Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Confectioners and social activists accused retail chains of discriminating against Russian manufacturers. According to their data, Magnit and Pyaterochka set margins 1.5–2 times higher for domestic sweets than for imported ones. As a result, products of the Alyonka, Babaevsky and other Russian brands can cost 50-77% more expensive than similar products in terms of composition and purchase price of Nestle, Mars, Ferrero and Mondelez. Public activists appealed to the deputies of the State Duma with a request to sort out the situation. The FAS said it would take action if violations were found. Retail chains deny the charges: according to them, products of foreign brands are often produced in Russian factories, and prices for confectionery products are primarily determined by the manufacturers themselves.

Why are Russian sweets more expensive than foreign ones?

The State Duma Committee for the Protection of Competition intends to check the pricing situation for Russian confectionery products in the federal retail chains Magnit and Pyaterochka. The reason was the results of a study by the Moscow Society for the Protection of Consumer Rights and the Public Consumer Initiative, as well as the responses of manufacturers of sweets. This is stated in a letter from State Duma deputy Sergei Lisovsky addressed to the head of the committee, Valery Gartung (Izvestia has it).

шоколад
Photo: IZVESTIA/Pavel Volkov

"The analysis revealed a systematic practice of establishing discriminatory margins. So, in particular, in the Pyaterochka and Magnit chains, the mark–up for products of Russian brands (Alyonka, Babaevsky, N.K. Krupskaya confectionery factory) can be 1.5-2 times higher than for products of similar composition and purchase price from foreign manufacturers (Nestle, Mars, Mondelez, Ferrero)," the deputy notes.

According to the data provided in the letter, the cost of domestic sweets can be 50-77% higher than imported ones. The MP believes that this practice contradicts the goals of import substitution and disrupts the balance of economic interests of market participants.

To verify the situation, Sergey Lisovsky sent requests to the Ministry of Industry and Trade and the Federal Antimonopoly Service. However, according to him, the antimonopoly service did not respond to the appeal for six months, and the ministry did not identify any violations, indicating that these goods are not socially significant.

"At the same time, the agency did not give a proper legal assessment to the fact that the principle of freedom of contract and market pricing does not repeal the direct prohibition on the creation of discriminatory conditions established by Article 13 of the Law on the Fundamentals of State Regulation of Trading Activities in Russia," the deputy's letter says.

шоколад
Photo: Global Look Press/Maksim Konstantinov

Attached to the document is a response from the largest Russian confectionery holding United Confectioners, which includes 16 enterprises producing products under the brands Krasny Oktyabr, Alyonka, Mouth Front and others. The company also points out the difficulties of competing with foreign manufacturers.

"It is difficult for domestic food producers to compete with multinational companies from unfriendly countries. Foreign brands continue to dominate the shelves of chain stores, attracting customers with lower prices," the holding's response says.

Confectioners note that lower prices for imported products are set, among other things, due to the "limitless marketing budgets" provided to retail chains by foreign manufacturers.

"In our opinion, there really is a difference in margins," United Confectioners told Izvestia.

касса
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

Sergey Lisovsky told Izvestia that the committee intends to hold an expanded meeting with representatives of the Federal Antimonopoly Service, the Ministry of Industry and Trade, manufacturers and retail chains to discuss the problem.

The editorial board sent inquiries to other Russian and foreign confectionery companies asking them to assess the situation.

How will the FAS check the margins on Russian sweets

If a foreign product with a higher cost is sold cheaper than its Russian counterpart, this may indicate that competition is not at the expense of production efficiency, but due to the conditions of access to store shelves, Anton Nedzvetsky, head of the Moscow Society for Consumer Protection, told Izvestia. The organization conducted a study of pricing for Russian and foreign goods in wholesale and retail trade.

шоколад
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

According to the expert, we may be talking about a targeted policy of foreign corporations, which retail chains use for additional profits, including receiving financial bonuses from suppliers.

The situation when a foreign bar with a higher cost is on the shelf twice as cheap as a domestic Alenka bar looks at least strange, Oleg Pavlov, head of the Public Consumer Initiative, told Izvestia. If the price difference is not related to objective costs, but is explained by marketing agreements or supplier bonuses, this distorts competition and misleads buyers about the real value of goods, he believes.

— At the moment, the [Federal Antimonopoly] Service is studying the appeals received from a number of confectionery manufacturers regarding discrimination by retail chains. In case of violations, the service will apply response measures," the FAS told Izvestia.

The service recalled that earlier the Voronezh Department of the Federal Antimonopoly Service had opened a case against Agrotorg LLC (Pyaterochka chain) on grounds of discrimination against the Rossoshan Dairy Plant. The retailer reduced milk purchases from the company by 96.5%, while continuing to sell products from other suppliers.

молоко
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

Izvestia sent a request to the Ministry of Industry and Trade, asking for clarification of the department's position on the actions of retail chains.

How do retail chains explain chocolate prices

However, the trade does not agree with the accusations. According to the Chairman of the Association of Omnichannel Retail Companies (ACORT) Stanislav Bogdanov, a significant part of the products of international brands are also manufactured in Russian factories.

— The cost of confectionery products is formed primarily on the manufacturer's side, and the trade margin plays a secondary role in it, — he noted. — The composition, including the proportion of cocoa, is included in the cost of the product: the higher the cost of raw materials, the higher the selling price, followed by the retail price.

шоколад
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

According to media reports, since the beginning of 2026, prices for individual cocoa ingredients have increased by about 10-20%. But, according to Oleg Pavlov, Russian manufacturers are having a harder time with expensive logistics and sanctions.

Stanislav Bogdanov noted that large retail chains apply uniform pricing principles for Russian and foreign goods: purchasing conditions, the market situation and competitors' offers are taken into account.

— The size of the margin depends on objective economic factors — logistics costs, marketing support, promotions and demand for a specific product. At the same time, the country of production of the product does not affect it," the head of AKORT is convinced.

Confectionery, according to him, remains one of the most dynamically developing categories: manufacturers are actively launching new products, and the range of domestic products in chains is expanding with them. Retailers, in turn, support the growth of the representation of Russian brands on the shelves and are interested in the availability of consumer-demanded goods in this category.

шоколад
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

— The range of large retail chains is dominated by products from domestic confectionery factories: the share of Russian chocolate and chocolate bars is approximately 70%. In total, depending on the store format, there are from 50 to more than 550 types of goods in this category," said Stanislav Bogdanov.

According to the Pyaterochka retail chain, demand for some Russian confectionery brands increased by about 30-40% over the year. Domestic confectionery products are in demand by customers and are increasing their presence on the shelf, X5 noted, which, in addition to Pyaterochka, includes the Perekrestok supermarket chain, the Chizhik discounter chain, Krasny Yar grocery stores and the Slata chain.

The press service of Magnit refrained from commenting. Izvestia also sent inquiries to other trading companies.

According to Georgy Ostapkovich, scientific director of the HSE Center for Market Research, the Federal Antimonopoly Service and the Ministry of Industry and Trade are unlikely to regulate anything in this matter. According to him, the price of a product is determined by demand. This is a normal market economy, in which businesses themselves have the right to set the price at which they want to sell it, and the state should not interfere, otherwise it is no longer a market, but state regulation.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast