Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

The machinations of housing: how they wanted to confiscate an apartment from a Muscovite for renting it out

The Moscow City Court returned the property to the owner, but the practice of seizing homes for registering illegal immigrants is gaining momentum.
0
Photo: IZVESTIA/Andrey Erstrem
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

On May 26, the Moscow City Court overturned a high-profile verdict when a Muscovite's apartment was confiscated for the fact that illegal migrants lived in it. Boris Bubnov rented out his real estate, but through a chain of sub-tenants, illegal immigrants eventually settled there. The intermediary who organized this "hostel" was fined 50,000 rubles for facilitating illegal migration, and Bubnov's apartment was confiscated, considering it an instrument of crime, although he did not go through a criminal case. The Moscow City Court found this interpretation of the law to be a mistake and sent the case for a new hearing. Courts are increasingly using confiscation of housing in cases of illegal migration. How reasonable this is and how to avoid this risk by renting out an apartment is described in the Izvestia article.

Details of the criminal case

A modest apartment of 41 sq. m. Boris Bubnov, a Muscovite, owned the house with his aunt. They rented it to a Russian citizen and did not think that it would almost deprive them of their property. But the woman, unbeknownst to the owners, sublet it to a native of Uzbekistan. He, in turn, settled two of his illegal compatriots there.

"My client came once a month and took meter readings," Vitaly Kasparov, Boris Bubnov's lawyer, told Izvestia. — Everything seemed to be fine. Then one of the neighbors complained about the migrants living in the apartment, and the police arrived.

The owner found out about everything from the interrogator, who summoned him for questioning. It turned out that a criminal case had been opened against the subtenant, whose existence the owner did not suspect, under the article on the organization of illegal migration. In February 2026, the Shcherbinsky District Court issued a verdict: a fine of 50,000 rubles was levied against an Uzbek citizen, and Boris's apartment was confiscated for state revenue, citing its use in criminal activities against the security of the Russian Federation. This decision came as a complete surprise to the owner.

"There were no thoughts about confiscation at all," Boris Bubnov confessed to Izvestia. — And when I heard the verdict at the trial, I was just shocked. I didn't understand how this could happen. On what grounds? Why? What for? The accused was given a fine of 50 thousand, and I was given confiscation.

He decided not to tell his aunt, the co-owner of the apartment, so as not to worry.

"If the decision of the first instance had stood, it could have had a negative impact on the apartment rental market, as the actions of any unscrupulous tenant can lead homeowners to lose their property rights," believes Vitaly Kasparov. — One of the principles of justice is being violated — that a person should be responsible only for his own actions, not for others.

On May 26, the Moscow City Court overturned the decision of the Shcherbinsky District Court, finding in it an incorrect interpretation of criminal legislation regarding the confiscation of property. The case has been sent for a new review.

When confiscation is legal

Courts began to seize housing in cases of fictitious registration of migrants relatively recently. At the end of 2024, amendments were made to Article 104.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, which allow for the possibility of depriving property used as an instrument of crime in crimes related to the threat to the security of the country, among other things, the organization of illegal migration.

For example, in December 2025, a court in Nizhny Tagil issued a decision on a fine of 110 thousand rubles and confiscation of a house belonging to a local resident. The man registered two illegal immigrants, citizens of Tajikistan, in it. The investigation concluded that the owner used the property solely as a tool to generate income, deliberately participating in the scheme of illegal legalization of migrants.

In March 2025, the Kirovsky District Court of Yekaterinburg imposed a fine of 300,000 and confiscated a room from a man who had registered nine foreigners on a fictitious basis, the regional prosecutor's office said.

And in May 2026, in Nizhnevartovsk, a native of Tajikistan fictitiously registered 13 foreigners in one apartment and eight in another. He was sentenced to a fine of 200 thousand and confiscation of one of the apartments as a means of crime, the press service of the courts of general jurisdiction of Ugra reported. There have been other similar solutions.

Lawyers interviewed by Izvestia noted that in all these cases, the seized real estate was not the only housing, and the owners of the property were accused in criminal cases of organizing illegal migration. This is their difference from the case of Boris Bubnov, whom the investigation did not accuse of anything.

Despite the fact that the practice of confiscation of apartments by the courts is becoming quite common, lawyers disagree on the validity of such decisions. The main question is whether the apartment can be recognized as an instrument of crime.

For example, Vladislav Kocherin, a lawyer and managing partner of the Kocherin and Partners law firm, does not believe that apartments can be seized from owners, even if they turn out to be guilty of organizing illegal migration.

— The current criminal legislation provides for such an opportunity as the confiscation of tools, equipment or other means of committing a crime belonging to the accused. But at the same time, it is obvious that the apartment in such cases turns out not to be a tool, but still a place where the crime was committed.

In these situations, the concept of an instrument of committing a crime is interpreted incorrectly, the lawyer believes. Such judicial acts can be annulled by filing complaints, and the convicted person will be able to restore his rights to real estate.

There have been such precedents. For example, in February 2026, an apartment was confiscated from a resident of Alapaevsk, who fictitiously took in 10 foreigners. The defendant pleaded not guilty and won the appeal in March.

At the same time, lawyer Vadim Turov, in an interview with Izvestia, expressed the opinion that the court has the right to recognize the apartment as an instrument of crime, because illegal migration is organized with its help.

— According to the same principle, vehicles are seized from those who re—got behind the wheel drunk, - he noted.

Confiscation by the courts is used to further deprive a person of the opportunity to engage in this kind of criminal activity, lawyer Andrei Nokhrin believes.

— You can't scare anyone with fines anymore, especially when they fine those who have nothing to take. Therefore, they are not very afraid, and we have more and more "rubber apartments", — said lawyer Denis Fomelskoy.

Thus, judicial practice on confiscation of apartments for violations of migration legislation is just being formed and remains controversial. On the one hand, the law allows for the seizure of property as an instrument of crime, on the other hand, courts do not always distinguish between who exactly owns housing: the perpetrator or a person unrelated to the case.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast