Span analysis: why the restoration of the Shukhov Tower caused controversy
The Shukhov Tower on Shabolovka is awaiting a large-scale restoration for the first time in a hundred years: the project involves dismantling five of the six sections of the structure and replacing some of the historical metal with modern analogues where necessary. The decision caused controversy among experts. Critics fear that after such works, the monument of the Soviet avant-garde will actually turn into a novelty. The project developers point to significant corrosion of structures and the need to ensure the safety of the structure. What exactly is planned to be preserved and why the restoration will require partial disassembly of the tower — in the material of Izvestia.
Monument to overcoming
In the spring of 1922, the newspaper Izvestia reported on a major victory on the labor front — on March 19, the Shabolovskaya radio station, designed by Vladimir Shukhov, began operating. The event was presented as an unprecedented breakthrough in Russian engineering. The openwork structure, almost 150 m high, was called "one of the most remarkable buildings in the modern conditions of life of the Russian Federation." A special reason for pride was that "the tower was built completely without scaffolding, a method that has not yet been used in Western Europe and America."
— According to the original design of my great—grandfather, the tower should have been slightly different - taller and more harmonious, but the country did not have the right assortment of metal. In an ideal model, the lower sections are made of a heavy, massive profile, and as you move up, where the load is less, it changes to a lighter and narrower one. Due to the acute shortage of rolled metal, we had to improvise and assemble some of the sections from exactly the same metal. This is the paradox: it is precisely due to the lack of materials that the structure has received its recognizable appearance — it is a monument to overcoming," Vladimir Shukhov, the great engineer's great—grandson and president of the Shukhov Tower Foundation, told Izvestia.

Today, the Shukhov Tower no longer performs a broadcasting function, but remains one of the recognizable monuments of the Soviet avant-garde in Moscow. Guided tours are conducted to the tower, introducing visitors to the engineering history of the structure. One of these groups gathered on Sunday, September 6th.
This is probably one of the last opportunities to see the tower before the start of large-scale work. For more than a hundred years, major repairs of the building have never been carried out. The work is scheduled to begin in October. The customer is the Russian Television and Radio Broadcasting Network (RTRS). The Glavgosexpertiza of Russia had previously issued a positive opinion on the conservation of an object of cultural heritage of federal significance.
"The project provides for the dismantling and replacement of the first to fifth sections of the tower and its other elements. Special attention will be paid to anti—corrosion protection when replacing parts," Konstantin Korsakov, a specialist at Glavgosexpertiza of Russia and chief expert of the project, is quoted as saying in an official release on the organization's website.
In addition, landscaping of the adjacent territory on an area of more than 649 square meters is planned.
The key point
A century later, a fundamental dispute broke out around the tower: how much historical material can be replaced so that the monument remains authentic.
— In 2022, RTRS agreed with the Ministry of Culture to upgrade the tower's status from a cultural heritage site of regional significance to a federal one. However, at the same time, they approved a modified, completely new monument protection item. It differed from the previous 2014 document in exactly one key point. Previously, the original Shukhov structures, assemblies, elements, materials and rivets were under state protection, but this item was simply removed from the new security item. It was in this stripped—down form that the document was agreed upon, which now paves the way for a large-scale replacement of historical details," architectural historian and urban defender Airat Bagautdinov shared his concerns with Izvestia.
The principles of scientific restoration require that the monument be preserved in its original material strictly according to the fixation measurement, said Andrey Batalov, head of the Architectural Monuments section of the Federal Scientific and Methodological Council of the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation and a member of its presidium.
— There is experience in restoring such facilities, although it requires non-trivial engineering solutions and serious costs. We have not yet seen a full—fledged restoration project for the tower - we have only been sent conclusions about its accident status with a request to allow dismantling. However, the idea of dismantling the monument and rebuilding it makes no sense. Due to the modern requirements of Glavgosexpertiza on safety, the metal of the elements will have to be thickened. As a result, the unique aerial, grid—like structure will be lost, and instead of a masterpiece of architecture, Moscow will receive a heavy structure similar to an ordinary power transmission tower," he said.
Before that, in 2025, the Vladimir Shukhov water tower in Vyksa, Nizhny Novgorod region, underwent restoration. It was reported that about 95% of the original metal was preserved in the process. The damaged one was repaired by laser surfacing. But the height of this structure is only 38 m. The main thesis of those who oppose the new project is the fear that after the restoration, the Shukhov Tower in Moscow will become a novelty.

— I am worried that the monument will simply be destroyed. Now we are talking about taking it all apart, trying to save something, and replacing something. And in this case, of course, it is likely to be just a novelty. Because it's quite difficult to assemble it as it is," says Vladimir Shukhov's great—grandson.
A security issue
Supporters of renewal, in turn, believe that Vladimir Shukhov's true legacy is his unique mathematical ideas, engineering solutions and recognizable geometry, which will be preserved when recreating elements from durable modern materials. It's about the parts where reinforcement is needed.

The theses about the destruction of the monument in the RTRS are considered unfounded and provocative, not based on competent knowledge about the properties of materials, engineering loads and urban planning standards. It is important that the project provides for the preservation of the original appearance and architectural silhouette.
"The physical properties of metal, like any other material, do not imply its eternal use. The structures of the Shukhov Tower are subject to significant corrosion and are beyond the standard life of their operation. There are no ways to restore metal structures that involve their reuse without loss of strength characteristics," the message on the official website of the RTRS says.
The restoration project is related not only to the preservation of the facility, but also to the issue of safety. The task is to prevent the possibility of collapse, given that people and buildings in the neighborhood may be affected.
"For a simple everyday understanding of the issue of preserving the Shukhov Tower, it is enough to imagine a situation in which an emergency bridge made of metal structures for railway transport across the river is proposed to be repaired by restoring corrosive metal structures (stripping, painting). Authenticity will be preserved, but the bearing capacity of the bridge will not be ensured, despite the significant financial investments spent. The threat of collapse will remain," the report says.
The reputable Tsniipromzdaniy is engaged in the development of technical solutions. Experts insist that classical conservation methods on Shabolovka are impossible due to deep internal defects in the metal. As a result, the project becomes a compromise between preserving the original scheme and ensuring security. A century after Izvestia celebrated Shukhov's breakthrough, the main thing becomes to preserve the unique structure for future generations, so that the openwork tower on Shabolovka remains a living monument to the engineering genius.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»