Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Land owners will be obligated not to obstruct the access of telecom operators and infrastructure builders to their territory. This is stated in the materials of the Ministry of Finance on the updated Strategy for the development of the communications industry. Now the right of unhindered access (public easement) It does not apply to plots for private homes and private farms. As a result, it is difficult for operators to negotiate with many disparate private owners. Conflicts over the laying of communication lines and the installation of cell towers occur regularly — the showdown often ends in the courts. According to experts, the new rules will speed up the construction of communication facilities, simplify the connection of territories to the Internet and reduce the number of proceedings. At the same time, they warn that land owners may more often face inconveniences associated with construction work and infrastructure maintenance.

Why do operators need access to private land

Telecom companies and infrastructure operators building cell towers and other communication facilities will have unhindered access to land plots of all forms of ownership. Such plans are mentioned in the materials sent by the Ministry of Finance for interdepartmental coordination as part of updating the Strategy for the development of the communications industry until 2035. Izvestia has reviewed the document.

Обслуживание аппаратуры на опоре двойного назначения
Photo: IZVESTIA/Andrey Erstrem

"It is required to legislate the possibility of establishing a public easement for the placement of communications infrastructure on land plots of all forms of ownership, create a legal framework for maintaining a single digital Register of communications infrastructure facilities, and also consolidate the principle of "tacit consent" when issuing permits for the placement of communications facilities," the document says, which was reviewed by Izvestia.

According to the principle of "tacit consent", if the authorized state agency has not sent a reasoned refusal to issue a construction permit within the time limit prescribed by law, the permit is considered to have been issued automatically.

A public easement is a restriction on the rights of the landowner, which allows the use of this land in the public interest and in the interests of the population, explained Maxim Kuznetsenkov, partner of the real estate and construction practice at Melling, Voitishkin and Partners. Such a mechanism can be used, for example, to ensure passage or passage through the site, citizens' access to publicly accessible water bodies, grazing and herding of farm animals, as well as for hunting, fishing and other legally prescribed purposes.

Частная территория
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

In his opinion, the introduction of a public easement in the communications legislation will allow organizations that place and operate cell towers, cable sewers or build data processing centers to freely place these facilities on land.

The Ministry of Finance has prepared and sent for approval by the interested departments a draft report that contains key areas for updating the Strategy for the development of the communications industry of the Russian Federation for the period up to 2035, the ministry told Izvestia. They were formulated based on the results of consideration of proposals from interested ministries and ANO "Digital Economy" on the site of SIC Telecom with the involvement of the expert community, they said.

"One of these areas is the issue of simplifying the procedure for establishing a public easement for the placement of antenna—mast structures and communication lines," the Ministry of Digital Affairs said. — At the same time, the draft report notes that work is currently continuing with the industry and interested departments to update the strategy, including discussing a number of other proposals.

The final version of the report on the implementation of the instructions is not yet available, the Ministry of Finance added.

Сотрудник во время замены коммутационного оборудования
Photo: TASS/Natalia Shatokhina/NEWS.ru

MegaFon supports the initiative. They believe that in practice, such projects often require lengthy approvals from land rights holders, and deadlines may increase due to differences in approaches to access registration and the lack of a uniform procedure for different categories of land and forms of ownership. All this eventually slows down the construction and modernization of networks, the company said.

Formally, both telecom operators and telecom infrastructure builders have the right to receive public easements from 2023, but in practice the mechanism needs to be improved, in particular, because now it is not possible to access all land plots with its help. For example, it is now prohibited to issue public easements for plots for individual housing construction, personal subsidiary farms and reserve lands, Anatoly Galkin, director of Rostelecom's TEA NEXT project office, told Izvestia.

— Payments for public easements do not cover losses and losses on agricultural land, the calculation of the cost of these losses is often the subject of serious disagreement and slows down the construction process. Also, the issue of the absence of the need for land reclamation during trenchless passage has not been fully fixed. Almost all issues can be resolved at the legislative level," he believes.

Трактор капает траншею
Photo: TASS/Vladimir Smirnov

Even if an easement is established, its recipient must agree with the owner or tenant of the site on a fee for its use, added Leonid Konik, a partner at ComNews Research.

— The holder of a public easement is obliged to conclude an agreement with the owner or tenant of the site, as well as to bring the site into a condition suitable for use. In practice, this often leads to protracted conflicts between the telecom operator and the owner or tenant of the land," he said. — When laying main communication lines, private land plots — residential housing or subsidiary farms - are often found on the way. It is very difficult for an operator or a construction company to negotiate with many disparate users.

If the possibility of extending the mechanism of public easement to the placement of communication facilities on land plots of all forms of ownership is really being considered, this can significantly simplify the construction of the backbone and regional telecommunications infrastructure, Leonid Konik believes.

Will the new regulations accelerate the construction of communication lines

Denis Kuskov, CEO of TelecomDaily, said that conflicts over the laying of communication lines and the installation of towers regularly occur in the north-west of Russia, in the central regions, and in the vicinity of large cities. As a rule, this happens in conditions of dense suburban development or, for example, where fields have been transferred and divided into building plots — sometimes even before the advent of mobile communications there, he claims.

Сотрудник во время замены коммутационного оборудования
Photo: TASS/Natalia Shatokhina/NEWS.ru

For example, a few years ago, Link Development, which was building communications infrastructure in the Leningrad Region, could not obtain part of the sites for the placement of antenna and mast structures. The dispute between her and the owners reached the arbitration courts.

During the construction of a communication line in the Novosibirsk region, a MegaFon contractor laid a fiber-optic cable with a deviation from the agreed route, as a result of which the cable ended up on a private plot. But the owner did not give consent to the use of his land. As a result, in 2021, the court ordered to dismantle the cable and release the land.

The development of networks today depends not so much on equipment as on access to land, says Oleg Yablokov, NTI expert on wireless communications. In order to consolidate networks, pull fiber into sparsely populated areas and along transport corridors, install base stations and supports, operators have to place facilities on a variety of sites of different forms of ownership. The situation is aggravated by the transition to the joint use of passive infrastructure — poles and lines are increasingly being built and operated by specialized infrastructure companies, rather than the operators themselves, he said.

— The main problem of access is the need to negotiate with each owner individually. This is poorly predictable: the owner may refuse, delay approval, or request a disproportionate fee, and for linear objects crossing dozens of sections, one refusal is enough to block the entire route," he says.

The consolidation of a public easement as a single mechanism removes dependence on the will of an individual owner, whose interests are protected by the established fee and order, Oleg Yablokov believes. For the industry, the main thing here is the predictability of terms and conditions, he said.

However, more inconveniences may arise for people — there is a risk that land plots may be significantly changed, the soil is damaged, a significant part of it will be blocked by a cell tower or a cable around which nothing can be built, said Eldar Murtazin, a leading analyst at Mobile Research Group.

Установка оборудования на вышке сотовой связи
Photo: RIA Novosti/Yakov Andreev

According to him, the purpose of the innovations is to ensure that this infrastructure remains in place for many years, but there should be no abuse by land owners.

Expanding the access rights of operators and infrastructure builders to land plots will make it possible to connect homes and entire areas to the Internet, where it is often impossible to cable due to the resistance of land owners, says Denis Kuskov. The quality of cellular communications will also improve — supports for antennas and base stations can be installed where it is currently impossible, the expert added. But, on the other hand, the presence of such facilities can create inconveniences for owners of private houses and residents of cottage settlements, so when building such facilities, the interests of all parties must be taken into account, he concluded.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast