Undisclosed payment: borrowers sue banks for money to raise rates
Russians are actively seeking a refund for the increase in loan rates by banks, it follows from the court decisions studied by Izvestia. Financial organizations provide loans with low interest rates if the client agrees to purchase additional products, meet certain requirements (for example, in terms of spending on the card), or make a one-time payment. In October, customers managed to get their funds back through the courts several times and keep the reduced rate without meeting the banks' requirements. This opens up the possibility of getting back tens and hundreds of thousands of rubles to Russians who previously bought such services when applying for mortgages, car loans and other loans.
How borrowers are challenging the rate hike
The courts oblige Russian banks to return funds to borrowers for paid rate cuts, and sometimes to keep interest rates low for them, follows from the decisions for 2026. This applies in cases where, upon conclusion of the contract, customers receive a small rate in exchange for a cash payment, purchase of options, or fulfillment of any requirements, for example, a certain amount of expenses on the card. If the borrower refuses additional services, the bank increases the interest.
In at least eight cases this year, Russians have won a legal dispute against Sberbank. The financial institution made mortgage interest dependent on the Domclick Plus package of services, which included life insurance (optional, unlike mortgaged real estate insurance), a Savings loan subscription, and a mortgage discount.
So, in Volgograd, the court found it illegal to include a package of services in the mandatory conditions for issuing a mortgage loan, in St. Petersburg — a separate fee for changing the rate.
Borrowers were refunded the entire cost of the package or part of the payments. And sometimes they even obliged the bank to keep the reduced rate and refund the overpayment on interest that the person made after rejecting the additional product and the subsequent deterioration of conditions.
On "Banks.In August–September, more than five complaints were found about the rate increase after the rejection of Domclick Plus, including while maintaining life insurance. According to several requests, Sberbank restored the previous rate and refunded the overpayment.
This year, Russians have also won at least five lawsuits against VTB over the "Your Low Rate" option. Its cost was included in the loan amount, so interest was charged on the commission. In one case, the court found a pre-affixed consent and ordered the return of 174 thousand rubles, maintaining the rate of 24% instead of 35.7%. In another case, he collected 202 thousand rubles and interest accrued on this amount.
The registration of the "Your low rate" service remains voluntary for clients, the VTB press service told Izvestia. They confirmed that the refusal of it does lead to a recalculation of interest, but this is stipulated in the contract and complies with the requirements of the law.
Alfa-Bank also found at least four similar solutions for the "Favorable Rate" and "Your rate" options. Borrowers paid a one-time commission for a reduction in interest, and after refusing the service, the bank increased the interest. In one of the disputes, the client managed to obtain a refund of the fee for this program and maintain the reduced interest after litigation. In another case, the court found a pre-affixed consent to a "Favorable rate" and ordered to exclude 156 thousand rubles from the loan.
Sovcombank gave a discount on car loans for monthly Halva purchases: at least five transactions for 10 thousand rubles. If the conditions were violated, the rate was increased without the possibility of a reverse reduction. In September, the court confirmed the restoration of 16.9% instead of 22.6% and the offset of the overpayment to repay the loan, in October — 14.3% instead of 20.3% and the refund of almost 31 thousand rubles.
Disputes also arise with other financial institutions. Gazprombank's client repaid the loan ahead of schedule and demanded a refund of 510 thousand rubles for the interest reduction option. In January, the court recovered about 946 thousand rubles, including interest and a fine. In April, the court ordered OTP Bank to maintain a discount of three percentage points after abandoning the paid option "Your favorable rate". Izvestia has sent inquiries to all the listed financial institutions.
In October, customers managed to obtain a refund through the courts several times and maintain a reduced rate without meeting the requirements of the banks.
Is it legal to increase the rate after refusing additional services
The rate is the price of the loan and an essential condition of the contract, and not a separate service, explained the lawyer of the Pen Bar Association. & Paper by Anna Lysenko. According to her, the bank cannot charge a separate fee for what it is obliged to do anyway. Therefore, courts often recognize the commission for lowering the rate as hidden interest, and the condition for it is infringing on consumer rights. If such a fee is illegal, then it is illegal to increase the interest for refusing it.
In April 2024, the Central Bank recommended that banks waive fees for interest reductions and changes to other loan terms. However, the recommendation itself does not cancel out the conditions stipulated in the contract, so it is sometimes necessary to seek a refund of a specific overpayment through a financial commissioner or a court, explained Freedom Global analyst Vladimir Chernov.
The client has the right to cancel the additional service at any time, even after the end of the cooling-off period, said Evgenia Lazareva, project manager of the Popular Front for Borrowers' Rights. This right is provided for by the Law "On Consumer Rights Protection" and the Civil Code.
Is it profitable to pay for a reduced rate
When the loan is repaid on schedule, the discount can bring real benefits, said Mikhail Bryukhanov, Chairman of the Board of Directors of Pervouralskbank. Reducing the mortgage rate by two to three percentage points can reduce the monthly payment by 10-20%. However, when evaluating the benefits, it is important to consider the cost of the option itself.
Usually, the rate reduction fee is added to the loan amount, so the borrower pays interest on the cost of the "discount," Evgenia Lazareva warned. For the bank, this is a convenient tool that allows you to earn additional income, retain the client and return the basic conditions in case of violation of the terms.
This is beneficial for credit institutions, because they receive a one-time commission, which can amount to 100-500 thousand rubles, immediately, and not gradually over the entire loan term, explained Anna Lysenko. In addition, many borrowers repay loans ahead of schedule, but the commission paid in advance usually remains with the financial institution. An additional advantage is the opportunity to advertise a loan with a lower interest rate.
Basically, such programs are beneficial to those who repay the loan strictly on schedule throughout the term, said Vasily Kutyin, Ingo Bank's Director of Analytics.
The Popular Front also warns about the risk of losing hundreds of thousands of rubles if the option is rejected. In one of the cases studied by the organization, the monthly payment after the rate increase increased from 39.8 thousand to 55.8 thousand rubles. In the legal disputes studied by Izvestia, the interest after the cancellation of the discount in some cases exceeded 30% per annum.
How the authorities limit controversial schemes
In addition to the recommendations distributed in 2024, on July 1, 2025, the Central Bank introduced a mortgage standard prohibiting charging a commission for rate cuts. In addition, according to article 16 of the law "On Consumer Rights Protection", updated in September of the same year, credit institutions do not have the right to pre-mark consent for additional services. At the same time, the bank itself must prove that the client voluntarily agreed to purchase them.
Izvestia sent a request to the Central Bank.
However, it is still up to the courts to finally resolve disputes about paid options on consumer loans, Evgenia Lazareva added. In 2025-2026, decisions in favor of borrowers were repeatedly confirmed by higher courts.
You can challenge the interest increase if the option was actually imposed, the consent was given automatically, or the client was not offered a real alternative, Evgenia Lazareva explained. Other reasons are the lack of independent benefit from the paid service and insufficient information about the temporary nature of the discount and the possible sharp increase in payments.
How to refund the commission and overpayment
On the advice of an expert, in order to refund money for such a service, the borrower should:
Request a contract from the bank, a loan application, the terms of the paid program, and the calculation of the new rate.
Send a claim demanding to restore the previous rate, recalculate the debt and refund the overpayment. If no more than 30 days have passed since the loan was issued, write a waiver at the same time and request a refund.
If the bank refuses, contact the financial commissioner. For claims in the amount of up to 500 thousand rubles, this is a mandatory stage before the court. Additionally, you can file a complaint with the Central Bank.
File a lawsuit demanding to invalidate the disputed condition, collect a commission, overpayment of the rate and interest for using other people's money under Article 395 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.
If the bank has not voluntarily satisfied the legitimate demands of the borrower, it is possible to additionally collect a fine in the amount of 50% of the amount awarded to the consumer, compensation for moral damage and court costs, Evgeniya Lazareva added. According to her, the limitation period for claims related to the imposed services can be up to three years.
However, the refund of the commission does not always allow you to keep the reduced rate at the same time, warned Anna Lysenko. If the terms of the program were clear, and the client tries to refund the entire fee and leave a discount, the court may consider this as contradictory behavior or abuse of law. Therefore, it is possible to count on a positive decision, first of all, if there is evidence of unfair actions of the bank.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»