Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Russia has decided to tighten the fight against hidden forms of so-called borrowed labor, Izvestia found out. We are talking about situations where a person actually works for one company, but is officially registered in another. The employment relationship is disguised as a service agreement, which makes it possible not to register the employee directly and creates risks for his labor rights. The Association of Private Employment Agencies has sent initiatives to the Government that include the development of uniform criteria for identifying such cases. About how they plan to solve the issue of borrowed labor and whether it can be solved in principle, see the Izvestia article.

What is hidden borrowed labor?

The practice of using hidden forms of borrowed labor has become systemic in Russia, the Association of Private Employment Agencies Trud said. The organization sent a letter to Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin outlining its initiatives to remedy the situation (Izvestia has it).

работа
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

In this format, an employee works in the interests of one company, but is legally affiliated with another organization. Usually, such relationships are formalized through service contracts or outsourcing, which may cause employees to lose some of their labor guarantees.

According to the estimates in circulation, the volume of such a market in 2025 amounted to almost 11.5 trillion rubles. Up to 18 million people can work in shadow employment, according to the association.

"We are talking about replacing the contract for the provision of labor to employees under Chapter 53.1 of the Labor Code with a service contract," explained Sergey Peskov, president of the Trud Association of Private Employment Agencies. — Formally, the company receives the service from the contractor, but in reality, its employees can constantly work for the customer, comply with its internal rules and use its equipment. And this is already borrowed labor, which is prohibited in Russia, except in cases strictly stipulated by law.

As a result, employees are deprived of some of the guarantees provided for in official employment, the Association stressed. At the same time, the state does not receive personal income tax and insurance premiums, and companies operating in the legal field face unfair competition from businesses that reduce the cost of services through tax and social savings.

работа
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

A separate issue is the lack of clear criteria by which to distinguish real outsourcing from hidden borrowed labor. Because of this, it is difficult for customers, regulatory authorities and courts to clearly define the nature of such relationships. At the same time, according to the association, more than 90% of purchases of personnel services are made through electronic trading platforms.

The Association called for the creation of an interdepartmental headquarters under the Ministry of Economic Development with the participation of representatives of five departments and public organizations. We are also talking about uniform rules for differentiating outsourcing and staff provision, methodological recommendations, changes in legislation and control over online platforms. A separate point of the initiative is responsibility for companies operating without the necessary accreditation.

In addition, the organization has developed tools to identify signs of employment substitution. The methodology and the risk assessment questionnaire were reviewed jointly with Rostrud. Thus, when analyzing the contracts of one of the large retail chains with contractors, they revealed a possible underestimation of the tax base by 11 million rubles per month for one act.

налог
Photo: IZVESTIA/Yulia Khramtsova

The government has received a letter from the Association, sources in the Cabinet of Ministers told Izvestia.

Izvestia reference

Earlier, the Ministry of Labor clarified that borrowed labor is generally prohibited: according to the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, an employee cannot perform work on the orders and in the interests of a person who is not his employer, under his direction and control.

At the same time, the law directly regulates cases of temporary transfer of employees to other persons: chapter 53.1 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation establishes the specifics of labor relations when an employer temporarily sends its employees to third parties under a labor (personnel) contract.

A private employment agency or other legal entity, in accordance with the procedure and conditions provided for in Chapter 53.1, may, with the consent of an employee, refer him to a natural or legal person who is not an employer to perform the work functions provided for in the employment contract. At the same time, the provision of employees is permitted only in compliance with the rules established by law.

What are the pros and cons of the initiative?

The legalization of employment should solve not only a fiscal problem, noted in Trud. The withdrawal of workers from the shadow sector will provide them with social guarantees and reduce opportunities for dumping by unscrupulous companies. According to the Association's estimates, up to 50% of illegal employment is accounted for by contractors and outsourcing schemes.

работа
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

Today, it is especially important that competition for employees in the labor market takes place according to clear and transparent rules, added Arsen Badalyan, Deputy General Director of HR Capital. In conditions of staff shortages, companies are forced to look for more flexible hiring models, but sometimes the desire to reduce costs leads to the use of schemes that formally look like outsourcing, but actually replace labor relations.

"This creates additional risks for the employer, from tax claims and the need to review relations with employees to reputational, operational and criminal consequences," he said. — At the same time, bona fide companies are also suffering, which bear full-fledged expenses for registration of employees, pay taxes, insurance premiums, and provide social guarantees.

The use of non-transparent forms of employment, such as substituting an outsourcing contract for an actual employment relationship, creates unequal competition conditions in any service market, including logistics, said Irina Pak, HR Director of NC Logistic, a 3PL operator.

— Businesses should use only legal and transparent hiring tools. Clear rules that will help distinguish outsourcing from employee labor, reduce risks for companies and protect employee rights," she added.

работа
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet

The problem lies not so much in the actions of employers as in the fact that such violations are difficult to identify: currently there are no clear criteria by which to determine whether an employee's duties relate to an employment relationship or to work on a separate project, said Ekaterina Kosareva, managing partner of the VMT Consult agency.

According to her, recruitment sites earn money from traffic, but are not responsible for further relations between the customer and the contractor. The new rules should define their role and requirements for the operation of such resources. This will help protect employees, but at the same time it can increase business costs for completing already established processes. It is important to keep in mind that posting a vacancy or a response does not always lead to actual hiring.

— Among the non—obvious consequences, I would like to note an increase in state control over websites where you can find a specialist, - she noted. — This will require the development of IT solutions and the creation of the necessary infrastructure, which means additional costs for control automation. However, the costs will be offset by an increase in personal income tax receipts and insurance premiums — if the volume of shadow employment is really the same as the legislators calculated.

работа
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

In addition, a database of such sites may appear. They will probably need a special permit or a license to search for employees to work. This will make the labor market more transparent.

According to Arsen Badalyan, businesses need legal and flexible tools for attracting staff, especially in conditions of personnel shortage. Clear rules will help companies reduce legal risks, and employees to maintain the guarantees provided by law.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast