day of the 33rd APEC Summit will be remembered not only for economic declarations, but also for a series of important meetings. Xi Jinping, as host, talked with each of the summit participants in one way or another (21 official delegations came to him), discussing a wide range of issues: from reducing duties to the situation on the Korean peninsula. And Donald Trump managed to discuss the future of trade in North America with the Prime Minister of Canada and the President of Mexico. Vladimir Putin also has about a dozen contacts, and not the most mundane ones. Among them are South Korean leader Lee Jae—myung and Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi, whom the Russian leader met for the first time in seven years. The conversation took place against the background of a noticeable cooling of bilateral relations after the president's recent trip to the Kuril Islands.
Most of all, the world community followed the dialogue between Russia, China and the United States, which took place in various formats. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessant attended the bilateral Russian-American meeting on the part of the United States. Vladimir Putin was accompanied by Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, Finance Minister Anton Siluanov, Presidential aide Yuri Ushakov and Presidential Special Envoy Kirill Dmitriev. The conversation started in a pleasant atmosphere. The US president personally added special ease.
—Oh, who's that?" This is my friend! — Trump said with a smile, heading towards Vladimir Putin. — I'm glad to see you.
In the part open to the press, only the American president spoke — he expressed hope for a productive meeting. After that, the conversation continued behind closed doors for about 40 minutes. Vladimir Putin came out of it in a great mood, said Yuri Ushakov. Donald Trump talked with Xi Jinping for about an hour. Vladimir Putin also discussed pressing issues of bilateral relations with the Chinese leader the day before. All these negotiation configurations allowed, among other things, to prepare the ground for the main event of the APEC summit.
The conflict in Ukraine and global security
The action shifted to the Qilin Shanzhuang residence, where Xi receives the most distinguished guests. Its name highlights the trademark Chinese symbolism, referring to the qilin unicorn, which represents well‑being. For the first time in history, a trilateral meeting of the leaders of Russia, China and the United States was held here. The conversation lasted more than an hour, but the open part included only 10 minutes. The tone of the discussion was set, of course, by the Chairman of the People's Republic of China.
— Peace is the eternal aspiration of human society. Our planet has experienced more than 10,000 wars, and the two largest of them have brought unprecedented and severe suffering to humanity. To this day, more than 60 local conflicts are still smoldering in the world. History teaches that good relations between large states make the world safe, and confrontation between them plunges the world into chaos," Xi Jinping began.
Putin spoke immediately after Xi, and then Trump. After the protocol statements, the conversation continued without cameras. Later, Vladimir Putin told reporters that he enjoyed such a free discussion, which helped to better understand each other.
The leaders of the three countries agreed on the history and responsibility of the major powers for global security. After all, they were all winners in the Second World War, and they all stood at the origins of the creation of the United Nations. "Therefore, we have the task of preserving and strengthening the system of international law on our shoulders," Vladimir Putin said. This line was also picked up by Donald Trump: he started talking about the need to protect states from global unaccountable structures — and first of all pointed to the International Criminal Court, which, according to him, "has absolutely no control over itself." "I believe that he has completely departed from his jurisdiction," the American leader stressed. The Kremlin also does not recognize its jurisdiction and considers any decisions of the ICC to be unenforceable on the territory of the country. Of course, the Ukrainian crisis was not without its consequences — by the way, it was one of the topics of Putin's bilateral talks with both Xi and Trump.
"Our countries have many overlapping interests in the settlement of regional conflicts, of course, including the conflict in Ukraine,— Vladimir Putin stressed at the open session.
It is noteworthy that the meeting took place against the background of another important event on the Ukrainian track: on the same day, Trump's special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner went to Berlin for talks with Vladimir Zelensky and European leaders. According to Kushner, their priorities will be to work on a "unified position on key elements of long-term peace," preparing the agenda and format for the next round of negotiations on Ukraine and security issues.
The outcome of the nuclear issue in the negotiations
All three, despite the different political accents in their speeches, unanimously recognized the collective responsibility for maintaining security. Donald Trump decided not to be petty and said that contacts between the Russian Federation, the United States and China affect "the life of the entire planet." At the same time, the American leader did not dissemble: misunderstandings remain, since Moscow, Washington and Beijing often disagree with each other. So he smoothly moved on to the main topic of his speech — nuclear arms control.
— We are the three largest nuclear powers: the United States, Russia and China. We could discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons in the world. Because the use of such weapons is very scary to imagine. When you have nuclear weapons, it is very difficult to give them up. I represent a country that has nuclear weapons <...> It's not easy. But it is very important to cooperate, to work together, in order to work to reduce the risk of nuclear proliferation," said Donald Trump.
In China, according to Western media reports, they feared that Trump would turn the negotiations into a "political show." There were similar concerns in Europe. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz even asked the American leader to avoid surprises. According to political analysts, it was Donald Trump's statement on nuclear disarmament in the open part of the meeting that was such a surprise.
This is a classic example of American negotiating tactics: to set the most ambitious and public benchmark, to fix the topic on the global agenda, even if the negotiating partners are not ready for this, says political scientist Tatiana Kosacheva. By promoting the nuclear disarmament agenda, the United States also wants to disarm its likely opponents, especially since such an experience in their history has already been on the example of Great Britain, added orientalist Kirill Kotkov.
Trump has long insisted on involving Beijing in the issue of nuclear arms control, appealing to the pace of development of the republic. "At the moment, China has a much smaller nuclear arsenal than we do, but in four or five years they will catch up with us," he said earlier at the Davos forum. China indeed ranks third in the world in terms of arsenal size and has approximately 620 nuclear warheads, according to estimates by the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI). For comparison, the Russian Federation and the United States count in the thousands. However, Beijing did not consider this to be the subject of a trilateral discussion due to the disparity of arsenals.
However, now, after the termination of START III, there have been no restrictions in the world for almost a year. Most likely, China reacted to Trump's move with diplomatic irritation, but Beijing's position remains unchanged, Tatiana Kosacheva believes. That is why Xi Jinping did not enter into a polemic in the open part, later Chinese television only gave his general proposal from the closed part of the negotiations on the complete destruction of nuclear weapons. "This is the sword of Damocles hanging over the head of mankind. It should be completely banned and finally destroyed in order to eventually create a world free of nuclear weapons," the Chinese president stressed.
And this is a classic Chinese technique: to agree with a lofty goal, but actually block its practical implementation at the current stage, the political scientist emphasized. Therefore, one should not expect real agreements on the nuclear track: for any substantive conversation, China will require the inclusion of restrictions on American missile defense systems, intermediate-range missiles in the Asia-Pacific region and NATO's "joint nuclear missions," which Washington will not do and will continue to use this topic for political pressure, Tatyana Kosacheva believes.
Nevertheless, the trilateral meeting gave each of the powers its own strategic advantage, the experts concluded. This is an important reputational signal for Russia: the country remains a significant player, and attempts to isolate it have failed. China has confirmed its status through dialogue with the great Powers. The United States has strengthened its political weight by relying on pragmatism and the search for common ground. The meeting, as noted by the world media, clearly indicates the end of the unipolar world — now diplomacy is based on a balance of competition and cooperation.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»