Scientists have linked chronic loneliness with the risk of dementia
Loneliness in old age may be associated with changes in cognitive health, but not every experience of social isolation has the same effect on the body. Researchers suggest that the duration of this condition is important: a temporary feeling of loneliness and a constant lack of communication may have different correlations with the risk of dementia. About how chronic loneliness differs from episodic loneliness and why it is important to take into account the subjective feeling of social connection — in the material of Izvestia.
Scientists have been monitoring the condition of the elderly for 30 years
The study is published in the journal Aging & Mental Health. Scientists from the University of Bordeaux analyzed data from 3,777 people aged 65 and older. The observation took place from 1988 to 2018. During the first eight years, the researchers asked participants four times if they had felt lonely during the previous week. Based on the responses, people were divided into three groups: those who had never experienced loneliness, those who encountered it from time to time, and those who experienced it constantly.
48.3% of the participants were assigned to the first group, 34.4% to the second, and 17.3% to the third. The researchers then assessed the risk of developing dementia over the next 20 years. At this stage, the study involved 1,540 people who had not been diagnosed with the disease at the beginning of the second follow-up period. During the follow-up, 560 of them were diagnosed with dementia.
Karin Perez, a senior researcher at the Bordeaux Population Health Center and co-author of the work, noted that the results cast doubt on the idea that any experience of loneliness is equally dangerous for cognitive health.
Karin Perez
This distinction is crucial. Although most people experience loneliness at some point in their lives, it is chronic and persistent loneliness that can increase the risk of developing dementia.
Increased risk of dementia by 38%
During the 20 years of follow-up, dementia was diagnosed in 33.1% of participants who had never reported loneliness. In the group with episodic loneliness, 34.5% of people developed the disease, and 49.1% of those who experienced it constantly.
After accounting for other factors, the researchers found that chronic loneliness was associated with a 38% increased risk of dementia compared with no such experience. At the same time, episodic loneliness did not show a statistically significant relationship with the likelihood of developing the disease. Thus, the important factor was not the very presence of loneliness, but its stability. Participants who reported it during only one or two surveys did not show a significant increase in risk compared to people who had never experienced this condition.
The authors stressed that the results do not prove that chronic loneliness directly causes dementia. The study was observational, so it allows us to talk about a statistical relationship, but does not establish a cause-and-effect mechanism.
Possible mechanisms of loneliness's influence on the brain
Researchers have offered several explanations for why prolonged loneliness may be associated with poorer cognitive health. One of them concerns the prolonged activation of stress and immune mechanisms, which, according to the authors, can support inflammatory processes in the body. In addition, chronic loneliness is associated with insufficient physical activity and a less healthy diet. These lifestyle features may contribute to the development of cardiovascular diseases and diabetes, conditions that are also associated with an increased risk of dementia.
Another possible mechanism concerns social contacts. Communication with other people creates conditions for cognitive stimulation: a person has to keep up a conversation, memorize information, react to the interlocutor and participate in joint activities. In the long-term absence of such interactions, such stimuli may become fewer.
Perez noted that prolonged social stress can lead to an accumulation of physiological stress on the body. At the same time, the listed mechanisms are based on previous scientific data and are considered as possible explanations for the discovered connection, rather than as processes directly proven in the framework of this work.
Loneliness does not always depend on whether a person lives alone.
Another important result was the monitoring of the living conditions of the participants. Almost 30% of people in the group with chronic loneliness did not live alone: they lived with a partner or other family members. According to the authors, this shows that social well-being cannot be assessed solely by the number of people with whom a person shares housing. The feeling of loneliness can persist even with the constant presence of others.
Ivana Simon, the first author of the study
This vulnerability can also arise from unsatisfactory relationships, the burden of caring for loved ones, or the lack of meaningful activities.
She added that medical and social specialists, as well as government representatives, should not use living conditions as the only indicator of social disadvantage. It is also important to take into account the subjective feeling of connection with others.
Is it necessary to take into account the duration of loneliness
The researchers noted that the work has a number of limitations. In particular, the feeling of loneliness was assessed using a single question about the experiences of the previous week. This approach did not allow for a detailed study of the quality of the participants' relationships, whether they had meaningful activities, and other features of social life. In addition, the results are based on observations of a French cohort formed at the end of the 20th century. Therefore, they cannot be automatically transferred to all groups of elderly people and other social conditions.
Nevertheless, the authors believe that the duration of loneliness should be taken into account when assessing social factors related to cognitive health. They propose to expand the opportunities for older people to participate in public life, create public spaces accessible to different generations, and pay more attention to identifying chronic loneliness.
Conclusions of the study authors
Since some situations of loneliness can be prevented or overcome, it can become an important goal of measures aimed at maintaining healthy cognitive aging, maintaining independence and improving the quality of life in old age.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»