Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

Scum in the law: Tallinn and Kiev are working on the confiscation of Russian assets

How will an attempt to steal money from Russian citizens and transfer €38 million to Ukraine turn out for Estonia?
0
Photo: Global Look Press/Mihkel Maripuu
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Estonia is calculating the mechanisms for the withdrawal of frozen private Russian assets. Tallinn is considering their complete confiscation in favor of Ukraine if Moscow refuses compensation payments to Kiev, the republic's Foreign Minister Margus Tsakhkna told Izvestia. According to him, the necessary legal framework has already been created, and Estonia is coordinating further steps with Ukraine. In the Russian Federation, this is called theft and warns of the inevitability of a response. It may concern the regime of economic activity of Estonia in the border areas, including fishing and shipping, as well as the review of access of Estonian vessels to Russian territorial waters, which are of critical importance for the logistics of individual ports.

How much are Russian assets frozen in Estonia?

Estonia is looking for "legitimate" ways to steal frozen Russian assets. The authorities of the republic are trying to use national legislation and international mechanisms to direct the blocked property of Russian citizens in favor of Ukraine.

— Private Russian assets have been frozen in Estonia. We have the relevant law, and now we are preparing the next steps together with Ukraine. This is a certain framework, a system that allows us to act, but it takes time to implement. If the conflict is resolved, the damage will be recorded in international instances in The Hague, Ukraine will sue Russia, and Moscow will refuse to pay compensation, then through this mechanism we will be able to use the frozen assets," Estonian Foreign Minister Margus Tsahkna told Izvestia at the Munich Security Conference.

Answering a clarifying question about the possibility of complete confiscation of property, he did not rule out such an option.:

"We can,— he said.

Thus, Tallinn plans to present this step as a "reparative" mechanism: Russia will allegedly retain the right to refund funds only after full payment of compensation. However, in practice, this means actual confiscation. Estonia has been one of the most active lobbyists for such a decision in the EU for several years now — back in 2023, the country was the first to develop national legislation on this topic.

In 2024, Tallinn approved a law allowing the seizure of frozen assets of Russian individuals and legal entities. According to the Estonian side, the total amount of blocked property is 37-39 million euros. As Margus Tsakhkna clarified earlier, a significant part of these assets is related to the transit of Russian fertilizers illegally held in Estonia after the start of its production. According to the plan of the legislators, the proceeds are supposed to be sent to Ukraine as compensation for the damage caused, while the decision on the practical use of the property remains with the Foreign Ministry.

Back in 2023, Margus Tsakhna emphasized the importance of Estonia being the first in the EU to legalize the possibility of confiscation of Russian assets. In turn, the head of the European Diplomacy, Kaya Kallas, previously expressed the hope that the Estonian experience could become a reference point for other states of the union.

Andrei Korobeinik, Deputy Chairman of the Finance Commission of the Estonian Parliament, previously explained to Izvestia that the application of the new mechanism in practice faces serious limitations. According to him, property subject to EU sanctions can be frozen, but the adopted law itself does not create an automatic procedure for its confiscation.

Russia may tighten the regime in the border waters

In general, the topic of using frozen Russian sovereign and private assets to support Ukraine has been discussed in the West since the beginning of a special military operation. The main part of them — over 200 billion euros — is blocked on the territory of the European Union. At the same time, Brussels emphasizes that direct asset withdrawal is difficult due to the lack of a unified legal framework. In particular, almost $224.5 billion worth of Russian assets are blocked in the accounts of the Belgian depository Euroclear. We are talking about both sovereign and private funds — 1,980 individuals and 683 organizations are under EU sanctions.

Russian President Vladimir Putin has already noted that such a practice in Europe could be considered an act of theft. According to Russian Justice Minister Konstantin Chuichenko, the country's leadership has been presented with options for responding to the possible seizure of Russian assets by Western states, and presidential spokesman Dmitry Peskov stressed that Moscow would not leave such actions unanswered.

Izvestia reference

In October, the European Commission took the initiative to expropriate approximately €210 billion of Russia's sovereign assets blocked in the EU since February 2022 (€185 billion of which are in accounts with the Euroclear depository in Belgium) under the guise of a "reparative" loan to finance Ukraine's military and budgetary needs in 2026-2027. In December, the European Commission proposed an alternative scheme, which involves the allocation of a loan guaranteed by the EU budget in the amount of € 90 billion. The head of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, said that the EC proceeds from the need to cover two thirds of the €135 billion financial needs of Ukraine for 2026-2027. The remaining third, according to her, should be provided by Kiev's foreign partners.

Speaking about Estonia's retaliatory measures on the part of Russia, Nikolai Mezhevich, President of the Association for Baltic Studies, drew attention to the fundamental limitation for symmetrical measures. There are practically no significant Estonian assets on the territory of the Russian Federation, and the few facilities that can be identified in the north-west of the country are not capable of becoming a full-fledged instrument of pressure, the expert believes.

— In this situation, the logic of Moscow's reaction must inevitably be asymmetric. We may not be talking about one-time symbolic steps, but about systemic economic and political measures that are not related to the use of military force. Of course, it is possible to prevent Estonian fishing in the Peipsi and Pskov lakes, and limit the movement of Estonian vessels in Russian territorial waters as much as possible," Nikolai Mezhevich told Izvestia.

He considers it necessary to phase out trade, including sectors that are sensitive to the Estonian economy, even if they are niche or consumer goods. Given the disparity in the economic scale of the two countries, such measures, in his opinion, can have a much more painful effect on Tallinn than on Moscow.

According to Nikolai Mezhevich, if such a practice begins to spread to other EU states, it will no longer be about a private national decision, but about the formation of a dangerous precedent that can undermine confidence in the European financial system and reduce the investment attractiveness of the region in the eyes of large foreign investors.

So far, there is no unity in the European Union on the issue of full confiscation. Although Estonia, Lithuania, Latvia, Poland and a number of other countries are actively promoting a hard line, Belgium (where the bulk of sovereign assets are held), Italy and France express serious concerns about legal and financial risks.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast