Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

The lawyer spoke about the impact of citizenship on Durov's extradition in the terrorism case.

Kutuzova: the decision on Durov's extradition will be made by his host state
0
Photo: Global Look Press/Steffens/Keystone Press Agency
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The possible extradition of Telegram founder Pavel Durov depends not only on the charges brought, but also on the country of his actual location, citizenship and legislation of a particular state. Lawyer and human rights activist Ekaterina Kutuzova explained on July 29 to Izvestia what factors would be important when considering such an issue.

According to the expert, Durov's citizenship of several countries makes the extradition procedure more complicated from the point of view of international law. At the same time, the passport of a certain state by itself does not guarantee full protection from extradition: the key role is played by the place where the person is at the time of possible detention.

Kutuzova noted that if Russia initiates an extradition procedure, it has the right to send a corresponding request to a foreign state in accordance with Russian criminal procedure legislation and international treaties.

"However, putting a person on the international wanted list does not mean automatic extradition. The state in whose territory the wanted person is located independently decides on his detention and possible extradition on the basis of its own legislation," the lawyer emphasized.

Citizenship is of particular importance in such procedures. According to the lawyer, a number of countries restrict or completely prohibit the extradition of their own citizens to foreign countries. For example, the Russian Constitution stipulates that a citizen of the Russian Federation cannot be extradited to another state. Similar restrictions apply in France: French law also provides for the refusal to extradite its own citizens. Thus, if Durov is located on the territory of Russia or France and retains the citizenship of the relevant country, his extradition may be legally impossible.

At the same time, Russian citizenship by itself does not exclude the possibility of extradition if a person is in a third country, Kutuzova added. In this case, the decision will be made according to the laws of the host country, and the presence of a Russian or French passport does not extend the norms of these states to another jurisdiction.

According to the lawyer, when considering an extradition request, several circumstances are taken into account at once: the nationality of a person, his location, the existence of international extradition treaties, the nature of the charges, the principle of double criminality, the statute of limitations, the possible political component of persecution and respect for human rights.

Separately, the lawyer stressed that international search and extradition are different procedures. The Interpol Red Notice is not an international arrest warrant and does not automatically oblige countries to detain a person. It only informs the law enforcement agencies of different states about the search for a person, and the decision on detention is made by each country independently in accordance with its internal laws.

According to Kutuzova, in the case of Durov, the most important factors will be the combination of Russian and French citizenship, the possible status of a UAE citizen, his location and the legal assessment of the charges.

The expert added that it is more legally correct to talk not about protection at the expense of one of the passports, but about the totality of legal guarantees that apply in a particular country. It is the legislation of the receiving State that will determine whether a person can be detained, whether his extradition is possible, and what grounds may lead to a refusal of extradition.

Pavel Durov, the founder of Telegram, was charged on the same day in the case of facilitating terrorist activities in Ukraine, and he is on the international wanted list. The reason for the criminal case was the investigation of the activities of the chatbot "Diver/Leo — dating, communication and new friends" in Telegram. Previously, it was included in the unified register of prohibited information of Roskomnadzor.

The agency also stated that the administration of the messenger had not deleted prohibited information and a number of channels, chats and bots that were used by Ukrainian special services and terrorist organizations. The FSB Central Control Center reported that the Ukrainian special services used a "Diving Agent/Leo" to involve Russian citizens in terrorism. Since July 2025, 46 Russian citizens aged 12 to 22 have been detained as a result of joint activities.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast