Researchers talked about the benefits of support groups for young fathers
Young fathers who participated in support groups or received consultations at home and over the phone said that it became easier for them to cope with loneliness and take care of a child. Researchers from the University of Kent and their colleagues collected data on such programs in 11 countries. According to the questionnaires on anxiety and depression symptoms, the results varied from program to program. For more information, see the Izvestia article.
Who asks fathers how they are coping
When specialists meet with the family during pregnancy and after childbirth, the father is often perceived primarily as a person who supports the partner. Sharyn Baldwin, a researcher at the Center for Health Services Research at the University of Kent, who led the work on the review, examines what kind of support men themselves need.
"At least one in ten men faces mental health problems during the perinatal period," she noted.
In an earlier meta-analysis of 74 studies involving over 41,000 participants, the prevalence of depression in fathers from the beginning of their partner's pregnancy to the end of the first year after giving birth was estimated at 8.4%. The results varied depending on the country and the assessment method. This work dealt with depression, and the new review covered other difficulties, including anxiety, stress, and social isolation.
In the perinatal review, the authors selected 19 publications that described 18 studies. In nine of them, participants were randomly assigned to groups. In other studies, researchers, in particular, interviewed men about what changed after classes or consultations.
The programs were most often studied in Australia, the USA and Singapore. In some projects, men came to meetings without partners, in others, couples discussed child care and the allocation of responsibilities together. Another part of the programs was conducted at home, by phone or via text messages. In a study of one of these services, 87.5% of fathers surveyed reported that messages helped them feel less lonely.
Why did the questionnaires and conversations give different answers?
Studies that evaluated symptoms using standard scales have produced varying results. For example, after participating in the home visit program, fathers showed fewer signs of depression and emotional stress associated with raising a child. In another program conducted by the nursing staff, six weeks and three months after delivery, there was no difference in the severity of depressive symptoms compared with the usual follow-up.
In the conversations, the participants often talked about the changes in their daily lives. Meetings with other fathers provided an opportunity to talk about the complexities of caring for a baby, and classes for couples helped to discuss who would take on specific tasks. Some men noted that they became more confident in communicating with the child and better understood where to turn for help. These changes could have gone unnoticed if the organizers evaluated the program only based on anxiety and depression scores.
Most studies did not track the result for long. The authors suggested that future assessments should find out whether the changes persist after the end of classes, and take into account how much fathers feel involved in child care and know where they can get help. For the Kent researchers, the gap in data for the UK itself is also important. Not a single British paper on the effectiveness of such programs met the criteria for inclusion in the review.
Practical circumstances, such as work and lack of time, also hindered participation. The authors believe that a flexible schedule of home consultations and the ability to take part of classes online can simplify access to programs. In their opinion, services that accompany families in the first year after giving birth can invite fathers to talk about how they are coping with the changes and what kind of help they need.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»