Scientists have found similarities between free and forced choice
It seems to a person that an independent choice and a decision without alternatives are arranged completely differently. In the first case, he weighs the options, relies on his own desires and preferences, and in the second case, he simply accepts the only available offer. However, a new study has shown that the brain can form both types of decisions using similar neural processes. About how the mechanism of choice works and whether this means that free will is an illusion — in the material of Izvestia.
How the brain makes free and forced decisions
The study is published in the journal Imaging Neuroscience (IN). Scientists have studied what processes occur in the brain immediately before a person makes a decision. They were interested in whether the mechanisms of free choice differ from those that are involved when a person has no alternatives.
With a free choice, a person sees several options, evaluates them, and settles on one of them. Personal preferences, values, and goals can influence the decision. When forced to make a choice, only one option is available, so it remains for the person to recognize it and accept the proposed solution.
Previously, neuroscientists assumed that these processes should be different, since independent choice is closely related to individual human characteristics. Some studies have indeed shown differences in the distribution of neural activity for different types of decisions. However, the question of how exactly the brain forms each of them has remained open until now.
New work has shown that immediately before making a choice, brain activity develops in a surprisingly similar way, regardless of whether a person could choose between several options or had to take the only one.
How the brain forms a decision
To make a decision, the brain gradually collects and compares information in favor of different options. This process can be represented as the operation of a loading indicator: the signal gradually increases and reaches a certain level, after which the person makes a choice. In some cases, information accumulates very quickly — in hundreds of milliseconds. Therefore, it may seem to a person that a decision has arisen suddenly, although the brain has been processing the available information for some time.
In this case, neural activity does not necessarily increase evenly. Due to the natural fluctuations in the work of nerve cells, the signal can move either towards one option or towards another. This partly explains why people don't always make the same decisions, even if their preferences remain the same.
For example, one day he may choose a pie, and the other — a donut, although he likes both desserts equally. Such fluctuations do not necessarily mean that preferences have changed: the final choice is also influenced by how the brain processes information at a particular moment.
Previously, scientists have discovered a similar mechanism when solving problems with an obvious correct answer — for example, when it is necessary to determine the color of a traffic light signal. The authors of the new work checked whether it also works in situations where there is no single right option, and the decision depends on the person's inner preferences.
What the experiment showed
49 adults participated in the study. The scientists recorded their brain activity using electroencephalography while the volunteers completed their choice of tasks. Participants were shown colorful balloons. In some cases, there were two balls of different colors in front of them, and they could choose one of them on their own. In others, there was only one ball, which had to be accepted as the only available option.
At the moment of making the decision, the volunteers pressed a button. The researchers tracked how the electrical activity of the brain changed immediately before this action. It turned out that with free and forced choice, activity developed very similarly. In both cases, the signal gradually increased and reached a comparable maximum level shortly before pressing the button. When the participants made a decision quickly, the activity increased more intensively, and with a slower choice — gradually.
Thus, the results showed that the brain can use a common mechanism of information accumulation not only when making a choice with an obvious correct answer, but also when the decision is determined by personal preferences. At the same time, scientists studied not only the signals associated with decision-making, but also the processes of preparation for the action itself.
Does this mean that free will is an illusion?
The similarity of neural processes can give the impression that a person is not as much in control of his decisions as he thinks. This question is reminiscent of the famous experiments conducted by neuroscientist Benjamin Libet in the 1980s. Then the researchers found that brain activity begins to change even before a person realizes the intention to perform an action.
Such results have sparked a discussion about whether a person makes a decision on their own or whether the brain begins to prepare an action before it becomes conscious. The new work also shows that some selection steps can occur automatically. However, the authors emphasize that not only the information processing mechanism itself is important, but also what kind of information the brain uses. When freely chosen, they are related to a person's personal preferences, goals, and previous experiences.
Two people can go through similar neural processes and settle on the same option, but come to it for completely different reasons. For example, one will choose a certain item because of its appearance, and the other because it better suits his needs. Therefore, the similarity of brain activity in different types of decisions does not mean that individual characteristics of a person do not matter. On the contrary, they participate in the formation of information that the brain takes into account before making a choice.
What does the study change about freedom of choice?
The work shows that free decisions can be formed according to the same basic principles of information accumulation as forced ones. The brain gradually processes the available information, compares the options and reaches a certain threshold of activity, after which a person performs an action.
At the same time, the study does not provide a definitive answer to the philosophical question of the existence of free will. Scientists studied neural processes during specific experimental tasks, rather than all possible situations in which a person makes decisions. Therefore, the results cannot be automatically transferred to difficult life choices related to moral beliefs, long-term plans, or responsibility.
In addition, only 49 people participated in the experiment, and the choice was limited to simple tasks with colored balls. Further study of the issue will require research that will check whether the similarity of neural processes persists with more complex solutions and in other conditions. The authors suggest shifting the focus from the question of whether a person is really free to choose, to what exactly makes a decision personal. Even if the brain uses a common information processing mechanism, the content of this information is determined by the preferences, goals, and experiences of a particular person.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»