Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

A scheme is gaining momentum in Russia, in which, under the guise of individual studios, buyers are offered shares in spacious apartments with illegal redevelopment, lawyers and real estate market participants said. This practice is especially common in large cities, in particular, in Moscow and St. Petersburg. Sellers buy up neglected "two-bedroom apartments" and "three-bedroom apartments" and arbitrarily divide them into small isolated rooms, without registering separate cadastral numbers for them. For new owners, the acquired property turns into serious problems. The risks of such facilities and why they continue to be sold are described in the Izvestia article.

How to create studio shares

According to Alexey Zhuravlev, head of the Your Lawyer law office, professional market participants are behind such transactions. They can act through sole proprietors, LLC companies, or as individuals. They usually buy dilapidated spacious housing, which is then converted into several microstudies without the necessary permits. However, the changes are not formalized. After that, according to the expert, an agreement is drawn up on the order of ownership and use of the apartment, which is in common shared ownership, and upon the sale of each share, on the assignment of rights and obligations under it.

"The buyer is being persuaded that he gets an isolated room with an area of, say, 14.7 square meters for sole use," the lawyer emphasized. — But legally, the subject of the transaction remains a share in the right, and not a separate real estate object.

Пустая серая комната
Photo: IZVESTIA/Alexey Maishev

Elena Tikunova, head of the security unit at the federal company Etagi, noted that even when sellers officially announce the sale of shares, such transactions remain risky.

— If we talk about the volume of the offer, then about 1-1.5% of ads openly report the sale of shares on aggregators. About 1-1.5% more accounts for the gray market — cases when the buyer is not disclosed the real legal status of the object, she explained. — Some sellers go to such tricks in order not to lower the price. We only support share repurchase transactions with subsequent registration of full ownership rights.

Major repairs are being carried out in such apartments with the demolition and relocation of walls, the construction of blind partitions to create the effect of separate apartments, said Ekaterina Kosareva, managing partner of the VMT Consult agency.

"Engineering systems and kitchens are being installed," she pointed out. — But most often these are unauthorized alterations without official registration and approval from the housing inspectorate. This means that they are almost certainly made in violation of building regulations and may not be safe to live in.

Ремонт внутри квартиры
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet

According to Ekaterina Kosareva, sellers try not to talk directly about the status of the object, using vague phrases like "their own home" or "their own apartment." And in the photos and in the ads they try to create the impression that we are talking about a full-fledged separate housing.

— It is not difficult to be deceived if you do not check the extract from the Unified State Register of Legal Entities. It will indicate that we are talking about an apartment with shared ownership, and not about individual objects, and the cadastral number of all "apartments" will be the same," the expert noted.

St. Petersburg was one of the first to encounter such a practice, including due to the large number of communal apartments preserved in the city, said Igor Gorsky, vice president of the Russian Guild of Realtors (RGR).

"Such facilities were bought out, each room was actually converted into a separate studio and then they were actively offered to investors," he said. — The Association of Realtors of St. Petersburg and the Leningrad region strongly opposes such schemes.

Сверка проектной документации
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

The expert also noted that when buying such housing, a person often receives not a separate object, but a share in the ownership of one apartment.

What are the risks of micro-apartments

Developers also record such schemes. According to Svyatoslav Ivanov, head of the sales department of the Rasvetay Stolitsa company, this practice discredits the entire industry.

— The consequences for the buyer are extremely severe: legally, he becomes not the owner of the studio, but the co-owner of a share in a large apartment, while automatically being recognized as a violator of the law, since redevelopment is often not agreed upon.

Alexey Popov, chief analyst at Cyan, called the signs of such studio shares: differences in layouts compared to the floors above and below, non-standard layouts for bathrooms, wet areas and ventilation, as well as too attractive a price.

Девушка осматривает квартирное помещение
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

Ekaterina Kosareva stressed that such housing would be difficult to sell.

"A fine is likely, as the responsibility for illegal redevelopment lies with the new owner," she added. — The fine is small — about 2.5 thousand rubles for individuals. However, at the same time, the person receives an order to return "as it was." In extreme cases, when redevelopment poses a danger to the residents of the entrance, the court may forcibly evict the new owner.

A separate problem is the kitchen area and bathroom, located where they should not be. Such engineering solutions can be unreliable and increase the risk of accidents, problems with electricity and ventilation.

"And neighbors can complain about the noise from using plumbing in such converted apartments," she added.

Человек набирает воду в кастрюлю
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

According to the owners of microstudies, it is almost impossible to legalize redevelopment in apartments above the ground floor.

"The neighbors of the "normal" apartments are not happy with the increased load on communal utilities and drip into the Moscow Housing Inspectorate. And then the court obliges to return everything to its original form. In addition, the owners of the shares can move anyone there, and in fact the same communal apartment is obtained. It is very difficult to live in such conditions," wrote one of the buyers.

How to detect deception

Acquiring a share is one of the most risky types of transactions, Elena Tikunova believes. According to Svyatoslav Ivanov, among the main risks is the inability to formalize ownership of a separate object, the requirement to return the premises to their original form and pay the fine on their own. In addition, the transaction may be invalidated through the court, after which the parties will return to their original position.

"Such redevelopments are often carried out in violation of engineering standards, which creates risks of accidents, network overload, and even structural collapse," he stressed. — Before the transaction, you need to check the extract from the Unified State Register of Legal Entities and make sure that the premises have the status of independent housing. It is also worth requesting documents for redevelopment approval. Otherwise, the money saved on the purchase may result in high court costs and even a complete loss of investments.

Представитель исполнительной власти изучает документы
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

The lack of a cadastral number is the main indicator that the share is being sold, said Dmitry Proskurin, commercial director of Metrium.

The expert advised potential buyers to always request an extract from the Unified State Register of Legal Entities — it will show whether the room is a separate apartment or part of another facility.

— You can do this through the Gosuslugi portal, the Rosreestr website, or during a personal visit to the MFC. The self—issued statement contains all the necessary information about the apartment, except for the name and other personal data of the owner," he added.

Also, buyers should check the technical data sheet of the premises. It is not necessary to purchase housing with redevelopment if there is no act of completion for it. Otherwise, the new owner may face a fine, and in some cases, the obligation to return the apartment to its original appearance at his own expense.

Dmitry Proskurin also noted that it is worth being wary if the owner insists only on paying in cash. According to him, this may be due to the fear that a bank check will reveal legal problems and the deal will fail.

Сверка проектной документации
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet

Alexander Yakubovsky, a member of the State Duma Committee on Construction and Housing and Communal Services, told Izvestia that lawmakers had already begun to fight such a scheme. In particular, it is no longer possible to artificially allocate shares with an area of less than 6 square meters. m.

— But practice has shown that this is not enough, because a large apartment can be divided into shares larger than the established minimum and continue to sell them as separate studios, — said the parliamentarian.

Alexander Yakubovsky believes that the problem needs to be solved systematically: if the premises are sold as independent housing, it must be legally registered, meet the requirements for residential facilities and have a separate cadastral registration. If a share is sold, it must be explicitly designated as a share — it cannot be given out in an advertisement or contract for a separate apartment or studio. According to the deputy, it is the elimination of this substitution, and not only the tightening of fines for illegal redevelopment, that will help to stop this practice.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast