- Статьи
- Economy
- Unnecessary burden: the increase in fines has not stopped banks from imposing additional services on borrowers
Unnecessary burden: the increase in fines has not stopped banks from imposing additional services on borrowers
In the first half of 2026, the Central Bank received twice as many complaints related to the sale of additional lending services by banks. They mainly relate to the imposition of such products on borrowers or the refusal to repay funds for them. The regulator confirmed to Izvestia an increase in the number of requests. Moreover, this happened despite tougher penalties for banks for deceiving consumers. The financial commissioner's service also told about citizens' messages: for example, there were cases when the bank sold priority services to the borrower (quick chat responses and SMS notification) for 370 thousand rubles. How to avoid overpayments is in the Izvestia article.
How much do Russians overpay to banks for additional services
Russians began to complain much more often about violations of their rights in consumer lending. During the year, the number of reports to the Central Bank about the imposition of additional services and difficulties in refunding funds for them increased 2.1 times and amounted to about 2.8 thousand in the first half of 2026, Izvestia calculated based on data from the regulator.
This year, approximately one in seven complaints was related to additional services, while for the same period in 2025, only one in 12 complaints related to this topic. Moreover, the growth occurred despite the fact that at the end of last year, the authorities tightened the responsibility for banks for violating consumer rights.
The Central Bank of the Editorial Board confirmed that the rate of increase in the number of complaints is accelerating. They clarified that the concept of "consumer deception" is not formally fixed at the legislative level. However, the imposition of additional services bypassing the client's will and any other unfair actions (including omission) that may affect the transaction cannot be attributed to bona fide sales.
The financial officer's service told Izvestia about specific appeals from citizens. Sometimes we are talking about large sums. For example, when issuing a loan, the bank sold a package of services to the borrower for 370 thousand rubles. It included priority service in a financial institution (in a chat and contact center), as well as an "SMS alert." At the same time, the total amount of the loan received amounted to 698 thousand. In other words, the client had to pay more than half of it.
In fact, such schemes have long ceased to be a minor addition to the product and have turned into an almost parallel loan within a loan, said Anton Nikitin, founder and CEO of Fingold.
As Izvestia wrote, there are also cases when banks charge significant commissions when selling insurance. In some cases, the margin reaches 25 times the size. For example, a person can pay 300 thousand rubles for a service, and only 12 thousand rubles are transferred to the insurer for registration of protection, the rest is the commission of the credit institution.
The practice of imposing "quasi-services" remains, such as postponing the next payment or skipping it, the possibility of obtaining credit holidays at the request of the borrower, and lowering the rate, the financial officer's service noted. The Central Bank reminded Izvestia that the bank is obliged to inform the borrower that additional services offered with the loan can be waived.
Despite this, people continue to report the imposition of services. Izvestia also studied similar complaints against <url>. One of the users noted that it was only a year after the loan payments began that he discovered that the bulk of the monthly payment was spent not on repayment, but on additional services. And he didn't use them.
Another Russian noted that from June 2023 to August 2026, large amounts were debited from his account every month under the guise of "Payment for the borrower's insurance protection program." As a result, he lost "several tens of thousands of rubles." Another borrower complained that he had signed a consumer loan agreement for 303 thousand rubles, and the overpayment for additional services amounted to 100 thousand rubles. In particular, the bank has activated the "surety" service.
Izvestia sent a request to the largest banks with a request to comment on the situation with the imposition of additional services.
Why do banks continue to impose their services
In part, the increase in the number of complaints this year is due to the fact that the Central Bank continues to receive complaints about violations from previous periods, the regulator told Izvestia. They added: now about 50% of all complaints are against one bank, which previously agreed to an additional service when receiving a consumer loan. As a result of the supervisory response, he corrected the business process, but the Central Bank continues to receive requests from his clients who faced the problem even before the changes.
New complaints against banks are also coming: for example, a visiting employee of a credit institution may offer to sign documents that agree in advance to additional services, while the client is not informed about the availability of these services, the regulator clarified. The same thing sometimes happens when applying for a loan in a mobile application.
However, supervisory work is underway with banks that commit such violations, the Central Bank stressed. Control purchases are carried out, and fines are imposed. If a financial institution systematically imposes additional services, incorrectly informs customers when applying for financial products, distorts the full cost of a loan, or unreasonably refuses to provide credit holidays, it faces liability. At the end of last year, fines for such violations were raised to 0.1% of the capital, which is already a significant amount. And if the instructions of the Central Bank are not fulfilled, then the liability may reach up to 1% of the bank's funds.
However, so far the economic motivation of banks seems to outweigh the risks, says Maria Ermilova, Associate Professor of Finance for Sustainable Development at Plekhanov Russian University of Economics. Additional services bring banks a significant portion of the profits from the loan product, she said. Even with high fines, the marginality of the imposed insurance and services often covers potential penalties, the expert explained.
Previously, fines were only 20-40 thousand rubles, this amount did not stop credit organizations at all, it can be called a statistical error, and for both large and small players.
The amount of 1% of the capital, but not less than a million rubles, is already visible even for a large bank in the accounts, said Anton Nikitin from Fingold. However, the issue is law enforcement. To impose a fine, you need to prove the fact of the imposition, and not just the sale of additional services along with the loan. So far, this is being done through complaints and case-specific proceedings. Therefore, the effect of increasing fines will not appear immediately, but as the practice of penalties accumulates, the expert believes. It's too early to talk about a trend reversal.
However, as stated in the financial ombudsman service, banks have already become more willing to return money for additional services in a pre-trial manner after contacting the commissioner.
Where to complain about the bank
The borrower needs to remember that along with the loan, services can be sold that affect the cost of the loan, and those that do not change the terms of the loan, the Central Bank said. Moreover, if the client refuses to purchase certain services (for example, insurance), the bank has the right not to offer him preferential loan terms.
People need to study the details carefully — this will help avoid unnecessary expenses, the regulator stressed.
Experts are sure that it is necessary to require the calculation of the full cost of the loan with all services. It is also necessary to check all preset checkboxes in online forms, said Maria Ermilova from Plekhanov Russian University of Economics. If the service has already been imposed, then it is worth recording the evidence (contract, screenshots, statements) and sending a written complaint to the bank, she advised.
If you refuse, you must write to Rospotrebnadzor, the Central Bank or the financial commissioner's office. By going to court, you can claim compensation for moral damage and a consumer fine of 50% of the amount awarded.
Also, as Anton Nikitin advises, at the first sign of imposition, Russians should directly refer to the new fines under Article 14.8 of the Administrative Code. According to him, in practice, this often accelerates the bank's reaction more than the reference to the law on consumer protection.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»