"The word "lose" should not be applied to the economy"
The Russian economy as a whole remains flexible, but this flexibility can easily be "overloaded" with unnecessary regulations, Maxim Reshetnikov, Minister of Economic Development, told Izvestia at the SPIEF. According to him, competition plays a key role — when one or two players concentrate the market, they begin to "push through" the rules. This is especially noticeable in online platforms, which become the "goalkeepers" of market entry, and the issue of returns already affects business costs. At the same time, in tourism, the minister noted, it is important to adjust the responsibility of operators without shifting risks to people. In an exclusive interview with Izvestia, Maxim Reshetnikov talks about how the economy has withstood shocks, the direction in which the labor market is changing, and why foreign investors are coming to Russia.
"The main thing is that we have preserved the market nature of the economy"
— We now live in a world in which, according to you, reality changes about once every two weeks. How do you account for such constant changes in external factors?
— If you take the six years that the government has been in operation, then every two or three years there is some kind of new reality. The coronavirus pandemic has changed the rules of the game, but it has also left behind a stronger economy. We have overcome COVID and have become more resilient and strong, like this economic organism.
We are currently in a period of freedom, and in 2022-2023 we were just adapting, looking for a new model. But the main thing is that we have preserved the market nature of the economy and its openness to foreign economic relations.
Now we are entering the next stage, which we are only just realizing. But the main trends are already clearly visible.
— What are our key risks?
— I would talk not so much about risks as about tasks. The first is to respond to external changes in time, because the sanctions pressure has not gone away. Both the 21st and 22nd sets of restrictions are already being prepared — and all this requires constant reaction, communication with partners, building relationships and completing the infrastructure, which is either lacking or blocked somewhere.
We are constantly engaged in payment systems, transportation, and ship insurance. Therefore, on the external track, this is really the focus of government and business attention — it is a constant job that requires time and effort.
If we talk about internal tasks, it's the labor market and the search for additional resources. This includes working on performance. Plus, the issue of investments: they are now projected to decrease, but this does not mean that the development paths are closed.
It is important to think more about how effectively what has already been created is being used. In this sense, the platform economy helps a lot.
It actually teaches you how to make the best use of existing resources — whether it's machines, machine tools, or other equipment. Due to this, the economy is able to grow by about 10% on the current basis — there is such a potential.
Plus, you still need to invest: they are there, they are coming, they need to be approached more carefully.
And most importantly, about the models. We have talked a lot about the fact that they will constantly change, because the external conditions are changing and development is underway. The question is not whether new models will appear, it is inevitable. The question is whether they will adequately reflect reality and be able to change in time.
And it depends on the institutions. If they are built correctly, the economy will adapt faster. We are talking about market institutions: protection of property rights, competition, free pricing and openness of external relations.
"The labor market has become more complex, and it can no longer be explained by simple indicators alone"
— Now the employee's market has changed to the employer's market. Do you see any risks in this?
— It seems like yes, it seems like no. It feels like there are changes, but it's not so noticeable in numbers. We still have low unemployment. Yes, the number of employees at risk of dismissal has increased slightly compared to two years ago, but overall it is far from some crisis levels. So in terms of numbers, the labor market situation is generally normal.
I agree that the number of vacancies per employee has decreased. But maybe it's something else — we just started expecting more. Now we need a more active staff transfer to create space for the next stage of economic growth.
But in general, the processes are underway. It's just that the labor market has become more complex, and it can no longer be explained by simple indicators alone.
Platform employment has grown significantly. People actively take advantage of new opportunities and take part—time jobs - warehouse, taxi, tutoring. Now it has become very easy to find additional income. It is earnings that are not just salaries.
And one more thing — there is also a flow within enterprises. Companies have already stopped firing through the threat of dismissal. I know the cases: There are two factories nearby, one without orders, the other, on the contrary, is overloaded. The directors simply negotiate — people are offered to switch to better terms. And people are calmly crossing over. Moreover, this often does not get into the statistics or anywhere else.
"The experience of the last five or six years shows that our economy is generally flexible"
— Is the efficiency of enterprises improving?
— This just gives enterprises the opportunity to wait out the period of reduced workload. Because they don't stay without orders anyway — it's more often about a temporary drop in volumes. On the contrary, it helps another company to complete its orders faster. Then the reverse process can also be activated — the economy is quite flexible in this sense.
— In your opinion, is it flexible enough?
— The experience of the last five or six years shows that our economy is generally flexible. But this does not mean that you do not need to work on this flexibility. We often limit it by regulation ourselves: solving one problem, we add restrictions here, here and here — and as a result, the system begins to react worse to changes.
This needs to be done all the time. Competition is very important. Because when there are one or two manufacturers on the market - it doesn't matter if they are state—owned or private — they still start to "push through" solutions: to raise the duty somewhere, to conduct an investigation somewhere, to impose restrictions somewhere. This needs to be constantly monitored.
In practice, there are many situations where balancing decisions have to be made. Yes, a specific issue needs to be addressed somewhere, but at the same time, we must not deviate from the basic principles so that the system as a whole develops and evolves correctly.
— Can we say that a certain crisis of trust in the relations between the state and business has been overcome? Do you think that small and medium-sized businesses are now on the verge of running out of resources?
— I would not say that we have had or have any crisis of trust between business and the state. This means that there is a normal communication system, there is movement towards each other, and there are platforms where these issues are discussed. From this point of view, there is communication, and there are platforms.
"Platforms are becoming what are called "goalkeepers" in Europe, meaning they actually control market entry"
— You have often mentioned the concept of a platform economy. What do you see as the ideal rules of the game in this market, including the laws?
— First of all, platforms are now perhaps one of the main drivers of labor productivity growth and economic efficiency.
Secondly, this market itself has grown rapidly. The turnover of platforms is already about 30% of retail trade, which is already a very significant share.
At the same time, the platforms become what is called "goalkeepers" in Europe, that is, they actually control the entry to the market. Plus, they tend to have a monopoly: usually there are one or two large platforms in the segment, at most two and a half. And then they begin to unite with each other due to synergy and gradually enter even the financial sector — we are already witnessing this.
Therefore, there is a need for competition and regulation so that there are equal rules of the game for everyone. First of all, for small businesses that sell their goods and services through platforms.
This is the main objective of the draft law, which will be effective from October 1. For example, every product card on the marketplace — and there are tens of millions of them — should be checked against ten parameters in government databases — and this should be done regularly, almost online. This is a big data exchange, separate storefronts are being formed, and all this is aligned with the platforms.
The most striking example, which we have not yet fully worked out, is the return of goods of proper quality. Now the stories begin: "it didn't fit" or "I wore it for two weeks and returned it." The same children's costumes, Christmas trees in January, and so on.
On the one hand, it may sound ridiculous. On the other hand, for small businesses, these are direct costs: round-trip logistics, and the goods are often returned in a different condition. And the seller cannot influence this. Therefore, it is necessary to change the rules of refunds on marketplaces, including the law on consumer protection, which is what we are currently doing.
And we have several such cases. Plus, a separate topic is competition: between our and foreign suppliers, as well as between the platforms themselves. All this requires constant adjustment of regulation, including at the EAEU level.
"From a humanitarian point of view, there is an information war going on against us"
— One of the possible growth points is tourism. The country allows you to travel to almost any place at any time of the year. Are we creating normal conditions now or are we still losing? To what extent are the rules of the game clearly defined here and are we able to compete with outbound tourism in the end?
— In general, I think the word "lose" should not be applied to economics. Tourism in the country is actively developing now, and this is not just a story of recent years, but the result of investments that have already come and continue to come, despite the high rates.
Now we have about 360 hotels and about 40 ski resorts, amusement parks, and so on. Approximately 400 projects are at various stages of implementation. The total amount of investments is about 1.9 trillion in preferential programs alone, and these are large hotels with 120 rooms. Smaller-scale projects are also actively developing on market conditions.
Tourism is growing both in terms of infrastructure and demand. And the fact that the market is promising is confirmed by the interest of foreign investors.
I met with representatives of a company from the UAE today — they want to manage our hotel chains. Also recently, a Thai company took over a large Anapa hotel with several hundred rooms. And these are not isolated cases: foreign businesses come and generally remain satisfied.
— How important is inbound tourism to us now? How valuable is it and what problems exist here?
— Inbound tourism is important to us from an economic point of view. And this year we need to increase the flow to 7 million, which is a plus of 20%. It is also an influx of currency. Although our trade balance is strong now, tourism is a stable industry in general.
A traveler arrives and always goes to a hotel, to restaurants. Then we see how this money "seeps" into the economy: taxes, investments, salaries.
In addition, competition is important. If we want to develop domestic tourism and raise the level of service, it is important for us to attract foreign tourists, because this increases competition and raises the bar.
From a humanitarian point of view, there is an information war going on against us. And when people arrive, they experience cognitive dissonance: perception breaks down, because it's beautiful, safe, tasty, interesting, and friendly here.
— What about the barriers to entry tourism, including visa and logistics?
— Yes, they are. The main problem is primarily logistics: international flights and so on.
The situation with visas is generally well-organized. The electronic document is valid for 64 countries, the period of stay has been extended to 30 days. There is a visa—free regime with China. There is also a group visa-free mechanism, which we are developing with India, for example.
The situation with flights is more complicated and varies by country, but work is ongoing. This year, for example, Saudi Arabia opened, and direct flights to Tanzania are now being launched. This is a gradual process — we are expanding our geography step by step.
In general, there is a shortage of aircraft in the world right now, so they are being redistributed between destinations. At the same time, the Russian direction remains in demand, so we are gradually "winning it back".
— And which markets are the most interesting for us now from the point of view of tourism?
— We look at several factors: population size, income level and how many people travel abroad in general. In China and India, for example, there is a large and growing stratum of wealthy people. And, of course, our Arab friends and partners.
Plus, we complement each other well in terms of climate. When they have intense heat, we have a comfortable summer in the middle zone or in the south.
"The responsibility system of tour operators needs to be improved"
— Now there are problems in the relationship between tour operators and consumers, as well as passengers with airlines. Is it necessary to tighten the legislation related to the refund of money and pre-deposited funds?
— Everything about tour operators is that the obligations stipulated in the law are generally fulfilled. We don't fix any systemic problems here. Although, of course, the system of responsibility of tour operators needs to be adjusted, because for quite a long time we have been pinpointing certain things — payments, deadlines, and so on.
But at the same time, it is important to understand that working capital is expensive, and it is pointless to simply require additional "freezing" of money in accounts, because this will eventually go to cost.
And one more thing: the main difficulties arise not with organized tours, but with situations when individual tourists buy trips on their own and find themselves in difficult situations. Here, people often act at their own risk, and this is a separate layer of issues that also requires careful configuration.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»