- Статьи
- Economy
- Claim factors: The Russian Federation refused to repay the debts of the United States on the "royal" bonds
Claim factors: The Russian Federation refused to repay the debts of the United States on the "royal" bonds
The Prosecutor General's Office of the Russian Federation asked the American court to dismiss the claim for payment of tsarist debts, Izvestia found out. The department considers the claims unfounded: Russia does not recognize itself as the legal successor of the Russian Empire. Earlier, the Noble Capital RSD investment fund demanded to recover $225 billion (17 trillion rubles) from our country for pre-revolutionary obligations and offered to settle with frozen Russian assets, although there are less than $5 billion (about 400 billion rubles) in the United States. Which states themselves remain indebted to Russia according to historical accounts — in the material of Izvestia.
Russia's response to the claim of "royal" debts
The Prosecutor General's Office has sent petitions to the District Court of the District of Columbia with a request to dismiss the claim for debts from pre-revolutionary Russia. The American court does not have the authority to consider the dispute in accordance with the US Law on the Immunity of Foreign States. This was reported in the department, responding to a corresponding request from Izvestia.
In mid—January, it became known that the Noble Capital RSD investment fund appealed to the US federal court and stated that the Russian Federation is the legal successor of the Russian Empire and must repay its debt in the amount of $225 billion (about 17 trillion rubles at the exchange rate of the Central Bank 76 rubles /$ as of January 30). The amount is enormous: it accounts for almost half of the expected Russian revenues in 2026. On January 30, the fund refused to withdraw its claim.
The organization identified itself as the rightful owner of $25 million in bonds with a 5.5% coupon placed through the National City Bank of New York. They noted that the obligations to private investors have not been terminated (despite the USSR's refusal of external debt in 1918), and the Russian Federation allegedly inherited them. At the same time, the fund stressed in the document that in some cases, Russia paid debts to foreign holders on imperial loans, but not to citizens of the United States.
Russia does not recognize the right of the US court to force it to pay royal debts and protects its immunity, explained Sergey Kobelev, a lawyer, a member of the Moscow City Bar Association and the Union of Lawyers and Bloggers at the Moscow State Law Institute and the AYUR. That is, a country has the right not to be a defendant in the courts of other countries without its own consent.
The Prosecutor General's Office stressed that the Russian Federation, as a sovereign state, has judicial immunity, therefore such claims are legally untenable.
Why the US lawsuit is unfounded
Our country has never recognized its obligations to the debts of the Russian Empire and has not confirmed its readiness to pay them, said Sergey Glandin, partner at the practice of Compliance and Sanctions Law.
— The plaintiff has no legal grounds to involve a sovereign state in proceedings in an American court, as well as evidence that the debt was ever recognized. That is why the Prosecutor General's Office considers the claim unfounded: the state can act as a defendant in a foreign court only with its own consent, which Russia has not officially given," the lawyer stressed.
All loans to the Russian Empire were abolished back in 1918, said Ekaterina Kosareva, Managing partner of the VMT Consult agency. She added: at the same time, the Russian Federation acts as the legal successor of the Soviet Union, which is fixed in the Constitution. And all the limitation periods in such a case have already expired decades ago, lawyer Sergey Kobelev added.
The Noble Capital RSD fund appeared back in 2002, and was not particularly prominent before the news of the lawsuit against our country. In addition, the organization was not the original holder of the bonds, even if it acquired these securities on the free market later, Ekaterina Kosareva clarified. So, probably, such a statement of claim is another attempt to find a lever of pressure on Russia in the context of the current international agenda, says Ekaterina Nikitina, a practicing lawyer, member of the Union of Bloggers Lawyers and the Association of Lawyers of Russia.
Western countries themselves have obligations to Moscow. In historical practice, there are several cases when the Russian Empire forgave them, rather than demanding their return. For example, under the terms of the Treaty of Paris on May 30, 1814, the allies, including the Russian Empire, concluded peace with France on relatively lenient terms.: no indemnity was collected.
In addition, examples include the period of the Russian Civil War (1918-1922). Then control over the country's gold reserves (before the First World War, its volume was more than 1.6 billion rubles in precious metals) was lost — some fell into the hands of the White Army, and the other ended up abroad, in particular, in England. However, not all the gold returned to the central vault of Russia.
Will the Russian Federation be able to return the frozen assets
The Noble Capital RSD Foundation believes that tsarist-era debt can be repaid through frozen Russian assets. Their total volume is estimated at over $315 billion, with $216 billion held in Belgium's Euroclear, $32 billion in Japan, and $26 billion in France. Only about $5 billion (over 380 billion rubles) in the United States. That is, this amount is not comparable with what Noble Capital RSD expects to receive from the Russian Federation.
The logic of the organization is simple — since Russia's assets in the United States have already been frozen by sanctions, it is very convenient to obtain a court decision that will allow to satisfy the "historical debt" at their expense, said lawyer Sergei Kobelev. However, attempts to use centralized state reserves to enforce court decisions are fraught with serious risks, said Alexander Abramov, head of the Laboratory for the Analysis of Institutions and Financial Markets at the Presidential Academy.
This approach undermines confidence not only in the depository infrastructure, but also in the currencies of the countries in whose jurisdiction these assets are located, creating long-term threats to financial stability, he added.
At the same time, on January 21, President Vladimir Putin announced that Moscow was negotiating with Washington on the possible use of part of the Russian funds frozen in the United States to restore territories affected by the Ukrainian conflict. The Russian leader also indicated the country's willingness to allocate $1 billion of these assets to the initiatives of the Peace Council, which should deal with the settlement and prevention of international conflicts. According to presidential spokesman Dmitry Peskov, discussion of such steps is possible only if a number of conditions are met by the United States.
Nevertheless, Russia can still return its assets, but it is very difficult to do so. This is due to the fact that there has not yet been a legal mechanism for blocking and returning them in world practice, says Natalia Milchakova, a leading analyst at Freedom Finance Global.
In addition, according to Sergei Kobelev, the prospect of a real return of all assets in the foreseeable future is not so much related to the claim for "royal" debts, but rather to the political outcome of the conflict in Ukraine and future interstate agreements.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»