Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

Scientists talked about the relationship between waist circumference and the risk of death

JECH: the risk of death is higher with very small and large waist circumference
0
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

South Koreans with very small or large waist circumference had a higher risk of death than people with intermediate values. The relationship was observed in different categories of body mass index (BMI). This conclusion was reached by scientists who analyzed the data of 17.3 million adults. About how the researchers compared weight and waist circumference, in which age groups the relationship was stronger, and what could be behind the results, see the Izvestia article.

As observed by 17 million adults

The body mass index is calculated by dividing the weight in kilograms by the square of height in meters. Two people with a height of 170 cm and a weight of 70 kg will have the same BMI — about 24.2 kg/m. However, their proportion of muscle and fat may vary. The waist circumference helps to additionally assess how much fat is concentrated in the abdominal area.

The researchers used data from the National Health Insurance Service of South Korea. The analysis included 17,252,815 adults who underwent a routine medical check-up in 2009-2010. Their waist circumference, height and weight were measured. At that time, the average age for women was 49, while for men it was 47. The average waist circumference was 76.4 and 83.8 cm, respectively, and the BMI was about 23 and 24 kg/m2.

The participants were divided into 15 BMI categories ranging from 12 to 50 kg/m2. In each category, the waist circumference was compared with a 5 cm step. The data was analyzed based on gender and age in order to compare people with similar parameters and track how the risk of death differed.

Each participant was monitored until his death or until June 30, 2024. The average term was almost 14 years. During this time, 955,725 men and 615,825 women died — about 11% of men and 7.5% of women in the sample. The researchers accounted for death from any cause.

At which waist circumference was the mortality rate lower

The relationship between waist circumference and the risk of death was found to be U-shaped. In men, the lowest risk was observed with a girth of 80-94 cm, in women — 75-89 cm. Mortality was higher at both ends of the distribution. A separate BMI analysis revealed a similar pattern. The lowest risk corresponded to a BMI of 24-28 kg/m for men and 23-27 kg/m for women.

An increased risk with very small and large waist circumference was observed in different age groups and BMI categories. The connection was stronger in older age, especially in women aged 75 and older.

The average waist circumference at the time of the examination differed among people of different ages. In men, it increased until about the age of 50, and after the age of 75 it was less. For women, the average girth increased from about 25 to 75 years old and decreased in older age groups.

Separately, the researchers examined participants with a waist circumference of average or higher for people of the same gender, age, and BMI category. In this part of the sample, every additional 5 cm of girth corresponded to a higher relative risk of death — by 16% in men and by 14% in women.

The association of a large waist with increased mortality has been studied before. In 2020, The BMJ published a meta-analysis of 72 cohort studies that collectively covered more than 2.5 million people. In it, the association of a larger waist circumference with overall mortality persisted even after BMI was taken into account.

What did the comparison of weight and waist circumference show?

In people with a normal body weight and a waist large for their BMI, the combination of a 5 cm smaller girth and an 8-10% lower weight overall was not associated with a lower risk of death. This difference in weight corresponded to about two units of BMI.

In the group with a slight excess of body weight and a large waist circumference for their BMI, the result was different. A 7-8% lower weight was associated with a lower risk of death. An even lower risk was observed in participants with a waist 5 cm smaller at the same BMI.

The authors compared groups of people with different initial parameters. To find out how a deliberate change in weight or waist circumference affects mortality, it is necessary to study the effect of such an intervention separately. If the causal nature of the relationship is confirmed, the results, according to the researchers, may provide "an empirical basis for an individual approach to the treatment of obesity."

How body composition can explain the results

One possible explanation is related to visceral fat, which accumulates in the abdominal cavity around the internal organs. A large waist circumference may be a sign of excess fat. Excessive accumulation of such fat is associated with metabolic disorders and an increased risk of cardiovascular diseases.

The authors suggest that with a smaller waist circumference and the same weight, a person may have less visceral fat and more lean mass, including muscle. When you lose weight by restricting calories, some of your muscle mass can also be lost. According to scientists, this can weaken the benefits of reducing the amount of visceral fat. To check what role this mechanism played, studies with repeated measurements of body composition will help.

The high mortality rate among people with very small waists may have another explanation. Weight loss in old age sometimes precedes the detection of the disease. This possibility was discussed by the authors of the JAMA Network Open in 2023. In a sample of more than 19,000 elderly people, weight loss was associated with increased subsequent mortality. To understand the connection with a very small waist circumference, it is important to know what it was like before the first measurement and whether it has changed over time.

At an older age, the condition of the muscles is also important. A decrease in muscle strength and mass is characteristic of sarcopenia. The authors of the European consensus attribute it to decreased mobility, falls, and higher mortality. Checking what role muscle condition played in the Korean sample would require separate measurements.

How do the results compare with medical recommendations?

Russian clinical guidelines on obesity suggest that BMI should be assessed along with waist circumference. For adults of European origin, 94 cm or more in men and 80 cm or more in non—pregnant women are considered indirect signs of central obesity - excessive accumulation of fat in the abdominal area.

Clinical thresholds help to identify central obesity associated with the risk of type 2 diabetes and heart and vascular diseases. In the South Korean work, the scientists solved a different problem. They determined at what values of waist circumference people in a particular sample were less likely to die from any cause during the follow-up. Therefore, ranges from the study should be understood in the context of its sample and outcome.

Another way to account for differences in body type is to correlate waist with height. A girth of 85 cm with a height of 160 cm gives a ratio of about 0.53, and with a height of 180 cm — about 0.47. The British National Institute for Health and Quality of Care (NICE) recommends using this indicator together with BMI in adults with a BMI below 35 kg/m2. In these recommendations, a ratio of 0.5 to 0.59 indicates increased health risks associated with the accumulation of fat in the abdominal area.

When measuring the waist, Russian guidelines suggest placing the tape in the middle between the lower edge of the last rib and the upper edge of the pelvic bone. The doctor compares the obtained value with BMI and other health data, including blood pressure and blood glucose levels.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast