Experts have assessed the risks and benefits of "whining" on the Internet
A new trend is gaining popularity on the Internet — paid "whining". Anonymous listening to complaints is in demand due to the lack of commitment. All the details are in the Izvestia article.
Reasons for the demand for the service
Ahmed Yusupov, a partner at the Goldman and Po communication agency, notes that the popularity of "whining" is caused by emotional scarcity and lack of time. With a constant flow of information, people lack live contact, and delegating the opportunity to speak out is easier than looking for an understanding listener among loved ones.
According to Yusupov, this service was a reaction to the popularity of coaching. If coaches are focused on goals and actions, then whining gives them the right to just be in the negative. The expert believes that this is not a temporary trend, but a transition to an economy of impressions, where value shifts from functions to emotional experience.
"Of course, some of the demand may subside when the wave of novelty passes, but the need for emotional service itself is likely to gain a foothold," Akhmed Yusupov said.
Psychological aspects and risks
Clinical psychologist, CBT therapist Anastasia Helemelya explains the effectiveness of the format by saying that at the moment of emotion a person needs validation of his feelings, not logical advice. Phrases like "don't worry" are often perceived as toxic positivity and devaluation, which only increases feelings of guilt and isolation.
However, the specialist warns about the risks of fixation on negativity and the formation of dependence on third-party listeners. The service provider does not have to be psychologically stable, which may increase the client's anxiety. Anonymity on the Internet reduces the level of shame, but does not replace a full-fledged inner work.
"Think of this service as aspirin — it will relieve the fever, but it will not cure the disease," Anastasia Khelemelya emphasized.
Differences from therapy and friendly support
"Whining" is fundamentally different from psychotherapy in terms of goals: the service works only with the current emotion, while therapy looks for the causes of problems and changes thinking. The format also differs from friendship in the absence of mutual obligations. In a paid service, the client is not obligated to take care of the other person's feelings.
Anastasia Helemelya recommends using "whining" only to relieve situational irritation. If the need to speak out occurs more than twice a week or the complaints are cyclical, this may indicate chronic stress or burnout. In such cases, empathy is not enough and the help of a professional psychologist is required.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»