"The law will set maximum fines for installment payments for housing"
Installments for the purchase of real estate will be regulated by law. Mikhail Mamuta, head of the Consumer Protection Service and a member of the Board of Directors of the Bank of Russia, told Izvestia about this in an interview. According to him, now this mechanism creates risks for consumers — for example, fines for late installment payments can reach half of the total amount owed. In addition, the Central Bank proposed to the Ministry of Finance to double the maximum loan amount for which credit holidays can be obtained — up to 900 thousand rubles. In an exclusive interview with Izvestia, Mikhail Mamuta talks about how the regulator is fighting unfair practices in the financial market.
"The main problem now is the installment plan for real estate"
— Since January 1, 2025, the mortgage standard has been launched in Russia. How well do banks comply with it?
— The standard is aimed at eliminating unfair practices that are not regulated by law. Judging by the dynamics of complaints that we receive, the standard copes with this task. The main thing that he forbids is to give a preferential rate if this leads to an overestimation of the cost of the apartment. Compared to the beginning of the year, complaints about such practices have decreased by about 70%. In addition, we have settled the issue with the sale of a discount on interest due to an advance payment, when it seems that a person is given a discount, but in fact he may pay more than he will benefit. Therefore, we positively evaluate the work of the standard.
— Are there any new formats of violations that require separate regulation?
— The main problem now is the installment plan for real estate. It is popular because of the high mortgage rates — for some developers, up to 30-40% of apartments are sold in installments.
The difficulty is that the installment plan for housing is not regulated at all: there is no transparent disclosure of the cost, apartments remain on the seller's balance sheet until the last moment, and penalties for late installment payments at the stage after the house is put into operation can reach 50% of the total amount owed. In fact, instead of a loan, an installment plan is used with a mortgage.
Together with the government, we plan to regulate the installment market for real estate. It is important that after the house is put into operation, ownership should pass to the buyer, and the developer should have a lien. Information about the debt burden will be transmitted to the BCI, and the terms of the contract and the consequences of the delay will be set out in as much detail as possible and in an understandable form with a payment schedule. The law will also set maximum fines for installment payments for housing. We propose to limit the fine to no more than 20% per annum of the overdue amount, rather than the entire debt.
The bill is currently being finalized jointly with the Ministry of Construction and the Market. The discussion is conducted at a professional level, and we hope that the bill will soon be prepared by government colleagues for submission to the State Duma.
— Earlier, the issue of increasing the maximum loan amount for credit holidays was discussed. When is it planned to adjust the mechanism?
— This issue is within the competence of the Ministry of Finance, but we, for our part, are ready to support the increase and have already sent relevant proposals.
We propose to double the maximum amount of unsecured consumer loans and borrowings — from 450 thousand to 900 thousand rubles. But, for example, for mortgage agreements, the statutory limit of 15 million rubles, which has been in effect since 2019, does not seem to need to be changed.
"There are significantly fewer complaints about toxic violations"
— How does the Central Bank assess the situation with unfair sales of banks? Are there any point-based impairments and in which directions?
— The problem has not completely gone away, but there have been significantly fewer complaints about toxic violations. For example, the number of complaints related to unfair sales by banks decreased by about 14%, and the imposition of additional services in consumer lending — by more than 30%.
Last year, we saw that some banks, including large ones, connect paid services without the consent of customers. We conducted targeted work with the violators — they eliminated these practices and refunded the money to the customers for the connected services.
I would also like to note that since August last year, we have been publishing information on our website about penalties for banks for violations of consumer rights. These publications affect the reputation, and banks try to eliminate violations promptly.
— Are there plans to expand the list of ranking participants based on complaints?
— Now we have rankings on complaints against banks and insurance companies. Microfinance organizations are next in line. We plan to start publishing information about complaints against MFIs in the spring of this year. In addition, we want to combine the complaints ranking from the Bank of Russia and the separate ranking of the financial commissioner into a common one — we will discuss this with the market soon.
— Is it possible to say today that the problem of imposing additional products when issuing loans is still relevant?
— There are no such wild things as before, when, for example, it was impossible to take out a loan without several insurance policies. This was due to the law on the full cost of a loan, which divided additional services into two groups: those that affect the loan parameters and those that do not. Moreover, both of them can be discarded. In principle, there is no compulsory insurance for citizens, except for mortgage collateral insurance. After the adoption of this law, which came into force in 2024, the number of complaints about the imposition fell by half. Last year, it decreased by about a third more.
Good trends are also noticeable in car loans. Here, the number of complaints about the imposition of additional services and non-repayment of money in case of refusal has decreased by almost three times. This happened, among other things, thanks to the Memorandum "On the principles of fair car loans", which the banks themselves developed at the end of 2024. Previously, we received many complaints that people's arms were literally being twisted, forcing them to buy a lot of unnecessary additional products and services on credit along with the car. And now we have an excellent example of how the market itself, without the coercion of the regulator, but with our expert participation, can discipline itself in the interests of the consumer.
— And what forms of imposition are now most often recorded by the Central Bank and how does it react to such cases?
— The forms of imposition that remain on the market can be conditionally divided into two groups: poor-quality consumer information and various tricks in remote sales channels.
In the first case, managers often persuade consumers to buy additional services when consulting, assuring them that they will not receive a loan without it. Today, such violations are not widespread and occur only among individual market participants. We carry out individual supervision work with them. The market listens to us and promptly corrects the shortcomings.
It should be noted that the market itself has become more mature and customer-centric, especially in recent years. But there are still those who still treat customer-centricity as a formality and a convenient slogan, but in fact they only care about their own benefit. So the problem of low-quality sales remains in the focus of our attention.
As for remote channels, gross violations, such as pre—established consents to receive services, have also become rare. Although there are still more subtle practices of "pushing" consumers to make a choice that is beneficial to the seller. We respond promptly to them. And I would also like to draw your attention to the fact that the version of the banking application plays an important role. We have noted cases where the lender has already fixed the problem, but the car dealership remained in older versions of mobile applications. Therefore, we recommended that banks remind customers more often to update mobile applications that have recorded such violations.
— Are there any plans to launch new information standards in remote channels?
— Now more than 70% of loans and almost 90% of deposits are issued online, so the quality of online communication is becoming critical. At the end of 2024, the Bank of Russia issued recommendations on sales in online channels. In 2025, major banks tested them. In continuation of this work, this year the banking associations plan to adopt a Memorandum on remote communication about bank deposits. We are taking an expert part in its development. I can say in advance that if this drags on or the quality of the document is unsatisfactory, we are ready to promptly develop and consolidate key standards at the level of a mandatory banking standard, similar to a mortgage standard.
It will regulate the disclosure of information: It should be complete, understandable and immediately accessible, without the need to collect details on different screens, and the client path in online applications should be transparent.
— Previously, the idea of regulating deposit advertising was discussed. Are there plans to introduce such regulation?
— The discussion with the Federal Antimonopoly Service on this bill is still ongoing.
At the same time, we are working on a draft law that will allow the Bank of Russia to set special requirements for information on websites and in mobile applications. This is done so that the consumer has complete and understandable information about each product, regardless of whether it is an advertisement or not.
"The economic benefit of the bank from violations should be eliminated completely"
— How do you assess the dynamics of complaints about account and card blocking, and what types of restrictions do customers report most often?
— Let's get this straight. Most of the "locks" that customers talk about are temporary restrictions on operations. In other words, access to the money in the client's account is saved and you can use it if you come to the bank in person. The restrictions do not apply to the transfer of wages or social benefits by the bank.
Banks apply such restrictions when there is a victim's appeal due to embezzlement of money or if there is information from law enforcement agencies.
We understand that restrictions create a lot of inconvenience for people and are therefore often perceived negatively. But they help to prevent new thefts on these details.
The problem is that banks have not always clearly explained to customers what the reasons for the restrictions are and what a person should do in this case.
In August, we issued recommendations in which we drew the attention of banks to this. And all the major organizations have changed their communication with customers.: they explain to people the reasons for the so-called blockages and suggest further actions. If we are talking about getting into the database of the Bank of Russia on fraudulent transactions, then everything is quite simple here. The restriction is valid as long as the information about the person is in the database. There are two ways to appeal against the inclusion of banking details: write an application to any of the banks where the person is served, or contact the Bank of Russia via the online reception. We will review it within 15 business days and make a decision.
If we are talking about the limitations of online banking under 115-FZ, then we need to start by interacting with our bank. Perhaps he will have clarifying questions — to whom and why the client was going to transfer money, what is the history of their origin. The questions must be answered. When the bank makes sure that the money is not related to money laundering, the problem will be solved.
As I said, banks should disclose the reason for the restrictions and tell you what to do to lift them. We must insist on this. You may need to submit a written request asking for an explanation of the reason for the blocking. If the bank did not respond or gave an indistinct answer, then you can complain to the Bank of Russia. We will try to understand the situation.
— In 2025, the number of complaints about the formation of long-term savings through NPFs increased by about six times compared to 2024. What exactly are customers complaining about? What problems is the Central Bank currently fixing with the promotion of the PDS?
— I must say that the increase in complaints is largely due to the sharp increase in sales of PDAs, along with which the number of complaints is growing. Moreover, if we compare the volume of sales of CDS and the number of complaints, then we cannot talk about massive violations. But individual sellers are trying to conclude more contracts, including using not entirely honest information. And this, of course, is unacceptable.
What we see from the violations. Firstly, banks often overestimate the amount of government co-financing under the PDS, promising the client more than he will actually receive, and do not fully disclose the terms of early termination. Sometimes a product is presented as more attractive than it actually is. We have already discussed these points with all the major banks and hope that the quality of information when selling CDS will improve soon.
— On December 29, new fines in the amount of 1% of the bank's capital were earned for systematic violations of consumer rights. Tell me, what kind of practices are planned to be suppressed using these measures?
— The law is important not only because it will help, as we hope, to stop the most toxic practices, but also because banks will now take into account the risk of its application when developing new products. This should cool down the hotheads — the bank's economic benefits from violations should be eliminated completely.
New measures will be applied when services are imposed, incorrect information is provided when making deposits, unfair refusals to grant credit holidays and distortion of the value of the UCS. Fines to banks will amount to twice the amount of their illegal profits or damage to the consumer. Thus, all the benefits of unfair practices are completely eliminated. That is, if a violation of 100 million is established, the bank will refund all this income plus 100 million on top.
The regulatory act, which specifies the procedure for application and limits of liability, is planned to be adopted in the first half of 2026.
"A person will receive notifications about applying for a loan through Gosuslugi
— There is a problem of over-creditworthiness in Russia, more than half of the debt is owed by borrowers with three or more loans. What should citizens who are in debt do?
— Now there are a large number of tools on the market to help citizens who find themselves in a difficult life situation. Some are provided for by law — for example, credit holidays, mortgage holidays, while others are offered by lenders themselves — restructuring, refinancing. The situation becomes more complicated when a person has several loans from different banks and MFIs, but there is a solution for such cases today.
Since 2023, the financial market has been operating a Standard for comprehensive debt resolution. The mechanism works as follows: if a person has loans from several financial institutions and he realizes that he cannot cope with them, then he can come to his bank and ask to restructure the debt with all creditors at the same time. The whole procedure takes 30 days — banks and other creditors will agree among themselves to whom and in what order the debtor will pay the debts.
— Is there any plan to refine this mechanism?
— The standard is voluntary, today several dozen creditors have joined it, and there are several hundred of them on the market, including MFIs and collectors, so we believe that it should be mandatory for everyone by law. We participated in the work on the draft law on comprehensive debt settlement, which was adopted by the State Duma in the first reading. He will determine the procedure by which one market participant will be able to arrange the settlement of all client's debts, including from other creditors.
If a person makes a delay and the creditor demands to repay the debt, then first he will have to offer the person to use a comprehensive debt settlement. In simple terms, the borrower will not need to run through all the lenders and negotiate with each one separately. It is enough to "knock" on the one who notified about the right to a comprehensive settlement, and this creditor will already have to contact the others and organize the entire procedure. Of course, this option is much simpler and much less expensive for a person.
Communication between lenders will be provided through the Bureau of Credit Histories (BCI). If they violate the procedure for conducting a comprehensive debt settlement, a person will be able to contact the financial commissioner.
— What other initiatives are you planning to develop this year?
— The first initiative concerns the unified portal of public services, EPSU. It provides that a person will receive notifications about applying for a loan through Gosuslugi. This will make it possible to react quickly if a loan or loan was issued without his knowledge or a person decides to cancel it during the cooling-off period prescribed by law (from 4 to 48 hours, depending on the amount borrowed), without paying any penalties.
Another initiative that we are discussing with the Ministry of Justice concerns the notary's executive inscription. The procedure itself is simple and quite convenient. In retail lending, it is used very often, effectively replacing a court order. If the borrower agrees in advance to the out-of-court collection of overdue debt, the lender can collect the delay through bailiffs without going to court.
How it works: the bank transmits the enforcement document to the bailiffs, they receive information about the debtor's account balances and can write them off to repay the debt. But the problem is that many people agree to the procedure without understanding its subtleties, if they have not encountered it before. Together with the Ministry of Justice and the Federal Notary Chamber, we propose to make this practice more transparent.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»