Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

On October 12, the Basmanny District Court issued the first decision in the case of the supply of substandard dry rations for the Ministry of Defense: Elvira Smirnova, Deputy General Director of Gryazinsky Food Processing Plant (GPK), who was charged with two counts of fraud, received four years in a general regime penal colony. Now they are considering charges against two defendants who deny guilt. Among the possible witnesses is former Deputy Defense Minister Dmitry Bulgakov. Izvestia studied the investigation materials and found out how the scheme was arranged and what control mechanisms operate in the execution of defense contracts.

Gold was added to the sentence

The hearing of Elvira Smirnova's case was held behind closed doors. The journalists were allowed only to read the introductory and operative parts of the verdict.

"According to the totality of crimes, Smirnova should be sentenced to four years of imprisonment to be served in a general regime colony by partial addition of punishments," Judge Konstantin Ochirov announced.

Эльвира Смирнова

Deputy General Director of JSC Gryazinsky Food Processing Plant Elvira Smirnova

Photo: IZVESTIA

During the protocol shooting, Smirnova turned away from the cameras and hid her face under her hood. She listened to the decision without emotion, only noting that everything was clear to her. In addition to imprisonment, the woman was fined 1.5 million rubles. The Defense Ministry's claim for damages was satisfied in full.

When the verdict was announced, it became known that operatives seized 159 million rubles, $8.9 million and €1.4 million in cash from Sberbank's bank cells belonging to Smirnova. Several plots of land belonging to her in the Moscow region, apartments, parking spaces and non-residential premises in Moscow with a total value of more than 90 million rubles were also left under arrest.

It took about ten minutes to list the seized jewelry and expensive watches. Among them were Rolex watches and products from Cartier, Tiffany, Hermes and other luxury brands. The court retained all these valuables, as well as real estate, as an interim measure to comply with the requirements of the Ministry of Defense and pay a fine.

Prohibited products

Elvira Smirnova was detained in April 2024 and sent to jail. Investigators are confident that she was part of an organized group that operated from June 2021 to April 2024, created to steal budget funds, the case file says.

Деньги
Photo: IZVESTIA/Anna Selina

According to the prosecution, other former top managers of the GKP, Alexander Mikhailenko and Valery Kovalevich, as well as businessman Igor Kotelnikov, were also participants in the scheme.

In 2022, the GKP signed an agreement with JSC Voentorg, which fulfilled obligations to provide catering services for the needs of military personnel. However, investigators believe that instead of fulfilling obligations to supply food, the company's management has built a criminal scheme to steal government funds. The defendants systematically overestimated the cost of products, replaced the required raw materials with cheaper and even substandard analogues. The examination showed that some of the seized samples of dry rations were unusable. Their further use was officially banned.

Pre-trial agreement

Elvira Smirnova has signed a pre-trial cooperation agreement with the prosecutor's office. It provides for a guilty plea and testimony against other participants in the alleged criminal scheme.

The other defendants plead not guilty. While Smirnova was being sentenced, proceedings against Valery Kovalevich and Alexander Mikhailenko began in the next room. Another defendant, Igor Kotelnikov, died in jail from a heart attack shortly before the trial began. However, the proceedings against him have not been stopped.: His relatives intend to seek posthumous recognition of his innocence.

Проволока
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

Former Deputy Defense Minister Dmitry Bulgakov, who is accused of fraud in another case, is also likely to be questioned during the trial. He had previously testified about the supply of dry rations as a witness.

How does the control over defense contracts work?

Over the past five years, the rules in the field of the state defense order have changed significantly. However, it would be wrong to assume that control has simply become tougher, says Timur Daudi, lawyer and senior partner at ICA Daudi & Partners.

— In September 2022, articles 201.2 and 285.5 appeared in the Criminal Code, establishing special offences in the field of state defense orders. They apply to both representatives of performers and officials," the expert told Izvestia.

There are also mechanisms to accelerate procurement, including the ability to conclude contracts with a single supplier.

— Thus, the rules developed simultaneously in two directions: simplification of individual procedures to speed up deliveries and stricter requirements for participants. However, the main mechanisms of financial control and product acceptance existed long before 2022," Daudi explained.

УК РФ
Photo: Global Look Press/Shatokhina Natalya

Control over the execution of defense contracts is not limited to product quality control during acceptance. It also includes an assessment of the fulfillment of contractual obligations, the validity of prices, financial transactions and the compliance of supplies with established requirements.

At the same time, the effectiveness of control depends not so much on the number of inspections as on their quality, the expert believes. It is important how thoroughly the real cost of products and the independence of procurement participants are checked, as well as how objectively the execution of contracts is assessed.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast