Stars oozed out: Russia has developed a new methodology for evaluating resorts
There is still a shortage of high—quality rooms in Russia - such facilities account for only 12-20% of the total number of accommodation facilities, experts told Izvestia. To solve the problem, they proposed to evaluate resorts in a new way: to see how much year-round infrastructure there is per hotel guest. The authors believe that this approach will balance the burden on infrastructure, stimulate the development of the premium segment and attract investors to create modern resort facilities. Whether the new methodology can help the industry is described in the Izvestia article.
How will the resorts be evaluated
A new analytical indicator for assessing the quality of resort hotel projects, the Resort infrastructure Coefficient (CCI), was developed by the Domos real estate platform and developer Gravion. The authors sent a letter with a proposal to the Ministry of Economic Development (Izvestia has it).
"Despite the development of domestic tourism, high—quality rooms in Russian resorts are still limited, and the pace of construction of new facilities with infrastructure for recreation and recreation is not keeping pace with demand," Yuri Nemanezhin, managing partner of Gravion, told Izvestia.
Ilya Umansky, President of the Russian Union of Travel Industry (PCT), told Izvestia that this problem is especially serious in regions with high and growing tourist demand. At the same time, according to him, it is important not to confuse the concepts of the quality of the room stock and the development of the hotel infrastructure.
"A high—quality room stock is primarily characterized by the age of the facility after construction or complex reconstruction, its technical condition, compliance with modern requirements and the availability of professional hotel management," he stressed. — Infrastructural saturation is another characteristic that is largely determined by the concept and specialization of the facility.
A resort hotel or sanatorium requires a more developed infrastructure — swimming pools, medical and SPA centers, restaurants, children's and sports spaces. An urban business hotel has completely different needs.
KKI offers calculations based on the area of infrastructure that guests can use all year round, and the average number of guests. Only hotel rooms are taken into account — without residences for owners. Heated pools, medical, SPA salons, wellness and fitness centers, children's clubs, business event venues and restaurants are taken into account. Beaches and other seasonal objects are not included in the indicator.
— The whole product is important: how much space and services the guest gets in addition to the room, whether the infrastructure works all year round and what leisure opportunities it offers, — said Yuri Nemanezhin. — CCI allows you to evaluate the quality of this infrastructure in one clear indicator. In addition, it can help distribute the load on resorts more evenly, stimulate the development of the premium segment and attract investors to create modern facilities.
For the pilot calculation, the analysts studied the four- and five-star hotels under construction located in the Adler district of Sochi, in the so-called golden triangle. They used open data from developers and project documentation. The results showed that the CCI may differ several times in different complexes. This means that the size of the hotel or site itself does not indicate how well the project is provided with infrastructure.
Izvestia sent a request to the Ministry of Economic Development with a request to confirm receipt of the letter and evaluate the proposed method.
How many high-quality rooms are there in Russia
According to the assessment of the founder and director of the portal Vseostroke.Svetlana Opryshko's Russian Federation, high-quality hotel rooms make up only 15-20% of the total offer. At the same time, there are many outdated facilities on the market — Soviet sanatoriums, small boarding houses and rental housing. On the contrary, there are not enough modern high-class hotels.
— The situation is particularly critical in the Kaliningrad region, Altai and Baikal, where the need for new hotels is ten times higher than the current pace of construction. A similar situation is developing in Sochi, Crimea and beyond," she said.
According to Aleksan Mkrtchyan, Vice President of the Alliance of Travel Agencies, official statistics may overestimate the share of high-quality rooms in Russia.
"I wouldn't talk about 20%," he stressed. — In my opinion, the real share of hotels with four stars and above is less than 12%. The main part of the room stock, about 88%, is apartments and hotels without stars or hotels with one, two and three stars. It is also necessary to take into account the fact that a significant part of the market is located in a gray area: guest houses and small facilities are not always included in official statistics.
According to his estimates, across Russia — from Kaliningrad to Kamchatka — there are not enough about 100 thousand high-quality rooms in four-star hotels and above.
"This is largely due to historical reasons,— says Aleksan Mkrtchyan. — In Soviet times, they tried to make recreation for workers and collective farmers inexpensive, but there was usually no talk of a high level of comfort. The high-quality service was mainly intended for foreign guests. As a result, there are many accommodation facilities left in the country, but there are still not enough modern high-class hotels.
Svetlana Opryshko named the high key rate and the rising cost of construction among the main problems — this hinders the launch of new projects. Hotels require large investments, and because of expensive loans, such construction projects often become unprofitable without significant government support.
"The situation is also affected by a shortage of qualified personnel and an increase in operating costs," the expert stressed. — The situation was aggravated by the fact that more than 75% of the room stock did not pass the "star" classification. Hoteliers are in no hurry to get certified due to the high tax burden and the cost of verification. As a result, the market becomes less transparent, and it is more difficult for tourists to understand in advance what level of service to expect from the hotel.
Will the new coefficient help the industry
Today, the buyer chooses not only the room, but also the environment, said Sergey Brazhnik, CEO of the Domos real estate platform.
— The living scenario is also becoming important: what can be done on the territory of the complex in summer and winter, how many public spaces are provided and whether guests will be comfortable when the hotel is fully loaded, — he noted. — At the same time, the area of the site or the scale of the project does not always reflect the real level of infrastructure provision.
According to Ilya Umansky, the proposed idea of improving the resort infrastructure "seems to be successful and in some cases may be useful." In particular, such an indicator can be considered when evaluating investment projects and determining the parameters of government support.
— As for the use of CCI as a guideline for the buyer of hotel real estate, its importance, in my opinion, should not be overestimated, — says the president of PCT. — For an investor, it is much more important not the number of square meters of infrastructure, but its relevance and impact on the project economy — workload, season duration, revenue and profitability.
The initiative to introduce CCI seems timely and professional, says Yana Ukhanova, CEO of Mantera Hotels. According to her, the industry really lacks an understandable quantitative indicator that would translate the vague concept of "environmental quality" into specific figures.
— For developers, this is a good benchmarking tool (a method of comparing their company's performance with market leaders. — Izvestia), for banks it is an additional risk filter, and for the state it is an indicator of the effectiveness of subsidized projects," she said.
However, according to Yana Sukhanova, CCI has three fundamental limitations, so it cannot solve all the problems of the industry. For example, year-round heated pools and year-round SPA areas require additional construction costs.
—Today in Russia, few investors are willing to freeze funds for 7-10 years at the current cost of debt financing," she said. — Until long-term lending specifically for infrastructure is available, CCI will remain only a statement of fact, but not a driver of change. In addition, the guest does not need a la carte restaurants and an extensive SPA in a three-star facility. Functional fitness and a buffet are in demand there. A high CCI for three stars will only mean inefficient use of space and an inflated room rate, which may scare away targeted tourists.
For a five-star hotel, on the contrary, a lack of infrastructure can lead to lower room prices and damage its reputation.
— It is worth adding an indicator to the calculation that takes into account the category of the hotel, for example, using increasing or decreasing coefficients, — she noted.
According to Svetlana Opryshko, it will not be possible to solve the problem of the lack of high-quality rooms only by increasing their number. An integrated approach is needed: at the same time, to develop the hotel infrastructure and increase the confidence of investors and market participants in the industry.
First of all, according to experts, large modern resort complexes with a well—developed family infrastructure are needed - water parks, swimming pools, various recreation formats and an all-inclusive system. In terms of service level and set of services, they should correspond to the best foreign resorts.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»