Revenue reserve: Auditors found 1.5 trillion hidden budget reserves
The budget may receive an additional 1.5 trillion rubles in 2026-2028, follows from the conclusion of the Accounting Chamber on the draft financial plan (Izvestia has reviewed it). The sources of reserves will be VAT, customs duties and privatization. The fact is that the budget does not take into account the cancellation of benefits for acquiring, bank card transactions and the transfer of rights to databases. At the same time, the auditors warn of the risks of shortfalls of 272 billion due to possible shortfalls in income taxes and gas duties. How hidden reserves can affect the treasury deficit is in the Izvestia article.
What can bring additional revenue to the budget?
In the next three years, the budget may receive an additional 546 billion, 587 billion and 665 billion rubles, respectively, for a total of about 1.8 trillion. This revenue potential was identified by the Accounting Chamber (JV) in its conclusion on the draft financial plan (the document was studied by Izvestia). At the same time, the auditors recorded shortfall risks of 118 billion, 73 billion and 81 billion, totaling 272 billion. Taking these losses into account, the revenue reserve is estimated at about 1.5 trillion: 428 billion in 2026, 514 billion in 2027 and 584 billion in 2028. At the same time, in the last draft budget (for 2025-2027), the joint venture discovered reserves 11 times less — 136 billion. The editorial board sent a request to the control body.
The budget revenue forecast takes into account key legislative changes aimed at revenue growth, including indirect effects, the press service of the Ministry of Finance told Izvestia. It also includes measures to increase tax collection and takes into account current trends in the main types of revenue. If during the execution of the budget revenues turn out to be higher than forecast, these funds will be distributed according to the established rules, the department added.
The main source of additional revenue will be the value added tax (VAT), which in three years could bring in $1.7 trillion to the planned $38 trillion. According to the auditors, the forecast of the Ministry of Finance does not take into account the planned cancellation of a number of VAT benefits. Now the collection will extend to the operations of companies that transfer and process data for bank card payments (processing and acquiring). We are also talking about transactions for the sale of exclusive rights to programs for electronic computers and databases included in the Unified Register of Russian Software — the tax will be included in them.
In addition, it is planned to cancel the VAT exemption for servicing bank cards (for example, issuance, delivery and commission services). It was introduced in 2006 to stimulate the development of cashless payments. Due to this, the expenses of market participants were not taxed, which reduced the cost of servicing transactions. The joint venture clarifies that the cancellation of the benefit will provide additional revenue to the budget, however, due to the lack of accurate data, it is currently impossible to assess the effect.
Another 52 billion rubles may come from the excise tax on liquid steel. The draft budget contains a smaller amount than in the forecast of the Federal Tax Service, due to a different approach to calculating the rate, the Court of Auditors said in its conclusion. Taking into account the tax assessment, an income reserve is formed.
Customs duties can also provide an additional 35 billion. According to the auditors, the calculations in the draft budget are based on projected export and import volumes, weighted average payment rates and the dollar exchange rate indicated in the forecast of the Ministry of Economy. However, the figures included in the financial plan do not match the assessment of the Federal Customs Service. If we take into account the forecast of the service, then there is a reserve of such income.
Plus, the budget can receive 452 million rubles from the privatization of non-financial assets. Currently, according to this article, the project includes only about 5 billion over three years. According to the joint venture, when calculating the forecast, some of the objects scheduled for sale were not taken into account.
- 1.5 trillion over three years, or an average of 500 billion per year, is not much in terms of the total budget size. For example, in relation to the average annual income, this is only 1.2%. But it is comparable to the total amount of federal treasury spending for 2026 on culture and cinematography (306 billion), mass media (146 billion), physical education and sports (75 billion rubles)," estimated Olga Belenkaya, head of the Macroeconomic analysis department at Finam.
Additional income will help reduce the budget deficit, says Fyodor Sidorov, founder of the School of Practical Investment. It is planned to reach 3.8 trillion rubles in 2026, and about 10.5 trillion in three years. The 1.5 trillion reserve will reduce the gap by about 14%. At the same time, even the current shortage parameters are considered safe for the economy — about 1.5% of GDP, which ensures financial stability.
By what income is the plan overstated
At the same time, as noted earlier, there are risks of shortfalls in the amount of 272 billion rubles. The main part is related to income tax, which can give 74 billion less than the planned 13 trillion over three years. The auditors consider the estimated collection rate of 99% to be overestimated. For comparison, by the end of 2023, it was 89%, in 2024 - 98%, and in July 2025 - 93%.
— The risks of income tax shortfalls are associated with a deterioration in the financial results of enterprises. Metallurgy is on the verge of a technical recession this year, shipping volumes are declining, and the situation in the coal industry is unstable. Falling prices for raw materials and services, a strong ruble and high interest rates are putting pressure on profits," explained Natalia Milchakova, a leading analyst at Freedom Finance Global.
The plan may not be fulfilled for the export duty on gas — minus 68 billion from the planned 1.7 trillion over three years. There is no algorithm for calculating the weighted average export price in the budget materials, so the joint venture made its own forecast based on the Ministry of Energy's assessment of exports and the cost of raw materials. This is also influenced by prices on world markets and export volumes, which remain unstable, investor Fyodor Sidorov added.
There may also be a shortfall of 55 billion in customs duties paid by individuals. According to the auditors, the FCS has included in the forecast a smaller number of imported cars than indicated in the budget, based on statistics from previous years and quarterly dynamics. In addition, the calculations used a dollar exchange rate that differs from the forecast of the Ministry of Economic Development, which also increases the risk of shortfalls.
Another notable item of possible losses are dividends and income from shares in the authorized capitals of companies. According to the auditors, the shortfall may amount to about 50 billion of the planned 1 trillion. This is due to the peculiarities of determining the billing period for the payment of dividends by one of the largest companies.
The risks of income loss indicated by the Accounting Chamber are justified, says Vladimir Klimanov, director of the IPEI Regional Policy Center at the Presidential Academy. Geopolitical tensions persist, costs remain high, and there are few opportunities for revenue growth.
Additional uncertainty is created by external factors — a possible global recession due to the conflict between the United States and China, falling energy prices and sanctions. Income from income taxes and customs duties looks to be the most vulnerable. However, some of the losses, according to the expert, can be compensated by additional income from other items.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»