Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Forest fires, hurricanes, floods — residents of Russian regions are increasingly complaining that they learn about these dangers after the fact — text messages with warnings arrive late or do not reach at all. At the same time, the collection of signatures for the introduction of a more effective emergency warning system at the federal level, Cell Broadcast, was completed on the website of the Russian Public Initiative project. This technology has been successfully used in Japan, South Korea, the USA, and has been introduced in Kazakhstan and European countries. Why it is not being launched in Russia against the background of increasing threats and an alert system that does not always work effectively is in the Izvestia article.

Delays in informing

Natalia Gusenko, a resident of Kirov, spends almost all her free time on major repairs to her apartment. In May, the roof of their two-story building was torn off during a hurricane, and several residential buildings were thoroughly flooded.

"I didn't receive any text messages, we didn't know about the impending hurricane," the woman told Izvestia. — Just a friend saw a video of him raging in her house chat and sent it to me.

смс
Photo: IZVESTIA/Pavel Bednyakov

Sergei Vasiliev from Chita did not know anything about the impending danger either, when he spent time at his dacha in the Locomotive farming Co-op last summer. Fires in the vicinity began on June 20, and the partnership was reached only three days later, but there were no reports during that time, Sergei assures.

— When the fire was already at the farm, that's when they found out. People told us to run, to save our homes. But everything burned down. The house was one-story, two-room, winter. Two greenhouses, a barn, a sauna. Many of them had their dogs and chickens burned down. I don't talk about things at all," he told Izvestia.

The situation was similar in a number of regions that have been attacked by UAVs in recent weeks. Rustam Khasanov, a resident of Chelyabinsk, says: sirens are never heard, but as for SMS…

"Look at this," he shows the Izvestia correspondent his smartphone. — The message "Unmanned danger", announced at 8 a.m. And the actual SMS receipt is 10:17.

громкоговоритель
Photo: IZVESTIA/Konstantin Kokoshkin

New threats require new solutions. But the emergency warning system in Russia relies heavily on the mechanics of the last century — sirens, loudspeakers, emergency messages on TV. In the twentieth century, SMS notifications were added to them. But it is often useless due to overloaded networks.

— SMS messaging technology works on the principle of targeted delivery, therefore, in order to notify a million people, a telecom operator must generate a million separate messages and queue them. In such conditions, the network is instantly overloaded, and people can receive an emergency SMS in 30-40 minutes when the danger is over," explains Timofey Voronin, project manager at Intelligent Analytics, TechNet NTI market expert.

A long chain of decision-making does not add to the speed of information, which also varies depending on the threat level. The primary level is local. Each municipality has a Single Duty Dispatch Service (EDDS). The duty shifts of factories, hydroelectric power plants, and other enterprises that may threaten the population interact with it.

The EDDS receives information about a threat, such as a leak of dangerous substances or the possibility of flooding due to a dam break, and reports to the head of the municipality or the chairman of the local emergency commission. They make the decision to inform.

мчс
Photo: IZVESTIA/Evgeny Pavlov

The next level is regional.

— For example, the structures of the Ministry of Defense learn about the danger of a UAV raid, they inform the operational headquarters of the region. He forms an information message, sends it to mobile operators, who turn it into SMS," explains Leonid Konik, head of the ComNews group of companies.

But the reaction cycle itself — detection, evaluation, confirmation, approval — is delayed. After all, different structures are responsible for each stage. And then there's the human factor. The head of a municipality or region can make a decision in a minute, or he can wait.

And, for example, on the night of May 17, in Khimki near Moscow, during a drone attack, not a single algorithm worked at all. After that, Izvestia sent a request to the Ministry of Emergency Situations of Russia in the Moscow region with a question about their responsibility in the field of warning citizens about possible threats.

бпла
Photo: TASS/Vyacheslav Prokofiev

"The decision to activate regional, municipal and local notification systems is made respectively by senior officials of the subjects of the Russian Federation, <...> heads of local governments," the department replied. As for the powers of the regional Ministry of Emergency Situations, it only "carries out constant monitoring of the technical condition of the elements of the regional warning system within the limits of the powers granted," the response says.

What is Cell Broadcast technology?

Cell Broadcast technology has been an effective alternative to SMS mailing lists for a long time. Unlike SMS, a million messages are not queued up to be sent here.

— Cell Broadcast works differently — the message is sent not to a specific subscriber to his number, but directly to the base station. And the station just broadcasts it on the service frequency. All phones located in the coverage area of this tower receive notifications instantly and simultaneously," explains Timofey Voronin.

This is important when the network is already overloaded in an emergency situation, says Vitaliy Osipenko, project manager of the Warning System.

смартфон
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

— Cell Broadcast has two more undoubted advantages, — the expert notes. — The first one is forced attention. When a message arrives, it instantly blocks all applications on the screen, accompanied by a loud sound, vibration, and you cannot disable this feature in the settings. The second is jewelry geotargeting. The system allows you to cover not the entire region with a message, but a specific area, village, and even a block.

According to Vladimir Freidman, vice president of Protey Group, which develops solutions based on Cell Broadcast, such systems are actively used in the USA, South Korea, and Japan.

On May 26, it was launched in Cyprus. Among the CIS countries, it is being implemented in Kazakhstan, and in 2026-2027 it is expected to happen in Estonia, Sweden, and a number of other European countries.

— We are involved in similar projects in some friendly countries in Africa. For example, we are currently working in Burkina Faso with local operators and the local government to implement just such a system," said Vladimir Freidman.

In Russia, the first versions of Cell Broadcast began to be tested by the Ministry of Emergency Situations and telecom operators back in 2010. And they became more active after the devastating 2012 flood in Krymsk, when the usual warning systems did not work there.

At that time, test implementations took place in Tatarstan, Novosibirsk Region, Khakassia, Tuva, and Moscow.

ураган
Photo: TASS/AP/Pavel Golovkin

In the capital, 15 million rubles were spent on the implementation of this system. However, it did not work in 2017, during a powerful hurricane that killed 16 people.

— The problem in the capital was that in the reports it was presented as "the implementation of the Cell Broadcast system", although in fact for 15 million they did not buy a full-cycle solution, but only an interface layer. This is a software gateway or API-docking module that connects the equipment of telecom operators and the control center, where they press a button to start informing. The failure during the 2017 hurricane was a direct result of this architectural flaw," explained Igor Bederov, Chairman of the Coordinating Council of the non—governmental security sector of the Russian Federation, founder of the Internet Search company.

In addition, the time simply did not come for this technology in the 2010s, experts explain.

"According to the results of testing in the regions, it was recognized as promising, it provided fast coverage of large areas without network overload, but had limitations on device support and required infrastructure modernization," said Ivan Zamyatin, head of the Infinit Security Center.

The point is that at that time the market was dominated by push-button phones and a large number of different operating systems. To receive messages via Cell Broadcast, the subscriber needs to manually change the settings. People did not want to do this, and the audience coverage was very low, but the Ministry of Emergency Situations was not satisfied with this, Timofey Voronin explained.

мчс
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

In addition, for the system to work, operators needed to purchase and maintain expensive equipment, and since the government and business did not agree on a financing model, it was easier and cheaper for operators to use ready-made SMS infrastructure.

But today, the technological landscape has changed. Almost all smartphones run on modern versions of iOS or Android. In these systems, emergency notification support is enabled by default.

In the current conditions, this system can become a reliable security tool, experts say.

— There is already progress. At the Svyaz-2026 exhibition, for example, they again proposed using Cell Broadcast in LTE as a cheap and stable notification channel," Lyudmila Bogatyreva, head of the Polylog agency's IT department, ROCIT expert, told Izvestia. — Protey has developed a ready-to-implement Cell Broadcast center that supports 4G/LTE networks and has interfaces for integration with Emergency Situations Ministry systems.

смс
Photo: Global Look Press/Andrey Titov

However, the specific timing and parameters of the technology implementation have not been determined, and once again we are talking about pilot testing areas.

What is needed to implement Cell Broadcast

To implement Cell Broadcast at the federal level, it is necessary to solve several tasks, experts say. First of all, to modernize the network equipment for 4G /5G, to develop a unified regulation for the interaction of operators, the Ministry of Emergency Situations and the regions.

— Sending the message itself is not the difficult part. It is much more difficult to assemble a working system around it. You need to understand who makes the decision to ship, determines the territory, is responsible for the launch, and what happens if part of the infrastructure is unavailable. Without this, Cell Broadcast remains just a technical capability for the operator, and not a full—fledged security tool," explained Alexey Postrigailo, senior partner at Ensain IT integrator.

Initiatives from below are also trying to push the authorities to address these issues. So, in May 2026, signatures were collected on the website of the Russian Public Initiative project for a proposal to introduce Cell Broadcast at the federal level. In order for it to be discussed at the government level, it was necessary to get 100,000 votes, but this could not be done.

громкоговоритель
Photo: Global Look Press/Petrov Sergey

In the meantime, each region is decentralizing the problem of building an alert system. Izvestia analyzed the contracts on the Public Procurement website in this area for 2025 and five months of 2026. It is difficult to estimate the total volume due to the lack of consistency in reports and transparency. But, for example, Dagestan spent almost 95 million rubles in 2005 on the supply and installation of equipment for the points of the regional public notification system. In the spring of 2026, five people died as a result of floods in the republic.

More than 700 million has been spent in the Samara region over the past year. But when an intense downpour hit the capital of the region on the evening of June 11, residents again complained about the lack or delay in informing. 140 million were allocated under two major government contracts in Primorsky Krai, over 100 million in Mordovia, 99.6 million in Chita, 59.4 million in the Sverdlovsk Region, and so on. But the result — nationwide — is not visible or audible. In the truest sense of the word.

The following persons participated in the preparation of the material:: Kirill Olkov, Irina Podzolkova

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast