Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The United States and Israel can use precision bombs to provoke landslides to destroy Tehran. Such scenarios have been discussed more than once in American military circles, David Haines, a former officer of the United States Army and an expert on chemical warfare, said in an interview with Izvestia. In his opinion, Israel could decide to create a natural disaster in order not to use nuclear weapons. What the coalition can do in the event of a failure of negotiations with Tehran is in an exclusive interview with a former American officer to Izvestia.

"This war is a tragedy capable of starting World War III"

— You were a military planner and an "unofficial envoy" to Iran 20 years ago. What exactly have you been doing?

— I am a biomedical scientist. I started working with Iranians after the Gulf War, when I stayed in Kuwait. I served as an army officer in a unit of the 82nd Airborne Division.

Основная группа исследователей из Университета Коннектикута (UCONN, Сторрс, Коннектикут, США) получает награду ректора UCONN за общественную деятельность

A core group of researchers from the University of Connecticut (UCONN, Storrs, Connecticut, USA) receives the UCONN Rector's Award for Community Service

Photo: The author's archive
Izvestia reference

The Gulf War was an armed conflict between the Multinational Forces (MNF) led by the United States and Iraq for the liberation and restoration of Kuwait's independence, which took place between August 2, 1990 and February 28, 1991.

My main responsibility was to protect against chemical, nuclear and biological weapons. I started researching chronic diseases among people exposed to toxic compounds released as a result of the war. On this basis, researchers from Iran contacted me and invited me, with the support of the Iranian government, to the Janbazan organization, the Iranian equivalent of the US Department of Veterans Affairs.

Президент США Дональд Трамп

US President Donald Trump

Photo: REUTERS/Nathan Howard

As a result, the work of my research group has provided a huge amount of valuable information and reduced the burden on the Iranian healthcare system. Our team has done everything possible to minimize the hostility that has existed between the United States and Iran since 1979. We are not naive, but our programs served as a kind of bridge between Americans and Iranians, which did not exist on any other site.

Unfortunately, we have not been able to reduce the level of this hostility enough to avoid the nightmare we are in right now. I personally don't understand why we attacked the Iranians. This war is a tragedy capable of starting World War III and destroying the global economy. I voted for Donald Trump three times, but I didn't vote for this. Like many American conservatives, I consider myself an adherent of the MAGA movement, and we did not vote for such a war. I am absolutely horrified at the thought that some of the strategies that were discussed, including with me, will be used to defeat the Iranians.

— Do you mean that the United States or Israel can use nuclear weapons, chemical or biological?

— Of course, there are widespread fears that Israel is using its nuclear arsenal to achieve a rapid military "checkmate." Nevertheless, although the Israelis are ruthless, they are not suicidal and realize that the retaliatory use of WMD against their nation — no matter how creepy it may sound — can turn into a new holocaust.

I categorically declare that no one is going to use either nuclear or chemical weapons. If the Israelis had used it, Iran might have swallowed it, if they really don't have nuclear weapons, but other countries won't tolerate it. The Israelis know this, they are not crazy.

пво
Photo: Global Look Press/Saeed Qaq

Iran's successful overcoming of the Iron Dome and David's Sling missile defense systems may force Israel to use other methods of struggle. They use tactics in which thousands of relatively inexpensive long-range strike weapons, including UAVs and missiles, converge simultaneously on their intended target. As a result, the cost—to-spent ammunition ratio benefits Iran as expensive interceptors such as Arrow and Patriot are depleted, especially when firing at false targets, which Iranian engineers have been very successful at creating.

"The goal is to erase part of the city"

— Then what can the United States and Israel resort to in this war?

— Trump promised Iranians "death, fire and fury," and in June 2025 advised the residents of Tehran to evacuate the city. From my point of view, this may be military rhetoric. Maybe he's bluffing, but if not, how can the city be destroyed? Turning Tehran into a kind of Dresden, Hiroshima and Nagasaki would look terrible. Another creepy scenario, which I am personally familiar with, is more feasible.

I want to express my deep gratitude for the opportunity to bring to the public field a speculative but evidence-based overview of a particularly terrifying strategy that could be used to inflict a swift and decisive defeat on Iran in the ongoing conflict.

тегеран
Photo: REUTERS/Majid Asgaripour

I have heard suggestions from many geologists, mining engineers, and related specialists that groundwater depletion is leading to subsidence of the soil under northern Tehran, where critical infrastructure for managing the entire country, including communications, water, and electricity, is concentrated.

This process can be accelerated by using several precisely placed JDAM bombs (concrete or bunker buster bombs) that would cause landslides. To do this, it is necessary to carry out calculations similar to those used to preemptively launch avalanches using explosives as a safety measure. I personally participated in such operations as an employee of the US National Park Service. This is a well-established technology.

бомба
Photo: Global Look Press/Staff Sgt. Frederick Brown

The vulnerability of Tehran and many other cities to landslides lies in the fact that they were built at the foot of mountains on unstable sedimentary deposits. This soil, colluvium— is a loose mixture of soil and rocks that can be set in motion by earthquakes or heavy rains. By placing the punches correctly, you can cause the formation to collapse.

"The idiots in the Pentagon predict that by killing the supreme leader, they will win"

— And what will be the consequences?

— The goal is to erase the part of the city that is under the deposits of colluvium. It is easy to see it at night along the illuminated serpentine road. If it starts to move, it will sweep away a path several hundred meters wide and several kilometers long. The "attractiveness" of the geological scenario lies in the fact that it allows achieving final victory by covering the center of Tehran with hundreds of meters of stones and gravel. This will seal the entrances to the underground facilities and destroy the government structure that is concentrated in the area. Civilian casualties in this case can be huge — from thousands to tens of thousands of innocent civilians.

This would have paralyzed the country as "effectively" as a nuclear strike, but the "optics" would have been somewhat better. However, if this were done, it would be a war crime on an unprecedented scale on the level of the Holocaust. But that would not require the first use of nuclear weapons.

ядерное оружие
Photo: Global Look Press/U.S. Air Force

I do not pretend to have insider information, but I have attended numerous military planning sessions and command and staff exercises where this scenario was discussed as a realistic alternative to the use of nuclear weapons or prolonged massive bombing. There are planners, both among us and probably among Israelis, who are considering this scenario. My interaction with high-ranking US officers, as well as representatives of the armed Forces of Arab, European countries, and even Russia, was broad enough that I seriously feared that desperate people in Israeli and possibly American military circles might take decisive action.

The idiots in the Pentagon predict that by killing the supreme leader, they will win. Ali Khamenei was not a friend of Americans, but he was moderate in his views. In particular, he advocated a fatwa against nuclear weapons. His goal was not military conquest. But we killed him. This is absolutely crazy. Whoever gave the order to kill him, be it an Israeli or an American, belongs in The Hague.

— Do you keep in touch with your Iranian colleagues now? What do they think about the situation in the Middle East?

— Now I am in contact with only a couple of former colleagues. They were important government officials during my visits to Iran. I discussed some of my concerns with them. I just lost contact with one of them, and I'm a little worried about him, as well as for many of my Iranian friends. God forbid, the United States or Israel will take military action that will kill many Iranians.

тегеран
Photo: REUTERS/Majid Asgaripour

I am deeply divided inside because of this conflict. I am a Jew by birth. My grandfather, Dr. Horace M. Kallen, was one of the founders of the modern State of Israel. I went to high school there. I have family and friends in Israel, but I also have best friends in Iran and Arab countries.

My main research co—author, Dr. Fadia Mahmoud from Kuwait University, is a devout Muslim. Like me, she's pro-Palestinian. I think it's monstrous what Israel is doing now, but I'm not an anti-Semite. I am both an ardent supporter of the Palestinians and a supporter of Israel, and I am horrified by this conflict.

"I was in the war myself. I still have nightmares."

— Obviously, the Trump administration may also be horrified by what is happening. Who is most opposed to the US actions in the Middle East?

— I will say this without a shadow of a doubt — Tulsi Gabbard. Technically, she agrees with all this, but she is a fantastic woman. Gabbard is a lieutenant colonel in the Army Reserve, and she has that insight and willingness to be a black sheep, to go against the flow. I don't think any other American politician is capable of this. She is very wise and has a deep analytical mindset. She replaced my distant relative, Avril Haines, who held this position under Joe Biden, as director of National Intelligence.

I believe that she will run for president and win, because she enjoys broad support among both Democrats and Republicans. She can even beat Vance—I admire him too. I believe that she has the potential to change the current course that we are following, and perhaps end this war. And I really hope that Donald Trump will listen to her and the people around her.

 Глава Национальной разведки США Талси Габбард

U.S. National Intelligence Chief Tulsi Gabbard

Photo: TASS/Sipa USA/CNP

However, she is systematically demonized by Neocons — absolutely abnormal people like Lindsey Graham (listed as a terrorist and extremist by Rosfinmonitoring. — Ed.) and that idiot Ken O'Keefe (activist, former US Marine and veteran of the Gulf War. — Ed.). Because of this, it is difficult for her to gain the necessary political weight.

The way our government's mindset has changed, these reckless foreign adventures... It scares me that deeply sick people have been influenced. They have gained great influence within the US government, and unfortunately, Tulsi Gabbard is perceived in America as a "lone cowboy", she is relegated to the background.

— Could a war with Iran cause serious disagreements within the Trump team?

— Yes, it has already happened. And it alienated a significant number of former Trump supporters, including me. I voted for Donald Trump three times. I voted for him, like many U.S. veterans, because he positioned himself as an opponent of the war. I believed in what he wanted to give people, but I did not vote for an attack on Iran. It's crazy, and many Americans think the same way.

I would like to emphasize that during his first term, Donald Trump was the best president we have ever had. I still think so. He has a vision for the future, which I fully support. But one part of this vision was the abandonment of wars for the sake of "regime change."

тегеран
Photo: REUTERS/Thaier Al-Sudani

I was in the war myself. My friends were dying before my eyes. I could smell it, the smell of what remains on the battlefield after a battle. I still have nightmares.

Now everything is really in the hands of Donald Trump — it is up to him to make the decision. I hope he will act wisely. God willing, it will be so.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast