Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Telegram has been at the center of a legal scandal: the California-based QR Switch company has accused the messenger of illegally using QR authorization technology and is demanding compensation. The amount in the lawsuit was not named, but, according to lawyers, it could amount to tens of millions of dollars. We are talking about a feature familiar to every Telegram user: he scans the QR code on the computer screen with his phone and gets access to the account. Experts do not rule out that the messenger has become a victim of so—called patent trolls - companies that buy up the rights to inventions not in order to introduce them, but to threaten lawsuits against large companies. Previously, QR Switch had made similar claims to Walmart, QuikTrip, and Toyota. How the trial may end and whether messenger users will lose their usual function is described in the Izvestia article.

What is the essence of the claims against Telegram

QR Switch, a company registered in California in 2024, claims that Telegram uses technologies protected by two American patents issued in 2013 and 2016. We are talking about QR authorization to log in to the web version of the messenger or the application on your computer. The user sees the unique code, scans it with the Telegram mobile application, confirms the action on the phone and gets access to the account on the new device. QR login eliminates the need to manually enter a username, password, or one-time code and is used in a variety of digital services.

QR Switch patents describe a way to make an electronic screen interactive using a QR code. A code is displayed on a monitor, terminal, or other display, and the user scans it with a smartphone, after which the phone connects to an Internet service. The patent authors envisioned this technology as an alternative to a more complex direct connection of a phone to a screen, for example, via Bluetooth or NFC.

In the lawsuit against Telegram, QR Switch claims that the messenger uses this technology without the consent of its inventor, and demands compensation, which it calls reasonable royalties, as well as interest and legal costs. At the same time, the trial has just begun, the court has not yet established whether Telegram violated patents and whether it should pay.

How much can Telegram pay?

American law allows you to file a patent claim without specifying the final amount. At the first stage, the plaintiff may demand a so-called reasonable royalty. Its size is calculated later, after examining the product, the number of alleged violations, and the value of the disputed function.

— Reasonable royalties are the lower limit, not the ceiling. The main dispute is usually about what amount is considered reasonable," Martin Bozmarov, a New York intellectual property lawyer, explained to Izvestia.

According to him, the calculation in such cases is usually not based on the entire revenue of the product. It can only be about the value of a specific function — in this case, QR authorization.

The lawyer considers an agreement before the verdict to be the most likely scenario. The defendant's expenses for the trial, taking into account the payment for the services of lawyers and experts, can reach up to $ 10 million. Therefore, the settlement is more profitable and, according to the lawyer, can range from tens of thousands to several million dollars.

телеграм
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

As for the possibility of disabling this feature in Telegram as a result of claims, this is unlikely, according to lawyers. Even if the courts prove the use of an already patented technology, they usually only seek significant compensation, said Mikhail Gusev, lawyer, head of the Infralex dispute resolution practice.

— Given the widespread use of technology, in the event of a ban on its use, the balance of interests of the plaintiff and the defendant (and with it millions of users) will be disrupted. And this criterion is important for judges when making a decision," the lawyer explained.

In addition, Gusev drew attention to the fact that the court's decision on this dispute will be valid only in the United States (since it is specifically about American patents and does not concern the use of this technology outside the country). To ban the use of technology outside the States, it will be necessary to recognize the court's decision in other countries, the lawyer explained.

Izvestia sent a request to the judicial representatives of QR Switch and Telegram. No responses have been received at the time of publication.

From Walmart to Telegram

The American physicist Wesley Budville was named as the creator of the controversial developments in a court filing. QR Switch indicates that the inventor has transferred the rights to both patents to the company.

In a public biography on the General Assembly educational platform, Budville is named as a co-author of more than 34 patent applications. We are talking about developments in the field of QR codes, mobile applications, digital advertising, games, data exchange and Internet services.



The patents referenced by QR Switch themselves were registered more than 10 years ago, even before QR code entry became a common feature of digital services.

However, the mere existence of a valid patent does not automatically mean victory in court. The judges have yet to find out whether the technology used by Telegram matches the description in the patents and whether the company has indeed violated the exclusive rights of their holders.

The lawsuit against Telegram looks like a continuation of QR Switch's series of claims against large companies from various industries. In early 2025, the company filed lawsuits against the structures of the Walmart retail chain and the QuikTrip gas station chain. All of these claims also related to the use of QR code technology.

According to open sources, the proceedings with Walmart have already been terminated. The reasons were not publicly disclosed: it is unknown whether the parties entered into an agreement, whether the plaintiff withdrew the claims, or whether the case ended for another reason. The termination of the process itself does not confirm either the payment of QR Switch or the company's waiver of claims.

At the end of March 2026, QR Switch also went to court with claims against Toyota Motor North America. This dispute has not been considered yet.

Signs of patent trolling

Telegram has become a victim of so-called patent trolls, experts interviewed by Izvestia did not rule out. This is the name given to companies that receive the bulk of their income from licensing patents and filing claims, rather than from the production of goods or services.

телеграм
Photo: IZVESTIA/Yulia Mayorova

— QR Switch shows the classic markers of this model: a specialized company owns patents, makes a series of similar demands to large defendants, chooses a convenient jurisdiction and asks for a reasonable royalty without a pre—specified amount, - says Martin Bozmarov.

At the same time, in the lawsuit against Telegram, QR Switch does not declare its own mass QR authorization product and does not describe itself as a competitor to the messenger. Her goal, as stated in the document, is only to receive royalties for the intended use of the technology.

Another sign of patent trolling is the jurisdiction in which the claim is filed. The Eastern District of Texas has been repeatedly called the epicenter of patent litigation by the American legal press. According to Unified Patents, the Eastern and Western Districts of Texas accounted for more than 60% of patent cases in 2025.

Lawyer Mikhail Gusev noted that East Texas attracts patent plaintiffs because of the accumulated practice, the speed of the processes and the perception of local juries as less inclined to support the interests of large corporations.

телеграм
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

QR Switch's victory in one dispute will not deprive other companies of the right to re—challenge both the validity of patents and the very fact of infringement," explained Martin Bozmarov. But it can strengthen the company's negotiating position.

— The amount of the settlement or verdict turns into a guideline for the next auction: the copyright holder will be able to refer to it as a comparable license, — the lawyer emphasized.

The history of the technology market has already seen such concessions. In 2006, the manufacturer of BlackBerry devices, Canadian Research In Motion, paid NTP $612.5 million under a settlement agreement that ended a dispute over patents for wireless e—mail. The agreement was concluded against the background of the risk of restricting the operation of the service in the United States and did not mean recognition of a violation.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast