Scientists have named a healthy amount of whole grains for the heart
Daily consumption of 60-100 grams of whole grains in terms of dry weight can improve cardiovascular health.This volume corresponds to about 4-6 servings of whole grain products. This is the conclusion reached by the authors of a meta-analysis of 87 clinical trials published in the European Heart Journal. About how whole grain products affect cholesterol, blood pressure, body weight and glucose levels, in the "Izvestia" material.
What scientists have studied
Scientists have long associated the consumption of whole grains with a lower risk of cardiovascular disease. However, the results of individual clinical trials remained mixed, and the optimal amount of grain needed to improve health was not precisely determined.
A research team led by Helda Tutunchi, a specialist at Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, combined the results of 87 randomized controlled trials. They studied how whole-grain foods affect risk factors for cardiovascular diseases.
The total sample was 6529 people. The tests were conducted in Asia and Europe, as well as in the USA, Canada, Australia and Brazil. The authors assessed not only the presence of a positive effect, but also the dependence of the result on the amount of whole grains in the diet.
The study participants consumed oats, whole-grain bread, brown rice, and other foods that contain the main parts of the grain. The results were compared with those of people who consumed fewer whole grains or refined foods.
A meta-analysis showed that an increase in the proportion of whole grains led to a moderate improvement in several indicators at the same time. The authors consider this important because the risk of heart disease is determined not by one factor, but by a combination of body weight, blood pressure, lipid levels, glucose, and inflammatory processes.
What indicators have improved
Eating whole grains was associated with a decrease in body weight and waist circumference. In addition, the participants' blood pressure, total cholesterol, and low—density lipoprotein levels, the so-called bad cholesterol, decreased.
Low-density lipoproteins carry cholesterol through the body. When there is an excess of cholesterol, it can be deposited in the walls of blood vessels and participate in the formation of atherosclerotic plaques. Over time, this increases the likelihood of disruption of blood supply to the heart and brain.
The participants also had lower concentrations of triglycerides, another type of fat that circulates in the blood. Their elevated levels are considered as one of the factors of cardiovascular risk, especially when combined with obesity, diabetes and impaired cholesterol levels.
Positive changes were also observed in the indicators of carbohydrate metabolism. Whole grains have been linked to lower fasting glucose levels and decreased insulin resistance, a condition in which cells respond less well to insulin. The authors also found a decrease in interleukin-6. This protein is involved in inflammatory processes and is used in research as one of the markers of inflammation.
The scientists assessed the degree of confidence in the results. They found the data on weight loss, waist circumference, total cholesterol and interleukin-6 to be the most reliable. A moderate degree of confidence was found for changes in bad cholesterol, triglycerides, systolic blood pressure, fasting glucose, and insulin resistance.
At the same time, the changes in each individual indicator were small on average. The main result is that several moderate improvements occurred simultaneously and could be combined.
How many whole grains should I eat
The positive changes became noticeable already with the consumption of about 30-40 g of whole grains per day in terms of dry weight. However, the most pronounced results were observed at 60-100 g. This amount corresponds to approximately 4-6 servings of whole grains per day. As an example, the researchers cited a combination of a plate of oatmeal porridge, a sandwich of whole-grain bread and a portion of brown rice.
"The most pronounced benefits were observed at 60-100 grams per day," Tutunchi noted.
However, these grams cannot be directly compared with the weight of an already prepared dish. The study mainly focuses on the dry weight of the whole grain itself. When cooking, oatmeal, rice and other cereals absorb water, so the mass of the finished portion becomes much larger.
The concept of a serving may also vary depending on the country, product, and recommendations. One slice of whole-grain bread, a small amount of dry cereal, or a serving of cooked brown rice can be considered separate portions, but the whole grain content in them varies.
Therefore, the conclusion of the study should not be understood as a requirement to eat four to six large bowls of porridge daily. We are talking about the total amount of whole grains distributed between several meals and different foods.
Why is replacing more important than simply adding
The practical conclusion of the study is not only to increase the amount of whole grains, but also to replace refined carbohydrates with them. If a person simply adds a few servings of porridge or bread to their usual diet, their total calorie intake may increase. It is considered more logical to replace white bread with whole grains, refined cereals with oatmeal, and white rice with brown or other whole grains.
This approach allows you to increase the proportion of whole grains without significantly increasing the total amount of food. In addition, the result will depend on the whole diet. Even a whole-grain product can contain a lot of sugar, salt, or fat when it comes to sweet pastries, desserts, or industrially produced snacks.
Therefore, scientists do not suggest evaluating nutrition by just one ingredient. Whole grains should be part of a general diet that includes vegetables, fruits, legumes, protein sources, and other minimally processed foods.
How Whole grains can affect the heart
The study did not identify a single mechanism that would explain all the detected changes. Most likely, whole grain products act through several interrelated processes.
The preservation of the shell, embryo and endosperm makes their composition different from refined products. Whole grains contain more dietary fiber and other substances that can affect satiety, digestion, fat and carbohydrate metabolism.
The results of the meta-analysis show that the benefits can consist of small changes in several directions at once. A moderate decrease in body weight and waist circumference reduces metabolic stress. Improving cholesterol and triglyceride levels can be beneficial for blood vessels, and lowering blood pressure and glucose can be beneficial for the cardiovascular system as a whole.
According to the authors, the absence of one very large effect does not make the result insignificant. At the individual level, the changes may look moderate, but their combination and spread to a large part of the population can potentially affect the number of cardiovascular complications.
Who can benefit more from whole grains?
The authors of the editorial accompanying the study suggested that replacing refined foods with minimally processed whole grains may be especially beneficial for people with type 2 diabetes.
Such patients often have several risk factors at the same time.: increased glucose, insulin resistance, lipid metabolism disorders, high blood pressure and overweight. Therefore, even moderate changes in several indicators at once can be of practical importance.
However, the study does not allow us to establish a universal diet for all people with diabetes, hypertension or high cholesterol. The amount of carbohydrates and the choice of foods should take into account treatment, body weight, physical activity level and concomitant diseases.
Whole grain products are also not suitable for everyone. In certain diseases of the digestive system, the amount of fiber has to be increased gradually or temporarily limited. People with celiac disease should choose gluten-free whole grains and avoid wheat, rye, and barley products.
How to apply the research results
The authors consider increasing the proportion of whole-grain products to be a relatively affordable way to improve the diet. The most practical solution may be to gradually replace refined grain products with whole grains.
You can start by choosing whole-grain bread instead of white, oatmeal instead of refined flakes and brown rice, or other whole grains instead of a refined side dish. This allows you to distribute the recommended amount between breakfast, lunch and dinner. However, whole grains are not a substitute for treating hypertension, diabetes, or cholesterol disorders. Dietary changes should complement physical activity, smoking cessation, weight control, and doctor-prescribed therapy.
The researchers concluded that the most pronounced improvements in cardiovascular risk factors are observed with daily consumption of 60-100 g of whole grains in terms of dry weight. However, the long-term effect of such a diet on the incidence of heart attacks and strokes has yet to be confirmed.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»