Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Arkady Bukh, a well-known New York lawyer, may be pushing his clients to cooperate with American intelligence agencies, Izvestia found out. An anonymous hacker source gave the editors video recordings of conversations with a lawyer, where he offered the interlocutor to surrender to the US authorities, and then share the reward set for his head. The lawyer was sure that he was communicating with Dmitry Khoroshev, the alleged leader of the Lockbit hacker group, for whose help the US intelligence agencies are promising up to $ 10 million. Booh has previously been credited with actively mediating between Russian hackers and the FBI. In particular, many hackers and sellers of stolen bank cards made deals with the American investigation through him. The details are in the Izvestia investigation.

Lawyer and pseudo-Khoroshev

Some time ago, lawyer Arkady Bukh received an anonymous message asking for advice on the increasing number of arrests of Russian hackers by the American authorities around the world. The lawyer was hardly surprised that they turned to him — by that time he had repeatedly defended the defendants in cybercrime cases, mostly immigrants from the former USSR. The lawyer recorded all subsequent conversations with the anonymous person on video, and some time ago this archive was at the disposal of Izvestia. It was handed over to the editorial board by a man who acted as Buch's interlocutor.

— I contacted Buch because I wanted to ask a few questions, because he is a well—known lawyer in this environment, - our source explained the reasons why he initiated communication with a lawyer. "But almost immediately, he started trying to figure out who I was. I was confused by this, and I decided to introduce myself to Khoroshev, just so that he would finally start answering my questions.

Dmitry Khoroshev is a Russian citizen wanted by the American special services, for whose help they promise a reward of up to $ 10 million. The FBI considers Khoroshev to be the creator and administrator of the Lockbit hacker group, which infected the networks of large international companies with a cryptographic virus, and then demanded a ransom from the victims to restore access to data.

"You take two thirds for yourself"

The "Legend" turned out to be successful. Judging by the notes available to Izvestia, Arkady Bukh believed that he was talking to Khoroshev. Perhaps also because the US authorities had arrested several alleged LockBit members over the previous two years, and Khoroshev had something to fear.

Izvestia reference

Over the past five years, the United States has been actively using detentions abroad and extradition against alleged participants in the Russian-speaking cybercriminal.

The LockBit group became the main target. At the end of 2022, Mikhail Vasilyev was detained in Canada, who later pleaded guilty in the United States. Ruslan Astamirov was arrested in Arizona in June 2023, and Rostislav Panev, the alleged developer of LockBit, was arrested in Israel in August 2024. In March 2025, he was extradited to the United States.

The most high-profile case was that of Vladislav Klyushin, who was detained in Switzerland in March 2021 for hacking corporate networks and trading on the stock exchange using stolen financial statements. In December 2021, he was extradited to the United States, in 2023, a court sentenced him to nine years, and in 2024, he returned to Russia as part of a prisoner exchange.

In November 2021, Denis Dubnikov was detained in the Netherlands on suspicion of laundering funds from the operators of the Ryuk extortion program. In 2022, he was transferred to the United States, where he pleaded guilty and was released in 2023, taking into account the time served.

The lawyer began to explain to the interlocutor that LockBit-type cases almost always end with a long sentence for the accused. The lawyer then described in detail who exactly was involved in his case in the United States and emphasized how closely he was familiar with the people who were investigating these cybercrimes.

— Today, the New Jersey office is engaged in LockBit, Washington, DC is engaged, Florida has become more active, both coasts. By the way, I have very good and warm relations with the prosecutors there. I've been practicing for a quarter of a century, and I have a good, warm relationship with almost all cyber kids. That is, they will tell me more than someone else on the street, they are quite open, they talk normally," the lawyer says in the video.

By cyberbullies, Buch did not mean hackers, but their opponents — federal prosecutors and agents who conduct cybercrime cases. He calls the New Jersey Prosecutor's office neighbors altogether.

— Several hundred pages on your case. I'll sit at night and read. In fact, this is New Jersey, these are my neighbors, I have developed very warm relations with them for a quarter of a century, they led Drinkman and Smilyants there. This is one of the most leading offices, I have them across the river. The fact that they are chasing you in Voronezh, of course, they are trying to put you in jail. We need to talk," Buch convinces his interlocutor.

Дело
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

As can be understood from the further content of the conversation, "talking" in the lawyer's understanding meant contacting the American authorities, voluntarily coming to the United States and discussing the conditions of self-incrimination. According to the Izvestia interlocutor, Buch literally pushed him to this decision, repeatedly emphasizing his experience and connections. As arguments, he cited the possibility of agreeing to be released from custody under an obligation to appear in court. And also, most notably, to share the award announced for Khoroshev.

— Maybe it will even be possible to agree that if you come yourself, they will release you on bail. Not even on bail, but on my word of honor — this is often done if a person arrives on his own. And an important point: they have put $10 million on your soul, look at it. Usually, as lawyers in this situation, we sign for one third, that is, you take two thirds for yourself. They're kind of paying this money for you," says Buch in the video.

In other words, the wanted man was actually offered to receive a reward for himself, and the lawyer would be owed a third of it, that is, with a maximum payment of about $ 3.3 million.

When the interlocutor stated that he was not going to leave Russia, Buch did not back down and offered a compromise: to meet on neutral territory — for example, in Dubai — or to negotiate with FBI agents on Zoom. At this stage, our interlocutor decided to stop communicating with Booh, probably fearing that this might lead to his trail. He deleted all accounts, including Telegram, from which he contacted the lawyer. At the same time, he still had video recordings of the calls — they were made by Buch and then forwarded to his interlocutor.

"I realized that the only advice I could ask him was how to come to the United States and surrender to his friends from New Jersey," the Izvestia source now says.

Arkady Bukh was indeed quite often involved in the cases of people accused of cybercrimes. In 2025, while investigating the activities of one of the Ukrainian hacker groups, Izvestia contacted Buch and asked about his connections with the special services. Then he answered evasively. According to him, he usually offers clients three options, and one of them involves cooperation with one of the American special services.

Суд
Photo: Global Look Press/Pogiba Alexandra

— The first is to go to a jury trial and prove your innocence. We really like this option, because it's a lot of work for lawyers, but it will also cost the most — up to $1 million. The second is to admit guilt, but not to turn anyone in. Still, many gangsters believe that then there is a chance to get a discount: for example, not 50, but 15 years. The third option is to offer some interesting project to one of the agencies and get a minimum term, often already spent in prison before the trial," Buch said at the time.

Izvestia reference

Arkady Bukh is an American criminal defense lawyer, born in Baku, who has been practicing in New York since the early 1990s. Among his clients are the creator of the SpyEye Trojan, Alexander Panin, carder Vladislav Khorokhorin, and spammer Oleg Nikolaenko. All of them cooperated with the investigation and received sentences much shorter than they were threatened with.

In April 2016, Panin was sentenced to 9.5 years in prison, while his accomplice received 15 years.

Khorokhorin, who was considered one of the world's largest traffickers of stolen bank card data, received only 7 years and 4 months in prison.

Nikolaenko (the creator of programs that at one point sent out a third of the world's spam — up to 10 billion messages per day) was held in custody for about 2.5 years and released as part of a deal with justice.

In 2015, Buch announced the creation of CyberSec in the United States, offering digital security audit services. Former defendants in cases of hacking and card fraud, including Igor Klopov, Dmitry Naskovets and Vladislav Khorokhorin, were involved in the work. The concept was based on the fact that former cybercriminals are able to test the protection of companies using methods close to real attacks.

In 2014, he defended Maxim Shinkarenko, who received 30 years in a case involving websites with child sexual exploitation materials. The lawyer claimed that his client performed technical functions, but Shinkarenko entered into an agreement with the prosecutor's office and agreed to a 30-year term.

Legal risks

Izvestia asked the lawyers to evaluate Buch's negotiations with a potential client. A practicing American lawyer, on condition of anonymity, considered that Buch could intentionally mislead the interlocutor.

Хакер
Photo: IZVESTIA/Alexey Maishev

— His actions look like deception. The promise "you will receive the reward" has no legal basis. I am not aware of cases where a reward has been paid to a wanted person for his own appearance: the announcement of the reward is a public offer addressed to third parties, and the wording "up to $10 million" means only the upper limit, the payment remains at the discretion of the authorities. In addition, New York has a direct ban on the "success fee" when defending a defendant in a criminal case. A third of the award, depending on the outcome of the criminal case, falls under this ban," the Izvestia interlocutor believes.

According to him, the absence of a signed contract does not matter: Buha is subject to the Rules of Professional Conduct of the state of New York, which also apply to potential clients, including anonymous ones. If it is proven that the lawyer was working in the interests of the FBI against the interests of the applicant, he risks being left without a fee and without legal status.

— It's hard to defend a person whose arrest you're going to make money on. Buch maintains the appearance of helping, presumably hiding that the actual purpose of communication has become the opposite. This is misleading," the source told Izvestia.

The Izvestia correspondent also managed to contact Arkady Bukh. According to him, he never pushed clients to make a deal with the investigation, while, in his opinion, the defender not only can, but is obliged to talk about cooperation with the investigation as one of the strategies, otherwise we are talking about inadequate protection.

Правосудие
Photo: IZVESTIA/Kristina Kormilitsyna

— Do I offer clients a deal with the investigation? No. I have to tell you about her. The decision to plead guilty according to the rules of legal ethics of the state of New York is made only by the client <...>," Buch told Izvestia.

The defender also rejected the claims that he offered to share the award with a potential client.

"A lawyer dividing money for his client's head is no longer a defender, but a plot for the disciplinary commission, and possibly for colleagues from the neighboring corridor of the court," said Buch.

According to him, such an offer to the client is unacceptable in principle, since it means a direct conflict of interests and a violation of the lawyer's main duty — loyalty to the client. This rule, he added, "is the only one that he has never wanted to circumvent."

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast