- Статьи
- Economy
- Food allowances: five departments will have access to end-to-end price monitoring at once
Food allowances: five departments will have access to end-to-end price monitoring at once
For the first time, Russian business has publicly opposed certain provisions of the draft law on end—to-end price monitoring - entrepreneurs are afraid of expanding officials' access to commercial information. The State Duma told Izvestia that, in addition to the Federal Tax Service, four more departments will receive it — the Ministry of Industry and Trade, the Ministry of Agriculture, the Ministry of Energy and the Federal Antimonopoly Service. The lower house of parliament assured that the risks of leaks are excluded, because the list will be strictly limited. End—to-end monitoring will allow you to track the cost of goods at all stages - from the manufacturer to the store, identify unjustified margins and analyze the reasons for the rise in price. Whether this will help in the fight against rising prices is in the Izvestia article.
How do the authorities want to control inflation
The authorities decided to strengthen control over food prices along the entire food chain, from production to sale. The government has submitted a bill on this to the State Duma, and it has already passed the first reading.
The document gives the Cabinet the right to determine which federal agencies will be able to receive data from the Federal Tax Service on companies selling food and services that are taken into account when calculating inflation. They will have access to information about prices, sales volumes, transactions and financial indicators of the business. Such data is planned to be used to monitor prices and analyze the reasons for their changes.
The bill has caused discontent among businesses. The CCI has sent its proposals to the State Duma Committee on Industry and Trade (the editorial board has the main initiatives). As Sergey Katyrin, president of the business association, explained to Izvestia, the document should include an exhaustive list of departments that will be able to receive data on companies, as well as limit its effect to socially significant goods. Besides, price monitoring should not create risks for the commercial secrets of companies, Sergey Katyrin is sure.
The responsible committee of the State Duma told the editorial board that they had reviewed the CCI's appeal. They added that the list of agencies that will be able to receive information will be limited. It will include the Ministry of Industry and Trade, the Ministry of Agriculture, the Ministry of Energy, the Federal Antimonopoly Service and the Federal Tax Service. Izvestia sent them requests, and the departments forwarded them to the Ministry of Industry and Trade.
"The transition to end—to-end monitoring of the entire supply chain will make it possible to track not only final retail prices, but also to identify the causes, factors of price formation (seasonality, rising prices of raw materials, logistics), as well as the stages at which unreasonably high trade margins are formed," the State Duma said.
They noted that if the Federal Tax Service begins to provide other agencies with access to business data (income, expenses and profits), this will increase control over the cost of products and eliminate possible manipulation by unscrupulous market participants.
At the same time, access to information will be strictly limited. The data will remain under the regime of tax secrecy and will be able to be disclosed only in cases stipulated by law. Officials will be held criminally responsible for the unlawful disclosure of information, the committee added.
In addition, the government will approve a separate list of food products, the prices of which have the greatest impact on inflation (for example, pasta), the State Duma reported.
Why do we need to control price growth in Russia?
Annual inflation in Russia accelerated to 6.02% in June from 5.31% in May. Consumer prices rose by 0.87% over the month, and by 4.19% since the beginning of the year, according to the Ministry of Economic Development. The largest contribution was made by services — they rose in price by 1% in a month and by 10.58% in a year. Non—food products increased in price by 1% (5.26% YoY), food - by 0.65% (3.42%). Fuel also increased in value over the month: natural gas — by 8.1%, diesel — by 7.1%, motor gasoline — by 6.9%. The press service of the Ministry of Industry and Trade separately stressed that inflation in the food sector is still below the target of 4%.
The proposed bill is designed to eliminate blind spots in the pricing system, said Natalia Milchakova, a leading analyst at Freedom Global. Now, with a sharp increase in the cost of certain goods, the government cannot always quickly determine at what stage the rise in price occurred and what caused it.
The buyer sees only the final cost, but the reasons for the increase can occur at any link in the chain — during production, processing, transportation, from wholesale suppliers or in retail, explained economist Olga Gogaladze.
If the population really sees that the authorities have established transparent control over pricing, this will reduce inflation expectations. When consumers predict a sharp increase in the cost of products, they begin to buy them for future use, which can provoke increased demand and additional pressure, says Arthur Leer, president of the Association of Exporters and Importers, managing partner of Lex Alliance Law Firm. At the same time, the business, fearing rising costs, puts these risks in advance in the cost of goods.
— Until now, the FAS has remained the main instrument for controlling unjustified price increases. However, the service mainly reacts to the fact of an increase in cost and does not always have data that allows us to identify the reasons for such an increase in advance and objectively assess its validity. Because of this, there remains a risk of erroneous conclusions regarding manufacturers or sellers," Natalia Milchakova noted.
The new mechanism will make it possible to identify unscrupulous schemes in the supply chain, Olga Gogaladze noted. We are talking about cases when goods are formally resold several times through affiliated companies or one-day firms, which artificially increases its value.
Another task is to identify deficit risks in a timely manner. If manufacturers have problems due to a shortage of raw materials, packaging, or supply disruptions, the government will be able to notice them before this leads to a reduction in supply in stores, the expert noted.
Will the mechanism allow to control inflation in the country
End-to-end monitoring will help to better understand how prices are formed, but will not solve the key causes of inflation, Olga Gogaladze noted. They are primarily caused by fundamental factors such as rising business costs for raw materials, logistics, energy resources and wages, staff shortages, rising fuel prices, changes in the exchange rate and other macroeconomic processes. Therefore, the new system will only make it possible to more accurately diagnose the causes of the rise in price, but by itself it will not be able to contain inflation.
Business is interested in a transparent environment and fair conditions, but a fine line runs between control and excessive interference, said Artur Leer from Lex Alliance Law Firm. Regulation should be aimed at stopping fraudulent activities, rather than narrowing the room for bona fide entrepreneurs to maneuver.
— It is important for the state to maintain a balance — to create a system that ensures transparency and uniform rules of the game, but at the same time does not turn into a mechanism of overprotection, suppressing initiative and imposing unbearable costs on business. The main task is to discipline the market without depriving entrepreneurs of the opportunity to make effective business decisions," he said.
However, the Ministry of Industry and Trade clarified to Izvestia that the draft law does not introduce new methods of regulating trading activities and does not establish additional requirements for conducting business.
Thus, the draft law can become an effective price monitoring tool, but it alone will not solve the problem of inflation. The business believes that the document needs to be finalized, and control over the supply chain will not eliminate the fundamental causes of rising prices — increased business costs, staff shortages, rising fuel prices and other macroeconomic factors.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»