Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

In Russia, they propose to introduce licensing of nursing homes, as well as to tighten control over the provision of such services. Senators sent a corresponding letter to the government after a number of tragic incidents that led to the deaths of elderly people. The initiative is supported by the relevant State Duma Committee on Labor and Social Policy. They believe that in addition to licensing, it is necessary to create a register of bona fide providers of such services with the possibility of exclusion from it in case of violations. Whether this will allow illegal commercial institutions to be brought out of the shadows is in the Izvestia article.

Why do they want to license the activities of nursing homes

An alarming situation has begun to develop in the country with the work of commercial institutions that provide accommodation services for the elderly and disabled for money, Senator Oleg Golov said in a letter to the head of the Cabinet of Ministers Mikhail Mishustin.

Столовая в доме престарелых
Photo: IZVESTIA

"A large—scale "gray zone" has formed and is rapidly expanding in Russia - a network of illegal private boarding schools and nursing homes. These facilities operate outside the legal framework, are not included in the official registers of social service providers, successfully avoid preventive visits and remain physically inaccessible to the risk-based approach mechanism," the document says, which was reviewed by Izvestia.

Of particular concern is a series of high-profile tragedies in such residential facilities in 2025-2026, which led to severe and even fatal consequences for elderly citizens, the author of the initiative notes.

Izvestia reference

In recent years, there have been a number of incidents involving illegal nursing homes in Russia. Among the high—profile cases of fires at such facilities are the deaths of 22 people in Kemerovo, seven in the Tyumen region and 11 in Bashkiria. In February of this year, an outbreak of acute respiratory tract infection occurred in an illegal private boarding house in New Moscow, which claimed the lives of three pensioners, 26 people in total were injured.

Пенсионер в доме престарелых
Photo: Global Look Press/dpa

"These incidents have demonstrated that mass deaths in shady institutions are caused not only by fires, but also by the systematic, cynical disregard by business owners of basic sanitary, epidemiological, and medical standards in order to minimize costs. These disasters are a direct consequence of the imperfection of control mechanisms in this area," the document says.

In this regard, the Government is proposed to take a set of measures to regulate the operation of such facilities. In particular, we are talking about the phased introduction of mandatory state licensing of such institutions by analogy with the practice of Belarus and Kazakhstan, where a similar mechanism is already in effect.

To increase the speed of identification of such facilities, it is proposed to transfer supervision powers to municipal authorities, as well as create a proactive digital monitoring system based on interdepartmental data exchange.

Медсестра открывает занавеску
Photo: Global Look Press/Ingram Images

Such a system will allow illegal boarding houses to be established based on a combination of indirect signs, such as abnormally high consumption of communal resources, registration of a large number of elderly people without family ties at the same address, or frequent calls from ambulance crews to private homes, the document explains.

Another important measure should be to conduct unscheduled inspections of such facilities without the approval of the prosecutor's office.

— Tragedies in private nursing homes are not regional emergencies, they are a systemic signal affecting the whole country. With the growing number of elderly people, the demand for inpatient care is steadily increasing, and legal institutions, for objective reasons, do not always have time to close it," Oleg Golov explained.

Коридор в доме престарелых
Photo: IZVESTIA


According to him, unscrupulous entrepreneurs who create illegal boarding houses, who work in the shadows, do not pay taxes, are not listed in any registers and are virtually invisible to the control authorities, are rushing into the vacuum.

The senator noted that tragedies related to the activities of such institutions are happening all over the country today — from the Moscow region to Siberia. Therefore, targeted measures to solve the problem are not enough: it is necessary to build a system that, on the one hand, will allow for strict suppression of abuses in the social sphere, and on the other hand, will not create excessive barriers for bona fide service providers.

The government's press service reported that the senator's appeal had been received.

Why haven't measures been taken yet

The initiative is supported by the relevant State Duma Committee on Labor, Social Policy and Veterans' Affairs.

— Of course, there is a long overdue need to restore order in this area. The issue of licensing nursing homes has already been raised before. So, back in 2023, the Ministry of Labor developed a corresponding bill, which has not yet been adopted, so the issue has not yet been resolved," Yaroslav Nilov, the head of the committee, told Izvestia.

Столовая в доме престарелых
Photo: IZVESTIA

According to him, in addition to licensing, it is necessary to create a register of bona fide providers of such services for senior citizens, from which businesses were excluded in case of any violations.

Izvestia sent a request to the Ministry of Labor with a request to comment on the reasons why the bill was not submitted to the State Duma. The ministry's press service reported that work on it is ongoing.

— Now private boarding houses for the elderly are operating in the "gray zone". No one can count them, there are no clear work regulations, and the state cannot check what is happening inside. If neither firefighters nor doctors can enter an ordinary cottage with 30-50 bedridden people, it is dangerous. Due to the lack of control mechanisms, we only learn about such places after terrible news — fires, the discovery of exhaustion of guests, outbreaks of fatal infections," Elizaveta Oleskina, director of the Starost v Radost Foundation, a member of the Civic Chamber, told Izvestia.

Парикмахерская в доме престарелых
Photo: IZVESTIA

According to her, now the client is invited to independently assess the safety and quality of the services for which he will pay.

— Licensing, if it is introduced quickly and in a strict form without extensive expert discussion with market participants, regulatory authorities and the public, can lead to the opposite effect — the departure of a part of the market "into the shadows," the expert believes.

There is already a registry of social service providers in Russia, however, if all institutions are required to undergo inclusion procedures, it will simply be impossible for a significant part of boarding schools.

Женщина трогает руку пенсионерки
Photo: Global Look Press/Paul Zinken/dpa

— In addition, not all buildings allow, for example, to equip additional exits accessible to people with limited mobility. But the number of these exits should be sufficient, because people can pay with their lives for their absence. If there are fewer private boarding houses, the remaining ones will most likely raise prices. This will hit those who already turn to such services not out of a good life," Elizaveta Oleskina believes.

In addition, according to the expert, in the low-price segment today, it is often not full-fledged care that is offered, but rather a business built on the urgent needs of people, rather than a high-quality social service.

"The tragedies that are taking place — regular outbreaks of fatal diseases and a series of fires — clearly demonstrate that the control model designed for a fair market stops working when confronted with a cynical violator," Oleg Pavlov, head of the Public Consumer Initiative, told Izvestia.

Кровати в палате
Photo: Global Look Press/Bulkin Sergey/news.ru

This means the need for a point-by-point and differentiated review of approaches to supervision in individual industries. In areas where the lives and health of citizens are at stake, control should be stricter and more prompt, the social activist believes.

— The government's policy of reducing the administrative burden on business is absolutely justified and necessary for the development of entrepreneurship. However, practice shows that some market players perceive such concessions not as a sign of trust, but as an invitation to impunity," the expert noted.

This situation is especially unacceptable in the field of social services for the elderly and the disabled, he added. Here, savings on security, personnel and sanitary conditions may lead not to financial losses, but to human casualties among those who, due to their age and state of health, are unable to protect themselves on their own.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast