- Статьи
- Economy
- Construction with a minus: regions inefficiently spent budget loans on infrastructure
Construction with a minus: regions inefficiently spent budget loans on infrastructure
Some regions have not achieved their goals in projects that they finance with infrastructure budget loans, the Accounting Chamber notes. In total, they were allocated 365 billion rubles, half of the amount of loans allocated to all subjects. But in 32 of them, it was not possible to receive the expected income, and in 45, the built housing was not put into operation on time. The problems are weak control, lack of responsibility, and possible abuse. Auditors warn that this jeopardizes the return of funds to the state, which means it can hit the budget system. How they will be punished for violating the conditions is in the Izvestia article.
How many loans were given to the regions for infrastructure
From 2021 to 2024, the regions received budget infrastructure loans from the government for 678 billion rubles. In the second half of 2025, they decided to add loans for another 300 billion, according to the July report of the Accounting Chamber (JV) on the effectiveness of expenditures on the development of subjects (Izvestia has it). Such loans are issued for 15 years at 3%, repayment begins from the third year. The money is mainly allocated for construction, capital repairs, housing and communal services and transport.
The auditors note that in 32 regions, plans for revenue from the launch of infrastructure projects at the expense of budget loans have not been fulfilled. The joint venture Izvestia clarified that over four years they have been allocated loans for 365 billion rubles. They added that among the subjects with the lowest level of revenues to the treasury are the Novosibirsk, Jewish Autonomous, Astrakhan and Saratov regions, as well as the Republic of Buryatia. The editorial board sent a request to the specified regions.
In addition, of the 68 regions where housing has been planned over the past four years, 45 indicators turned out to be lower than expected (the joint venture does not specify which ones). Moreover, in 10 of them, not a single square meter has been commissioned in several years. According to the plan, most of the houses are planned to be built with loans in the Krasnodar Territory, Tatarstan and Bashkortostan. Least of all — in Sevastopol, Karachay-Cherkessia and the Jewish Autonomous Region.
The regions regularly adjust the goals in the contractual plans — they make changes several times a year. For example, the Tambov Region lowered its revenue forecast from the development project of the Telecentre microdistrict by several million rubles, according to the joint venture report. Deadlines are also not being met: in the Astrakhan region, out of four municipal water supply facilities, one was completed with an eight-month delay, two were not commissioned on time and were only half ready by the beginning of 2025, although the deadline passed back in 2024.
If the regions do not achieve the stated results, there is a growing risk that they will not be able to repay infrastructure loans and pay interest on time, the Accounting Chamber warns. All this can have a negative impact on the budget system. In addition, delays and postponement of deadlines for the completion of facilities lead to an increase in the cost of construction, the auditors note.
The Finance Ministry told Izvestia that they did not see any risks of non-repayment of loans. The ministry added that most regions are fulfilling their obligations in a disciplined manner.
The Accounts Chamber's claims to infrastructure loans
There are problems in the mechanism of infrastructure loans itself, the joint venture notes. Firstly, there are no clear criteria and procedures for selecting projects at the regional level. Secondly, their authorities are not responsible for the failure of goals or underestimated indicators, which makes agreements on budget loans a formality.
Thirdly, it is possible to review contracts frequently, which reduces work discipline. Finally, housing plans are often established in projects, even if they do not involve the construction of houses. For example, according to the project in Arkhangelsk, where 12 gas buses are being purchased, it is planned to build 56 thousand square meters of housing by 2027.
To reduce risks, the Accounting Chamber recommended that the Ministry of Finance take into account the identified problems when developing rules for a new similar instrument — treasury infrastructure loans.
As explained by the Territorial Development Fund (their comment is attached to the joint venture report), Treasury infrastructure loans already have penalties for violating the terms — the interest rate in this case increases from 3% to 6%. In addition, when allocating funds through the competition, the region's experience in previous projects with infrastructure loans will be taken into account.
The Ministry of Finance informed the editorial board that it plans to issue 250 billion treasury loans in 2025.
What threatens the regions for disrupting the indicators
Infrastructure loans are an important tool for supporting regions that would not be able to implement major projects at their own expense, explained Dmitry Zemlyansky, Director of the Center for Spatial Analysis and Regional Diagnostics at the IPEI Presidential Academy. In particular, he cited the example of the construction of a subway in Nizhny Novgorod. In total, infrastructure budget loans affected the commissioning of 27.6 million square meters. m housing.
At the same time, according to the expert, the regions used loans in different ways. Some have allocated funds for the comprehensive modernization of public infrastructure or the renovation of transport, which has directly improved the quality of life of people. Others have invested money in new neighborhoods. But in such cases, the social effect is not always obvious: projects can simply reduce the cost of construction and benefit individual developers, Dmitry Zemlyansky emphasized.
One of the reasons for the contract failures was that most projects with infrastructure budget loans began in 2022, at the height of sanctions pressure and a sharp rise in prices for building materials, the expert believes.
Another reason for the failure of the targets is the complication of the economy of housing and infrastructure construction, explained Candidate of Economics Andrei Barkhota. According to him, due to rising prices for materials and labor, operating expenses have increased. As a result, the amounts included in the estimates turned out to be underestimated and projects began to go beyond the budget, which led to a delay in deadlines. He also noted that financial abuses by regional authorities are also possible, but against the background of inflation they are difficult to identify — they are literally masked among the total costs.
— First of all, residents of the regions themselves, for whom these facilities should be built, suffer from the failure of goals and inefficient use of infrastructure loans. In addition, it reduces the investment and tourist attractiveness of territories, especially if, for example, the quality of roads does not improve for a long time," said Natalia Milchakova, a leading analyst at Freedom Finance Global.
The most serious sanction for the failure of the announced results is the restriction of access to new tranches, Andrei Barkhota noted. A region that violates the terms may lose some of its future funding. On a broader scale, this will lead to a reduction in costs and investment programs, which will slow down the growth of key socio-economic indicators. The expert believes that in order to increase financial discipline, it is worthwhile to introduce administrative liability for violations of deadlines for the completion of facilities.
In the future, treasury loans may prove to be more effective than infrastructure loans, Natalia Milchakova believes. However, in her opinion, some regions will still not meet the targets. She also admits that in the future such loans may be issued in digital rubles — this will simplify control over the movement of funds and help to understand exactly where the money went and why the goals were not achieved. In addition, the role of law enforcement agencies in monitoring the implementation of such projects may be strengthened.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»