Astronomers have learned the reason for the unusual fragility of asteroid Bennu
- Новости
- Science and technology
- Astronomers have learned the reason for the unusual fragility of asteroid Bennu
Asteroids may look like solid blocks of rock, but some of them are actually loose accumulations of dust, rocks, and debris. A new study has shown that the strength of such an object is largely determined by the size and shape of the smallest particles, and the surface of the asteroid Bennu turned out to be so weak that it is inferior even to freshly ground coffee. How scientists came to this conclusion and why they needed to measure the strength of asteroids is described in the Izvestia article.
Bennu was not a solid block of stone
Space missions in recent years have shown that small asteroids may have a completely different structure than is commonly imagined. Bennu, Ryugu, and Itokawa belong to the so—called "asteroids - piles of debris" — they consist of dust, rocks, and large boulders that are held together by their own gravity and weak bonding forces between particles.
Scientists have been trying to understand how durable such a structure can be for more than 10 years. Of particular interest is the regolith, a layer of dust and debris on the surface of an asteroid. It is the interaction between individual particles that can give the entire mass additional strength, despite its loose structure.
Previously, such models were created mainly using spherical particles. However, real regolith grains are far from ideal balls: they can be angular, elongated, and have a complex surface. Therefore, previous calculations did not fully reflect the actual structure of the asteroid soil.
A new study published in the journal Nature Communications has taken this factor into account. Scientists have developed a universal model that relates the strength of a granular asteroid to two characteristics of its particles at once — size and shape.
Why are small particles holding onto a huge asteroid?
To understand the mechanism, the researchers focused on what happens at the points of contact between individual grains. The regolith particles come into contact with each other, and weak cohesive forces arise between them. Individually, they are almost invisible, but a huge number of such contacts can affect the mechanical properties of an entire surface area.
In the case of asteroids, Van der Waals forces are especially important. Previously, scientists assumed that they help small particles of regolith to hold together. However, to assess the strength of the entire asteroid, it is necessary to take into account not only the strength of an individual contact, but also how many such contacts occur inside the material.
The grain size becomes crucial here. The smaller they are, the more particles fit in the same volume and the more potential points of contact between them. An additional role is played by the shape: angular and irregular particles can form more contacts and adhere more tightly to each other than almost perfectly round ones.
It turns out to be a paradoxical situation at first glance: a huge asteroid may be weak not despite the large amount of material, but precisely because of the peculiarities of how this material is distributed. If there is a lot of space between large fragments and not enough fine dust, the number of bonds between the particles decreases, and with it the strength of the structure decreases.
Scientists have created a "bridge" of asteroid soil
It is not yet possible to simulate an entire asteroid taking into account each individual particle. Therefore, the researchers decided to study a small fragment of such a structure. In a computer model, they created a kind of "granular bridge" — a layer of particles between two large boulders, which then gradually moved apart.
The calculations used particles from 2 to 5 cm in size. The scientists tested 10 variants of their shapes, ranging from almost spherical to elongated and more angular. In total, the researchers conducted 78 simulations, considering both particles of the same type and mixtures of different shapes.
Paul Sanchez, senior researcher at the University of Colorado at Boulder and the first author of the paper
The shape of the particles is important because non-spherical particles can have many contacts and can also be very tightly packed, which increases the number of contacts and reduces porosity (empty space between particles. — Ed.).
During the simulation, the boulders gradually moved away from each other. At some point, the bonded particle layer stopped withstanding the load and collapsed. At this point, scientists could determine the tensile strength of the material. This approach allowed us to establish a general pattern: the strength of the granular structure depends both on the size of the grains and on how their shape differs from the sphere. Smaller and more angular particles create more contacts within a single volume and are therefore able to form a stronger structure.
To study Bennu, scientists also used data on the bonding forces between its particles, obtained from soil samples brought to Earth by NASA's OSIRIS-REx mission. This made it possible to apply the developed model directly to the surface of the asteroid.
The surface of the Bennu turned out to be weaker than ground coffee
Calculations have shown that the strength of the Bennu surface is less than 1 Pa. For comparison, the researchers used freshly ground coffee: a small cylinder of this material has a strength of about 50 Pa. In other words, the asteroid's surface is about 50 times fainter.
The reason, according to scientists, is the lack of the smallest particles. According to Sanchez, if there aren't enough of them, they can't fill the gaps between the larger debris. As a result, the number of contacts connecting the material into a single structure is reduced.
The obtained value is consistent with independent estimates made from remote observations of Bennu, as well as with what happened directly during sampling from its surface in 2023. Then the spacecraft encountered the unexpectedly loose structure of the asteroid, which also indicated its extremely low strength. At the same time, scientists emphasize that we are talking about the surface layer. The model describes a small portion of the granular structure, rather than the entire Bennu mass. The internal structure of the asteroid remains much less studied, so it is not yet possible to transfer the obtained value to the entire object.
Why know the strength of asteroids
Determining the strength is important not only for understanding how asteroids formed and evolved. These parameters are also necessary for modeling their behavior when colliding with other objects. This is especially important for planetary protection. If humanity ever needs to change the trajectory of a potentially dangerous asteroid, it is necessary to understand in advance how its surface and internal matter will react to the impact. One of the methods that has already been proven in practice is kinetic impact, which is a high—speed collision of a spacecraft with an asteroid.
NASA conducted such an experiment as part of the DART mission, sending the device to the asteroid Dimorphos. However, the effectiveness of such an impact depends on the properties of the celestial body itself. Therefore, data on particle size, shape, distribution, and porosity can become an important part of future collision models.
Paul Sanchez
Our theory is related to particle size, particle size distribution, and porosity. It can provide an initial approximation to the tensile strength and cohesive properties of asteroids. These are the main parameters of the material for programs simulating collisions with asteroids, the only proven method of deflecting asteroids.
In the next step, the scientists plan to expand the model to include a wider range of grain sizes, as well as try to describe the internal structure of asteroids. So far, direct data on the deep layers of such objects is extremely limited, so Bennu remains an example of how much an externally massive cosmic body can differ from the usual idea of a solid block of stone.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»